Playing the saxophone How much mouthpiece to take in

...given the slightly different dimensions of the mpcs I have had to adjust how much I put in my mouth.
I'm not sure that is necessarily a necessity. For me the amount of mouthpiece is based on sound, flexibilty and tone - not on mouthpiece dimensions.
 
Good luck playing baritone with a tiny bit of mp / reed in your mush !
I actually use very little on baritone. Especially compared with the length of the beak. I don't know why. Well I do know why, because I get the best control over sound.
 
cappers said:
...given the slightly different dimensions of the mpcs I have had to adjust how much I put in my mouth.
I'm not sure that is necessarily a necessity. For me the amount of mouthpiece is based on sound, flexibilty and tone - not on mouthpiece dimensions.
I am not going to argue with somebody far more experienced in sax playing, but for me the best sound, flexibility and tone with the Selmer is slightly further in my mouth than the 5C. I put that down to the differences in the tip openings and lay lengths.

It's only a few mm, just to position my lower lip close to the breakpoint. I didn't think that would be contentious!
 
cappers said:
...given the slightly different dimensions of the mpcs I have had to adjust how much I put in my mouth.

I am not going to argue with somebody far more experienced in sax playing, but for me the best sound, flexibility and tone with the Selmer is slightly further in my mouth than the 5C. I put that down to the differences in the tip openings and lay lengths.

It's only a few mm, just to position my lower lip close to the breakpoint. I didn't think that would be contentious!
No it isn't, I just tend to think in terms of sound and response. But what you say re: length of lay makes perfect sense.
 
I have no idea how much I take in. I've spent many hundreds of hours doing long tones and interval exercises, from pppp to ffff and back again, and whatever works, is what I've trained with, and that's what I do.

(Sure, I could measure the tooth marks, but I see no value in doing that. Just like I know where to reach for the clutch and brake, just like I know how to eat with a fork without poking myself in the eye, I know how to address a saxophone mouthpiece to get the best results for me.)

So, do that, and you won't need to worry about measurements. For some, less MP in the mouth will be the answer; for others, more will be the answer.
 
I actually use very little on baritone. Especially compared with the length of the beak. I don't know why. Well I do know why, because I get the best control over sound.
It's whatever works for the individual really of course, for me I need to have a fair bit, again all our set ups are likely very different too, plus we are no doubt aiming at a variety of different 'sounds'
 
It’s worth trying different things occasionally. It took me a couple years on tenor to figure out to take more in, I was relying on my alto instincts. Of course I was playing alto way more often, which is why it was years instead of months. I had to decide to dedicate a fair amount of time to practicing it.

I think dialing in my tenor sound improved my alto playing too. I merely re-applied the ideas of sound production I had on tenor to the smaller horn.

I agree with Pete that the “right” position depends on a lot of things, and that really you need to use sound and response as your guide, and don’t worry about so called rules or “best” practices. But certainly it’s worthwhile trying things, you may learn something.
 
For some, less MP in the mouth will be the answer; for others, more will be the answer.
Yes this. But if you find that less in your mouth (but not a ridiculously small amount) causes the muffled small sound, this suggests to me an embouchure that has too much lip curled over the teeth and some biting ie closing the reed against the facing.
 
Yes this. But if you find that less in your mouth (but not a ridiculously small amount) causes the muffled small sound, this suggests to me an embouchure that has too much lip curled over the teeth and some biting ie closing the reed against the facing.
I've been experimenting more to find the sweet spot. My teacher is of the 'bottom lip over teeth' school but I find the 'lower lip cushioned against teeth' works better for me.
I consciously aim not to bite or put too much pressure on the reed and I find 'teeth-over' produces more pressure than a 'cushion lip'.

I don't want this to turn into another long winded debate so I'll leave it at that.
When I see my teacher next month he will advise appropriately.
 
My teacher is of the 'bottom lip over teeth' school but I find the 'lower lip cushioned against teeth' works better for me.
Hopefully your teacher is also of the school that accepts what works for the student is a good way to go, rather than imposing a strict discipline.
I consciously aim not to bite or put too much pressure on the reed
It’s funny, for a long time it thought it was good to put as much pressure on the reed as possible and blow as hard as possible. I don’t think that now but some of the people I worked for seemed to like it.
 
Now it's a LIP thread? 😜
ZEN says, do you put the mouthpiece in your mouth, or your mouth on the mouthpiece.

Long night, waiting for the hardware store to open at 6am DST.
Cannot find four 10/32"x 1" pan head machine screws, to finish making a 45 degree bevel fixture, for the Mill and the Belt Sanders.
Earl Gray is brewed, 🥳
Sailors, never miss a Sunrise. 💛
Best to work at night, temp is about 78 degrees and 80 plus during the day. Epoxy layup time is adequate, in the large tool shop.
Inside of house is kept at 78.
 
Earl Gray is brewed, 🥳
Earl Grey old chap! Charles Grey, 2nd Earl Grey, UK Prime Minister 1830-34.
1755855050644.webp

His connection with bergamot flavoured tea is dubious since it was considered an adulterant to improve the taste of poor quality tea.
Grey's government also enacted voting reforms enlarging the franchise and the Slavery Abolition Act 1833, which outlawed the practice of slavery in the British Empire.
 
I think how much to take in depends on the length of the facing curve, so it'll be different for different mouthpieces. There's a "sweet spot" on each piece that balances control and projection. If you position your embouchure too far past the break point (toward the table) you lose flexibility and control. Too far in front of the break (toward the tip) and you dampen the reed's oscillation and lose projection and responsiveness.

A short facing curve allows you to take in less of the beak and a longer facing curve really requires that you take in more.
 
Last edited:
For me, it's more about the tip opening, reed strength, and a well developed embouchure.
The shape of the curve matters, but not the length of it, for me.
As little as is necessary, with respect to how much.

With an HR or Metal, the width of the MP, requires a slight change, with respect to the sides of the mouth.

Beginners, if taught properly, and play a couple of hours daily, usually get a pretty consistent and good quality tone, as they start their third year.
Then they are really able to control the dynamics, to tell the story of that tune.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,328
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom