Playing the saxophone If you thought "Scales" was good!!!

Such a outcry!!!>:). From being lazy to inciting anarchy.🙂)) Not bad for one question from a sax beginner. I nearly forgot an author of horror novels as well🙂)). Really guys I know some of you have been years learning the traditional methods for jazz improv.I will drop one name in to the mix for some of you that might be interested " Ed Byrne":mrcool jazz author and jazz educator, (If memory serves me right a member on the AJJ forum.) He teaches a method very similar to the one I have been talking about.

Some of you said what about minor tonalities etc. If you play from the key centre of the chord or chord tone you will not play a wrong note.😀 The chord you play over colours the line you play:thumb:, thats not something I made up or something off a match box, just a simple fact. Minor chord progression colours the lines you play minor:thumb:, major chord progression colour the lines Maj.:thumb:

Some have said it is too complex,:confused::confused::confused: lets do the sums, 12 keys, 48 arpeggios, 5 outside notes per Key.:thumb:

or 12 maj scales, 36 minor scales( nat, har, mel) and 7 modes per scale. How complex is that?? 336 scales, from 12 notes.:confused::confused::w00t:( and that doesn't count Blues scale)

For the easy part if you are into jazz and the use melodic minor for improv. Think on this C melodic minor is the same as Cmaj but with a b3rd.:thumb: So instead of learning another scale just learn how to use the Eb when using the Key of C. That works for all 12 melodic minor scales. Why because the #6,#7 bring those notes into major tonality, leaving just the b3rd. If we play classical music then it wouldn't work as you know in classical theory the those notes are lowered, on the descending scale.

It's not about being right or wrong, winning a debate on a forum, or who knows the most theory, or who can make the most sarcastic post. It is about making music, if that can be made easier then what is wrong with that.

Lazy!!!:w00t: Hey you still have to play all the arps and all the Keys. Maybe the terminology changes but the music doesn't.
 
lets do the sums, 12 keys, 48 arpeggios, 5 outside notes per Key.:thumb:

or 12 maj scales, 36 minor scales( nat, har, mel) and 7 modes per scale. How complex is that?? 336 scales, from 12 notes.

I once heard that James Morrison (Aussie multi-instrumentalist and insomniac) was told to learn all the scales at an early stage by a tutor. He decided he didn't need to because he would just learn all the tunes instead! Since he doesn't really sleep he has the time to do this, but I think it's quicker and simpler to learn scales instead.
336 (or however many!) versus thousands seems pretty simple.

For the easy part if you are into jazz and the use melodic minor for improv. Think on this C melodic minor is the same as Cmaj but with a b3rd.:thumb: So instead of learning another scale just learn how to use the Eb when using the Key of C. That works for all 12 melodic minor scales. Why because the #6,#7 bring those notes into major tonality, leaving just the b3rd. If we play classical music then it wouldn't work as you know in classical theory the those notes are lowered, on the descending scale.
...add in #4 and you have all the notes of a Blues scale too..! Although the #7 becomes the #4 in the subdominant key...!?:confused:

It's not about being right or wrong, winning a debate on a forum, or who knows the most theory, or who can make the most sarcastic post. It is about making music, if that can be made easier then what is wrong with that.

Lazy!!!:w00t: Hey you still have to play all the arps and all the Keys. Maybe the terminology changes but the music doesn't.

That is true. There are only about 33 tones to get to grips with on a sax till you get Altissimo, and the quickest way to learn all the combinations of these in all the patterns you could require will depend on the player. Some will learn it better in the ABRSM pattern of scales and modes etc, others might prefer key centres (that's the way Guildhall do their jazz exams, isn't it?). The real problem is that it's difficult to know the best way for you until you've tried all the different ways. Which is where a personal tutor comes in...? Most teachers teach in the way they learnt themselves, which is no bad thing, but this thread is making me think I need to do some more personal study on all these different methods so that I can recommend the correct one!

Thanks for an interesting read guys.

Nick
 
I'm still not really sure what you're getting at.

I say 'learn minor scales' - you say 'learn major scales with a b3'. Is there a difference?

Nick, Well yes there is you don't have to learn another scale, Learn C melodic minor as a scale, or learn how to use the Eb with the key of C. Sound wise there is no difference but like I said which is easier, lots of scales or 12 keys. At the end of the day, use your time learning scales or use your time learning 12 Keys and how to improv.
It is just an simpler way of doing the same thing.Shortcut!!! No!! just easier.
 
Nick, Well yes there is you don't have to learn another scale, Learn C melodic minor as a scale, or learn how to use the Eb with the key of C. Sound wise there is no difference but like I said which is easier, lots of scales or 12 keys. At the end of the day, use your time learning scales or use your time learning 12 Keys and how to improv.
It is just an simpler way of doing the same thing.Shortcut!!! No!! just easier.

Excuse me, but this is doing my head in reading this .... to be honest I think you're a bit confused about what a teacher has told you, and it's now coming out as complete nonsense.
You're saying learn to use Eb in the key of C - what does that mean? Do you mean play a C major scale with an added Eb over a C minor chord, well if the E natural is there as well it's just gonna clash. The interval needs to be a minor 3rd ie Eb so it sounds minor, and fits correctly with the chord underneath. Then you have a scale, where the 3rd note is flattened a semi-tone compared to the major scale, forming a new scale, in this instance, called the melodic minor. This principle is centuries old. What's the problem, just learn it, and move on. Honestly!!!
And you can't get by on just 12 keys, this notion is idiotic. When someone you're playing with asks what key that piece of music is in that you're playing, and you say C major, but the 3rd note is flattened etc etc, they'll pause, think for a minute, and reply "you mean C minor" and if you start to argue and tell them different, they're just gonna think you stupid.
I know you said you're a beginner, and if my post is upsetting in any way, well it's been a long week, and it's not meant that way, it's just that this is a public forum, and people should be able to jump in and try and steer someone straight when they appear to be going off on one.
 
Why all the head work trying to justify not learning scales and arpeggios? If you spent half the energy you use thinking about ways to avoid it, you'd know most of them by now!
 
God I’ve missed the crazy banter :w00t::shocked::confused:>:)

While I was hiatus I spent many hours working on my theory. It’s helped me grow as a musician. Learning scales and arpeggios is the basis to music. Each scale has its own voice and allows you to communicate to those listening. If you play a composition in a minor key it enables you to express in a more emotional way than you would by playing in a major key. Playing a major key sounds brighter, happier so to speak.

I also firmly believe that learning scales and arpeggios enables you to stop being a slave to the dots allowing you to be free to improvise and grow. :thumb:
 
Just a question to Chris: have you already learned Blues scales?

If so, did you get them by thinking of flattening/raising/deleting certain tones from the major? I don't think so...
See, blues scales in particular are so colorful and instinctive that you would miss the feel of them if you waste even a split nanosecond in filtering them from a major scale. Just do the decent thing please and learn them the "hard way".

Then to give Chris a bit of encouragement:
I'm for finding as many links as possible...so both arguments are right in the end.
Learning scales the "hard way" or trying to dodge them altering 3rds or 6ths or 7ths (or else) are both useful ways of looking them from a different perspective.
I don't think altering certain degrees of a major scale by a semitone up or down worked for me - so I don't think that way anymore and I'm actually enjoy spending whole sessions playing and improvising on rather unusual scales....exploring them is like landing on another planet...I don't fret them anymore.
 
Why all the head work trying to justify not learning scales and arpeggios? If you spent half the energy you use thinking about ways to avoid it, you'd know most of them by now!

Truly. I've just created a rather extensive "scale study program" as part of my practice routine and I'm actually enjoying that quite a bit. It's has lots of benefits.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom