Playing the saxophone Help with pitch needed

Happy Bull

Member
Messages
12
Location
uk
I have been playing saxophone for about 18 months, practising pretty much every day. This is after a break of about 25 years during which I forgot much of my previous learning.
I have a teacher online who I am very happy with and I'm making progress.

The problem I'm having at the moment that I wonder if anybody can advise about is:-

I am consistently playing about a quarter tone flat. I have measured against my tuning app.
My relative pitch is OK, except at extreme end of range notes which I would not expect to have right just yet.
This means that with backing tracks I play to I can sound flat!
My teacher assures me that this is something that will gradually improve as my embouchure improves. But I have now been noticing this for some months, and I'm not sure I'm noticing any improvement!

Can anybody advise about this? My instrument is a Yamaha YTS 23 with Selmer S80 C* mouthpiece.
 
It's not clear from your post whether you can hear while you're playing that you're flat. People who are concentrating on reading may not hear that they are flat, but if you're not reading can you play in tune?

Do you record yourself? Does it sound differently to you when you hear the recording compared to when you're playing?

It's possible to play a sax out of tune since it's not a keyboard. Pressing a key and blowing does not = a perfect pitch. It requires embouchure that brings the pitch up. Having the mouthpiece on the horn far enough is also critical. Can you push the mouthpiece on to the crook to nearly the end of the cork (with the cork very well greased)? Many mouthpieces need to be nearly to the end in order to play in tune.

Get back to us...
 
To get the best out of the saxophone, pitch and intonation wise, it needs to be it in tune with itself.

Overblowing long tube notes and adjusting the mouthpiece position to match long tube notes will give the position where the least player input is needed.

Low C, is the easiest place to start. Overblow C1 to C2 without the octave key and adjust the mouthpiece to make them sound the same. You can use the tuner to get a match.
When these match check C1 to G2 and C3. B1 to B2 and F#2.

Mark the position on the cork.

From this position it should be possible to adjust your oral cavity and embouchure to lip in everything else.
At this stage put the tuner away before it drives you mad.

Depending on temperature conditions you may have to pull out a little at the start of play till the horn warms up.
 
It does sound as if you just need to push the mouthpiece in a bit. Do you tune before you start? I tune to concert middle A, that’s your B on tenor, the horn should then be more or less in tune. If you are flat across the horn that should solve it.
 
It does sound as if you just need to push the mouthpiece in a bit. Do you tune before you start? I tune to concert middle A, that’s your B on tenor, the horn should then be more or less in tune. If you are flat across the horn that should solve it.
I would have thought that too. Or maybe a combination of needing to push in and bite a bit more.

However I hesitate to give advice based on some text on the internet against what a pro teacher says. So presumably the teacher has played your setup, ie horn and mouthpiece in the same position on the cork, and for them out is in tune hence nothing wrong with mouthpiece position.

This would indicate the teacher is right and you need to improve your embouchure, however in that case to assume it will gradually improve without telling you how to do it does seem a bit odd.

It could be worth trying the mouthpiece pitch thing, ie play the mouthpiece on its own (no saxophone) and see what pitch it is. On tenor there is a certain school of thought that says the pict should be concert G. I believe that although it can be an indicator of "correct" embouchure it may not always be the case but might be interesting to try.

My gut feeling is to say push it on until you hear it being in tune, but then without knowing everything, I do not want to negate what your teacher is working on with you as they could well know a lot more than "some bloke off the internet".
 
I would have thought that too. Or maybe a combination of needing to push in and bite a bit more.

However I hesitate to give advice based on some text on the internet against what a pro teacher says. So presumably the teacher has payed your setup, ie horn and mouthpiece in the same position on the cork, and for them out is in tune hence nothing wrong with mouthpiece position.

This would indicate the teacher is right and you need to improve your embouchure, however in that case to assume it will gradually improve without telling you how to do it does seem a bit odd.

It could be worth trying the mouthpiece pitch thing, ie play the mouthpiece on its own (no saxophone) and see what pitch it is. On tenor there is a certain school of thought that says the pict should be concert G. I believe that although it can be an indicator of "correct" embouchure it may not always be the case but might be interesting to try.

My gut feeling is to say push it on until you hear it being in tune, but then without knowing everything, I do not want to negate what your teacher is working on with you as they could well know a lot more than "some bloke off the internet".
The teacher is "online", so there is no first hand feedback.
 
The teacher is "online", so there is no first hand feedback.
Oh I missed that. In that case push the mouthpiece in. But also you should ask them why they think that is not the issue?

There must be some reason they didn't suggest that as an initial and very obvious diagnosis, given the limitations of online lessons.

It's always better to get in person lessons, especially for a beginner.
 
Last edited:
It could be worth trying the mouthpiece pitch thing, ie play the mouthpiece on its own (no saxophone) and see what pitch it is. On tenor there is a certain school of thought that says the pict should be concert G. I believe that although it can be an indicator of "correct" embouchure it may not always be the case but might be interesting to try.
I was told to play a concert G on tenor mouthpiece as well. On soprano C, alto A, and baritone D. If you change mouthpieces you must learn to get the right pitch tone. Nothing that comes natural.
 
Good morning and Happy New Year!


My instrument is a Yamaha YTS 23 with Selmer S80 C* mouthpiece.

What's the reed strength you're playing?

To go into detail we should know how embouchure has been taught to you.

Is there any information?
 
Last edited:
Thanks to everyone for your helpful replies. I shall investigate suggestions and report what I find.
To clarify a couple of points raised:
Yes I have an online teacher, we have never met.
Regrettably I can't take the risk of in-person teaching because of my health conditions. I have to restrict personal contact to immediate family and health professionals.
Sadly that means I'm not likely to have the fun of joining a band in the near future.
Hence my reliance on recorded backing tracks.
I also live in a rural location so access to sax tech for repairs or servicing isn't easy (not that I think there's much wrong with the instrument, it's been well cared for by me from new, more likely to be me).

Years ago I did have an in-person teacher who taught me the basics of breathing and embouchure. Some of it I remember!

I'm very impressed with the thoughtfulness and care of the replies on this site. No spam here! I think I'm going to enjoy using it.
Happy new year to you all.
 
I have results from experiments a couple of weeks ago but only just got round to posting.
I can get concert pitch correct notes for mid instrument notes (C down to F approx) if I push the mouthpiece on so that only about 5mm of cork is exposed. As I play notes at the ends of the instrument range I go flat. I'm happy with that result as it means there's nothing wrong with the sax, just the operator!

My teacher has advised not to push mouthpiece that far on but keep improving embouchure so that I will have some margin of adjustment left for tuning. So at the moment I'm going with that advice.

My principal concern was always to verify that the sax itself was OK, and I think I've done that.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,528
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom