old git
Tremendous Bore
- Messages
- 4,008
What about letting the scales drop away from your eyes? ;}
What about letting the scales drop away from your eyes? ;}
What about letting the scales drop away from your eyes? ;}
. From being lazy to inciting anarchy.🙂)) Not bad for one question from a sax beginner. I nearly forgot an author of horror novels as well🙂)). Really guys I know some of you have been years learning the traditional methods for jazz improv.I will drop one name in to the mix for some of you that might be interested " Ed Byrne"
jazz author and jazz educator, (If memory serves me right a member on the AJJ forum.) He teaches a method very similar to the one I have been talking about.

lets do the sums, 12 keys, 48 arpeggios, 5 outside notes per Key.

( and that doesn't count Blues scale)
Hey you still have to play all the arps and all the Keys. Maybe the terminology changes but the music doesn't.lets do the sums, 12 keys, 48 arpeggios, 5 outside notes per Key.
or 12 maj scales, 36 minor scales( nat, har, mel) and 7 modes per scale. How complex is that?? 336 scales, from 12 notes.
...add in #4 and you have all the notes of a Blues scale too..! Although the #7 becomes the #4 in the subdominant key...!?For the easy part if you are into jazz and the use melodic minor for improv. Think on this C melodic minor is the same as Cmaj but with a b3rd.So instead of learning another scale just learn how to use the Eb when using the Key of C. That works for all 12 melodic minor scales. Why because the #6,#7 bring those notes into major tonality, leaving just the b3rd. If we play classical music then it wouldn't work as you know in classical theory the those notes are lowered, on the descending scale.

It's not about being right or wrong, winning a debate on a forum, or who knows the most theory, or who can make the most sarcastic post. It is about making music, if that can be made easier then what is wrong with that.
Lazy!!!Hey you still have to play all the arps and all the Keys. Maybe the terminology changes but the music doesn't.
I'm still not really sure what you're getting at.
I say 'learn minor scales' - you say 'learn major scales with a b3'. Is there a difference?
Nick, Well yes there is you don't have to learn another scale, Learn C melodic minor as a scale, or learn how to use the Eb with the key of C. Sound wise there is no difference but like I said which is easier, lots of scales or 12 keys. At the end of the day, use your time learning scales or use your time learning 12 Keys and how to improv.
It is just an simpler way of doing the same thing.Shortcut!!! No!! just easier.
:shocked:
Why all the head work trying to justify not learning scales and arpeggios? If you spent half the energy you use thinking about ways to avoid it, you'd know most of them by now!
