Tech/maintenance Hell in a caravan....sticky pads

eb424

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,216
Location
london
Morning all, I play in my caravan and am having a torrid time with sticking pads whilst playing...I use a sax snake after playing and always leave the sax out to dry after swabbing after practice....when first playing the pads are fine but after a while the C# G# and D# start sticking...I used yam powder paper last time after cleaning with lighter fluid and kept the door shut whih helped a bit...I play a YTS custom z and think Yam pads are a little stickier than any other this may or may not be the case...does anyone here know if there are less sticky pads that I can swap the 3 notes above for that would mix with the current set.....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Try them set normally
I'm not going to say that is the cure, it shouldn't be unless they were set ludicrously light.


  • Slightly sticky pads may stick with light spring, but be fine with normal or heavy spring
  • Very sticky pads may stick with light or normal spring but be fine with heavy spring. (But not necessarily!)
  • Non sticky pads should be OK with light springing and above

This is just something to ponder on until somebody who is an expert tech corrects me.

So all these things, whether it is spring tension,key leaves, powder, patches, ointments, unctions or whatever is basically a bandaid rather than a cure. The best thing is to have non sticky pads (ie good quality in good condition and clean) along with tone hole integrity. And keeping toneholes clean I would see a tech and not futz with any kind of sandpaper on them)
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
It is very common for those 2 pads to stick. Sounds like you're already taking all the appropriate steps to mitigate, so just keep at it. Do get those springs checked as Pete says.

FWIW, the vast majority of the moisture in the horn is condensation from your breath, not saliva. So no need to go crazy with oral hygiene. Avoiding sugary drinks/foods right before you play should be enough.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Eddie I guess you will need a new horn, new mpc, new lig and new reeds, all of these will sort your problem>:)>:)>:)


Only joking its just that I haven't had to stock up on popcorn from one of your long threads lately.

Seriously it's a problem all sax players have to deal with, I use the BG pad dryers mentioned above, use before you play and it will be fine.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
It’s only a problem on my one of my horns and a pull through with a pad cleaner, usually a dollar bill, usually sees it off until the next time, and it’s almost always the G#. It’s the lower stack that puzzles me and made me wonder about the spring strength.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
If condensation is a problem a dehumidifier will certainly help. Trying to dry a horn on the stand in a damp enviroment won't help. Mildew will begin to form. Reeds go black.
Run some vinegar through the crook occassionally to keep it clean.
I always take it back indoors to air wouldn't mind so much if the van was stolen...but if my sax was in it.....neighbours not so much i guess...im leaving the spit swab in the g# when not playing...seems to help...
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yes, on that model Yamaha, the key leave under C# also opens G#, making anything else you put under G# redundant. If it doesn't, something is wrong.
Hi thanks for all the help..think the answer ws in front of me all the time. I noticed tonight that i leave the sax at times feed the dogs, have a smoke etc. I used the spit swab in the g# tonight and put the reed in the reedjuvinate...all ok .i will take out one of the key leaves and use it when not playing...hopefully prob sorted..
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
This is a cut and past of a post I made earlier today on SOTW. Not everyone agrees with my methods, but I have found them to be effective and do no harm to the saxophone. Tip: if you really want to hear if the stickiness is removed, put the neck (crook) up to your ear like a stethoscope as you open and close the key.

The technique I have used on my own saxophones and those that come into my shop for the last 20 years follows this sequence:

  1. Clean the pad and top of the tonehole using naptha (lighter fluid) and a cotton swabs with a flat tip.
  2. If the pad still sticks, I clean the top of the tone hole by pulling a strip of 1000 grit wet-or-dry paper between the pad and tone hole face down a few times.
  3. If the sticking sound has still not gone away, I remove the key and rub a tiny amount of teflon powder into the pores of the leather and blow off any excess.
  4. While the key is off the instrument I check the tonehole for a "burr" which I remove if I find one.
  5. At the end of this process, if for some reason the pad still makes a sticking sound it is replaced with a new pad.
The wet-or-dry paper showing the amount of brass removed after it has been pulled a few times. Flat end cotton swabs from Amazon, teflon powder from JLSmith.

1654117161197.png
1654117196173.png
1654117352727.webp
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@424 You also play(ed) a Conn 10M? Was the 10M suffering from sticky pads as well?

Over the years I've been playing lots of saxes. All modern saxes (toneholes off-line; B&S Blue Label, Yanigisawa T-880, Yamaha YTS 62, Yamaha YTS 25, GM4 tenor) I've played were more or less suffering from sticky pads. On all saxes it was G#, Eb and palmkeys that were sticky. On Conn, Amati, Weltklang, King Super 20, New King, Martin Committee ........ and other "old school built " saxes the sticking pads are/were not so common. I gave my saxes the same treatment. I'm quite picky when it comes to keep the tube, neck, toneholes/-rims, pads clean and dry. So maybe the modern saxes are less restistant to sticky pads beacuase of ...
..... the off-line construction? The price for better comfort is sticky pads?
..... modern pads are soft and smooth. I changed the G# and Eb pads several times on the Yani and YTS I played. The tech used original Yamaha replacement pads.
..... the keys(work) on modern saxes are complicated. So hard/complicated that you can't reach the pads. The result is that you don't clean/dry the pads so often as you should?

When I played sitting sticky pads were more common. Even on old shool built saxes. I always stand up when I'm playing. I also try to hold my sax straight out from my body ( not easy, the belly is getting bigger ....). On my Martin tenors most moisture is accumulated down in the bow. The closed pads are rather dry.

Just some reflections from a woodshed honker. So please "ta det med en nypa salt" (take it with a pinch of salt).
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@424 You also play(ed) a Conn 10M? Was the 10M suffering from sticky pads as well?

Over the years I've been playing lots of saxes. All modern saxes (toneholes off-line; B&S Blue Label, Yanigisawa T-880, Yamaha YTS 62, Yamaha YTS 25, GM4 tenor) I've played were more or less suffering from sticky pads. On all saxes it was G#, Eb and palmkeys that were sticky. On Conn, Amati, Weltklang, King Super 20, New King, Martin Committee ........ and other "old school built " saxes the sticking pads are/were not so common. I gave my saxes the same treatment. I'm quite picky when it comes to keep the tube, neck, toneholes/-rims, pads clean and dry. So maybe the modern saxes are less restistant to sticky pads beacuase of ...
..... the off-line construction? The price for better comfort is sticky pads?
..... modern pads are soft and smooth. I changed the G# and Eb pads several times on the Yani and YTS I played. The tech used original Yamaha replacement pads.
..... the keys(work) on modern saxes are complicated. So hard/complicated that you can't reach the pads. The result is that you don't clean/dry the pads so often as you should?

When I played sitting sticky pads were more common. Even on old shool built saxes. I always stand up when I'm playing. I also try to hold my sax straight out from my body ( not easy, the belly is getting bigger ....). On my Martin tenors most moisture is accumulated down in the bow. The closed pads are rather dry.

Just some reflections from a woodshed honker. So please "ta det med en nypa salt" (take it with a pinch of salt).
All good advice as usual @thomsax...Playing a new mouthpiece last night I noticed I leave the sax unattended for a while....problem sticking with the normally closed pads used a spit pad on G# which helped a lot....will take out the key leaves and if I leave the sax will open the bottom C#...you ok?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Bumping this thread with an update on my own key leaves experience. My tenor has always had issues with sticky G# and low Eb. So I finally broke down and got key leaves a month or so ago. It solved the sticking problem, but also created leaks on both pads. So I'm ditching the key leaves and living with the sticky pads. The ideal would be some sort of clamp that presses where you finger the note rather than touching the pad. I may do some more experimenting with that since I already have a set of clamps for other keys. In the mean time, I just need to be more diligent about swabbing and keeping those pads clean and dry.

Like most players, it's been a minor annoyance my whole life, but not a huge deal. And all my horns are different. On soprano, low C# is the one that sticks the most. My alto has no issues because I play it the least. My bari and bass also have no issues, but I think that's just due to the larger pads.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Bumping this thread with an update on my own key leaves experience. My tenor has always had issues with sticky G# and low Eb. So I finally broke down and got key leaves a month or so ago. It solved the sticking problem, but also created leaks on both pads. So I'm ditching the key leaves and living with the sticky pads. The ideal would be some sort of clamp that presses where you finger the note rather than touching the pad. I may do some more experimenting with that since I already have a set of clamps for other keys. In the mean time, I just need to be more diligent about swabbing and keeping those pads clean and dry.

Like most players, it's been a minor annoyance my whole life, but not a huge deal. And all my horns are different. On soprano, low C# is the one that sticks the most. My alto has no issues because I play it the least. My bari and bass also have no issues, but I think that's just due to the larger pads.
Hi @lydian i dont think the leaves are meant to touch the pads...I put mine under the arm on just the bottom C# ( ?) Which holds the G pad open..
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,556
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom