Tech/maintenance Hell in a caravan....sticky pads

eb424

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,216
Location
london
Morning all, I play in my caravan and am having a torrid time with sticking pads whilst playing...I use a sax snake after playing and always leave the sax out to dry after swabbing after practice....when first playing the pads are fine but after a while the C# G# and D# start sticking...I used yam powder paper last time after cleaning with lighter fluid and kept the door shut whih helped a bit...I play a YTS custom z and think Yam pads are a little stickier than any other this may or may not be the case...does anyone here know if there are less sticky pads that I can swap the 3 notes above for that would mix with the current set.....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
@Woodpad has an extensive set of baseline data. I would be starting from scratch.

FWIW, I still use Runyon Pad Dope on my pads. It's been quite a while since the last application, but I have not experienced any sticking pads in many years. Happiness is a clean and leak-free horn.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Obviously people live and play in quite different environments.

I never had a problem... Till I did the re-pad and then the body octave pip started sticking! Brand new pad off the cows rump, into the packet and onto the horn :confused2: . I pulled over the pad with a bit of card - about as rough as 1200 grit, I guess, and it's fine.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
There are a lot of different reasons why pads becomes sticky. I tried to measure effects of bad cleaning on pads by cleaning them after 24 hours. It seems that your cleaning is ok, you can check this by looking at the low D# pad. It is often the dirtiest pad.
During my tests a pad became permanently sticky by sugary drinks, which surprised me. Climate can also be a problem when the air humidity is often above 70% . Calcutta is a terrible place for pads.
Now all leather pads can become sticky and if cleaning and roughing them up as described by mizmar doesn't do the job the next step is new pads..
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Appreciate this is a while since your first post, but an old sax guy told me that a blue banknote pulled gently between the offending pad and the body of the sax will work wonders. It has to be a blue note (no pun intended), so a £5 note or a €10 euro note will do the job. It's something in the blue ink that leaves a trace on both sides, pad and sax, that helps. Did it myself tonight at rehearsal with my curved sop. Did the job instantly. Hope this helps.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Appreciate this is a while since your first post, but an old sax guy told me that a blue banknote pulled gently between the offending pad and the body of the sax will work wonders. It has to be a blue note (no pun intended), so a £5 note or a €10 euro note will do the job. It's something in the blue ink that leaves a trace on both sides, pad and sax, that helps. Did it myself tonight at rehearsal with my curved sop. Did the job instantly. Hope this helps.
That would work with the paper notes but I wouldn't expect it to work with the plastic ones.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Appreciate this is a while since your first post, but an old sax guy told me that a blue banknote pulled gently between the offending pad and the body of the sax will work wonders. It has to be a blue note (no pun intended), so a £5 note or a €10 euro note will do the job. It's something in the blue ink that leaves a trace on both sides, pad and sax, that helps. Did it myself tonight at rehearsal with my curved sop. Did the job instantly. Hope this helps.
I was told a dollar bill did the same. Fortunately never needed it 🙂
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
There are a lot of different reasons why pads becomes sticky. I tried to measure effects of bad cleaning on pads by cleaning them after 24 hours. It seems that your cleaning is ok, you can check this by looking at the low D# pad. It is often the dirtiest pad.
During my tests a pad became permanently sticky by sugary drinks, which surprised me. Climate can also be a problem when the air humidity is often above 70% . Calcutta is a terrible place for pads.
Now all leather pads can become sticky and if cleaning and roughing them up as described by mizmar doesn't do the job the next step is new pads..
When I started to buy used saxes the term "workable pads" was often used. I once asked an old school saxophone tech what the term meant to him; clean the pad with lukewarm soap water, the pad can be adjusted. Today we often replace pads instead of cleaning them. New low price pads or clean the old ones? Take good care of pads to avoid sticky pads. Never used "naptha" or "grit" on my pads. IMO "naptha" and "grit" is quick fix. But is fun to order new pads and cool to cure the new sticky pads. I have old saxes from the 40's, 50's and 60's with original pads. Still ok.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
When I started to buy used saxes the term "workable pads" was often used. I once asked an old school saxophone tech what the term meant to him; clean the pad with lukewarm soap water, the pad can be adjusted. Today we often replace pads instead of cleaning them. New low price pads or clean the old ones? Take good care of pads to avoid sticky pads. Never used "naptha" or "grit" on my pads. IMO "naptha" and "grit" is quick fix. But is fun to order new pads and cool to cure the new sticky pads. I have old saxes from the 40's, 50's and 60's with original pads. Still ok.
A lot of old school techs are good at avoiding unnecessary costly repairs. When cleaning with soap, some fats are removed. To minimize this I use an old type soft soap. The modern synthetic soaps tend to have improved defatting properties.

I have also seen some very old workable pads. In all cases they have an even imprint which is rather shallow.
Cork pads for small tone holes can also function for a long time.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Appreciate this is a while since your first post, but an old sax guy told me that a blue banknote pulled gently between the offending pad and the body of the sax will work wonders. It has to be a blue note (no pun intended), so a £5 note or a €10 euro note will do the job. It's something in the blue ink that leaves a trace on both sides, pad and sax, that helps. Did it myself tonight at rehearsal with my curved sop. Did the job instantly. Hope this helps.

Your “experiment” at rehearsal could have been successful because the banknote removed something from the pad or tone hole.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Banknotes are have been recommended for years. There may well be something about the paper however I always thought that it was important to be clean crisp new paper ones.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I can't verify for other currencies, but prior to the current plastic notes. UK bank notes were made from cotton fibres, not wood pulp and had a fairly rough surface, further enhanced by the raised ink with lots of fine lines and hatching in the design (intaglio printing) which would be abrasive, though not as much as wet and dry paper.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yep...meant c and d# bottom left...ill start using the spit pad. The sax always goes syraight back on the stand to air with 4 key leaves...
Where do 4 of them go? It only takes one to open C#, G# and D#.

Do you eat or drink before/during playing? Do you swab thoroughly after playing? Does your horn tilt forward in the stand?

Stickiness is more from sugar and other contaminants than from moisture alone. I imagine it’s much more humid in the southern US where live than in the UK, yet I have very few problems with sticking keys aside from the occasional G# and bis issues.

Seems like there is something else contributing to the problem which we haven’t identified yet.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Where do 4 of them go? It only takes one to open C#, G# and D#.

Do you eat or drink before/during playing? Do you swab thoroughly after playing? Does your horn tilt forward in the stand?

Stickiness is more from sugar and other contaminants than from moisture alone. I imagine it’s much more humid in the southern US where live than in the UK, yet I have very few problems with sticking keys aside from the occasional G# and bis issues.

Seems like there is something else contributing to the problem which we haven’t identified yet.
Thought they made them for the 3 palm keys too
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Banknotes work because of the texture of the paper. I have a bunch of old paper notes, including a 200 Belgian franc one with Adolphe Sax on it. A US dollar seems to work best, the others are ok in a pinch but aren't really coarse enough. I don't recommend 1000 Italian Lira notes, too smooth and insubstantial.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Thought they made them for the 3 palm keys too
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,554
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom