Saxophones Hawkes & Son Excelsior Sonorous

@confusedhere i’m curious as a inherited item if any of the history of ownership was passed along. It’s always really nice to see pictures of people playing them from back in the day. Or at least some knowledge of the person who owned it and its journey.
Owned by Charles Thackrah of Sydney NSW, founder of the Willoughby Orchestra. One of the many instruments he regularly played - trumpet, cornet, trombone, piano, double-bass, and in his eighties, electric bass guitar.
 
Owned by Charles Thackrah of Sydney NSW, founder of the Willoughby Orchestra. One of the many instruments he regularly played - trumpet, cornet, trombone, piano, double-bass, and in his eighties, electric bass guitar.
Interesting, indeed! Of course now that begs the question - since we are talking antipodes - whether high translates into low? It should, shouldn't it?:old:
 
Owned by Charles Thackrah of Sydney NSW, founder of the Willoughby Orchestra. One of the many instruments he regularly played - trumpet, cornet, trombone, piano, double-bass, and in his eighties, electric bass guitar.
Is there more than one orchestra? I looked it up online. Appears to be a mandolin orchestra. Are you part of that? Very cool you have the owners history! Thanks for sharing.
 
Agreed. But were pianos tuned "high pitch" at that time? Being string instruments (sort of), presumably they could be tuned at whichever pitch was predominant.
Especially with pianos, you need to be very careful if you have a really low pitch instrument and try to even bring it up to 440 Hz, the extra tension can easily crack the cast iron plate. At least that's what somebody who's been doing this for a living and the better part of 40 years told me.
 
Had this old beastie come into the workshop yesterday - a plain old Hawkes & Son alto. No model designation.
No pitch stamp on it either, which surprised me because it plays A at 44Hz.

Hawkes and son old alto.webp
 
"Before I go, let me point out that the difference between 435 Hertz and 440 Hertz is barely perceptible. Note that the second of my links is a tone generator. I opened it and started it going. It defaults to 440 Hertz because they have that kind of stranglehold on the world. I opened again it in another tab and got it going at 435 and I could not honestly say whether I actually heard the difference or just seemed to hear it because I expected to hear it."

At least three generations of flute players in France and the United States grew up believing it was the inherent nature of high quality flutes to play sharp up top and flat down below; that was because high quality instruments were copies of Louis Lot flutes built to play at A = 435. These flutes were then "retuned" to 440 by the simple expedient of cutting about 3/8" off the head joint and pushing in, which of course made the scale too long. So whenever a young flute player got his or her first Haynes or Powell the first thing was to learn how to make the thing play in tune. This led to entire schools of "how to blow low notes and high notes" - all of which wasn't required when they played their cheap Armstrong student flutes which were copies of the old closed hole Haynes Commercial which was a copy of a Boehm closed hole flute built to play at A = 440.

It wasn't till the 1970s that makers of high quality flutes actually recalculated the tone hole positions for A = 440 (even though Boehm published simple instructions for calculating tone hole positions, at any pitch, around 1880).

Robert Dick had a great article on this, with far more detail than I can remember, on the now long-gone Larry Krantz Flute Pages. Sadly, I have been unable to track down that article.
 
I just played 440 and 435, and the beats are pretty darn noticeable. Anybody who can't hear the difference is not just tone deaf but completely deaf.

I also played, or rather felt, 44Hz, aka F1, the lowest F on a piano and 1.5 steps below the lowest note on a bass saxophone.
 
432hz vs 440 hz.
There is a difference. But an A=432 hz is still in the range of an "A" even if it's goes more more flat. An "A" in 457 hz is also in the A range but sharper, more an A#.

Most modern saxes are designed to play an A4=440 hz. But often the grand pianos are tuned A=443 hz. Sax players use to adjust with the moutpiece. Maybe new design of mouthpices and necks can make a modern saxophone to work in A=432 hz and/or A=457 hz?

I think the discussion about to play and sing in A=432 hz is that singers spare thier voices and can sing more. The Swedish opera singer Birgit Nilsson said that if music was performed in a lower pitch she could sing more. And she wanted to sing more.

The violins on Cuba were tuned A=436 hz. It was beacause A = 436 hz was more friendly to the strings. Lack of strings on Cuba.

Are HP saxes wall hangers or can they be used? Is the quarter step impossible to handled? Is it the pitch or the timbre?

432 hz vs 440 hz guitar
View: https://youtu.be/Rt3EAPDn-Ug

440 hz vs 432 hz grand piano (digitally pitched)
View: https://youtu.be/dhux-KNMLz4

A Buescher High Pitch soprano
View: https://youtu.be/QOKocvItdU8

Conn HP soprano
View: https://youtu.be/NtbtLN6jjmM
 
Maybe new design of mouthpices and necks can make a modern saxophone to work in A=432 hz and/or A=457 hz?
No.
It's the length of the tube and the spacing of toneholes that dictate the pitch. Redesigning the neck/mouthpiece may help with some notes, but not throughout the whole range.

Haven't we had this discussion before ... ?
 
Haven't we had this discussion before ... ?
Many times .... and I've posted the text from "Band Instrument Repairing Manual" by Erick D. Brand many times as well. But here it is one more time.
hptolp.jpg
Yes. the average opinion is that HP saxes are wall hangers. But If you are the only sax/hornplayer you can play a HP sax?
 
You can typically compensate about 4 Hz on the A=440 standard. Flutes built at A=435 can kind of sort of be played at A=440 by shortening the headjoint, but as I noted above, the low notes are flat, the high notes are sharp, and you've got to develop various gyrations to compensate. Generations of flutists did this, but moving from a "few Hz off scale" to "the exact scale" is a real revelation, as I've experienced myself.

Yes, these days a lot of orchestras, especially in Europe, are tuning to 442 or even 444. I'd say for most instruments 444 is right at the raggedy edge of compensable, depending on the instrument. For example, if you've got a valved brass instrument, you can't push the tuning slides in any further than you can push them in. You could have them all chopped, and then if you pulled them for playing at 440, you'd probably be OK. For woodwinds, you really can't do much as the tone holes are totally fixed. String instruments can be tuned to whatever pitch you want, up till they start folding up from excessive string tension or until that high unwound string breaks whenever you look at it wrong.

I will also note that in the US A=440 is still the accepted standard and very few ensembles are tuning higher. I don't know the situation in Britain; as I noted on the continent a higher tuning is common; and I don't know anything at all about tuning standards in the rest of the world.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,642
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom