Saxophones How soon is TOO soon to want a second sax? :D

I'm sure the 2 baritones are the reason I've got 4 sopranos.

A well balanced inventory is key! 😛

But as many have said, at an early stage, it's best to stick with one for a while and not get yourself too distracted. So if you fancy a tenor, go for it but switch to it for several months before you start mixing. Going back to alto was really awkward for me recently.

I can't blame anyone for being tempted... I have 15 horns (3S, 6A, 5T, 1B, 1U) ... Not all in playing condition though. 😳
 
If you fancy a tenor, I'd say give it a go. If you buy used and look after it, you should get your money back when you sell it if it doesn't work out. There are lots of people who say you have to stick with one sax, pay your dues or whatever, but in my mind, music is for fun and if you fancy trying something and can afford it, give it a go. I'm not very big on 'thou shalt not' - I'm more 'oh yes I ******* shall'!
 
We want a tenor because it's the most saxophone looking saxophone. Great range if you get fluent with altissimo. Flexible tone and applications. Easier transpositions. Anybody holding a tenor looks cool. Tenor is king. However...alto is a democrat, Baritone is boss and soprano is above it all.

I added baritone to alto quite early on without difficulty, for me any way. The neighbours might have a different opinion. I struggled on and off with tenor for many years. Ears locked into Eb I suppose. Once I made a concerted effort to add tenor and found a mouthpiece I liked, it all fell into place.

Practice as always is the key. Clarinet helps too and you'll need a soprano and there's the Bb bass and the Eb contra bass and the Bb sub contra bass and those little ones are cute, sopranino and soprillo. Oh! and there's the one in between alto and tenor , the melody C and who wouldn't want a Xaphoon or make your own carrot clarinet.

If you have any tendencies to collecting or hoarding it might be best to stick to one. 😉
 
I started on tenor, then I got a bari without experiencing any serious problems, but alto was a real struggle for me - it has taken me 18 months to get used to it. It didn't help that it took me a while to find an alto instrument that I was comfortable with. But for me, blowing an alto and blowing a tenor feel very different.

If you are going to learn to play both, then you will need to spend a bit more more time practicing that if you just play one.
 
Thank you for all your replies ..both the funny ones and the sensible!
I like the car analogy, and that makes perfect sense to me. I would very much like to try out a tenor..just to see how it feels in my hand (indeed , whether I could manage one) but I will hold back ... 🙂

Now if anyone can tell me how to stop guitars breeding... we have rather a lot of amorous Yamaha's here...
 
I always remember at Wayne Shorter, playing his original student tenor until Miles Davis told him iwas time to get a new sax...
If you start few month ago (and you can play in a decent way stuff like "Take 5" or any bossa nova), go for it... if not, I would suggest you stick with your tenor until you manage the instrument a little more..
Now if you can afford it.. go for it!!! 😉
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,516
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom