Playing the saxophone Having a teacher = different mindset?

That’s a skewed view Thom, not many will want that or anything like it.

There are a few basics that most won’t have a clue they’re doing:

- Biting
- Not supporting/breathing properly
- Not playing in the middle of the note (arising from either or both of the other two)

Often really hard to fix, especially if you don’t know it needs tinkering with.

Putting the instrument together, fingering, theory - all can be learned from a book.
Exactly.
Where do I put my hands, which way around?
Which way up does the mouthpiece go?
What combination of keys give a different note... which note?
How do I remember the sheet music notes? F...A...C...E. Every good boy... what... Fish? Why Fish?
What am I doing wrong!?
 
Exactly.
Where do I put my hands, which way around?
Which way up does the mouthpiece go?
What combination of keys give a different note... which note?
How do I remember the sheet music notes? F...A...C...E. Every good boy... what... Fish? Why Fish?
What am I doing wrong!?
Fish - A little higher than Eish and lower than Gish.
 
Teaching saxophone, here around, is much about to learn to read and play melody from a book/sheet music.
That isn't actually teaching the saxophone.

It's a pet peeve of mine that so many so-called saxophone teachers, just teach reading or improvising. That is fine if it's what the student wants but has blithering to do (specifically) with saxophone playing.
 
Group lessons/ensemble is better for the adult student who knows what they want. I don't mean things basic knowledge and skills.

To meet a teacher once a week is IMO waste of time and money. We know that efficient learning is an early repetition. 2-3 times a week is better.
 
Group lessons/ensemble is better for the adult student who knows what they want. I don't mean things basic knowledge and skills.

To meet a teacher once a week is IMO waste of time and money. We know that efficient learning is an early repetition. 2-3 times a week is better.
My teacher, who plays on the same level as Michael Brecker, gives me enough material in one lesson to last me 3 months of daily practice. It would be pointless for me to have lessons more frequently because there’s no way I could master all that material in a week, much less a few days.
 
I think your teacher might be embarrassed at this comment.
It was meant to be a compliment. He’s certainly the best player I’ve ever met and an excellent teacher. Check out the video I sent you and let me know if you disagree.
 
My teacher, who plays on the same level as Michael Brecker, gives me enough material in one lesson to last me 3 months of daily practice. It would be pointless for me to have lessons more frequently because there’s no way I could master all that material in a week, much less a few days.
Yes that's work for you and your teacher. Maybe you could be as good as your teacher, and Michael Brecker, if you were working more side by side daily?
 
It was meant to be a compliment. He’s certainly the best player I’ve ever met and an excellent teacher. Check out the video I sent you and let me know if you disagree.
He’d be really embarrassed, trust me. Yes, very good player, but you compared him to one of the very very best ever.
Sanborn said this:
 

Attachments

  • image.webp
    image.webp
    44 KB · : 152
That isn't actually teaching the saxophone.

It's a pet peeve of mine that so many so-called saxophone teachers, just teach reading or improvising. That is fine if it's what the student wants but has blithering to do (specifically) with saxophone playing.
The first years a student need individual teaching. Learning to read, music theory, master the saxophone tone, maintain of the gear .... . Later on it should be more ensemble/group lessons. My daughters played clarinet and trombone for 5-6 yearsand they were doing fine. But they didn't like to be alone with a male teacher in a small room. If group/ensemble lessons were available maybe they have been playing today?
 
Last edited:
Yes that's work for you and your teacher. Maybe you could be as good as your teacher, and Michael Brecker, if you were working more side by side daily?
I don’t think so. It’s still up to me to do the work, which I never could do, even if I were constantly in the same room. Besides, I’d run out of money pretty quickly. Also, what’s the point of an amateur reaching that high level. It would be all consuming, and the rest of my life would fall apart. No thanks. I’m happy as a mediocre player with a good life balance and enough money to live comfortably.
 
I don’t think so. It’s still up to me to do the work, which I never could do, even if I were constantly in the same room. Besides, I’d run out of money pretty quickly. Also, what’s the point of an amateur reaching that high level. It would be all consuming, and the rest of my life would fall apart. No thanks. I’m happy as a mediocre player with a good life balance and enough money to live comfortably.
Brecker paid off his mortgage in two years of touring with Paul Simon.

You’re right though, most don’t even get anywhere near a Plumber’s wage.
 
That isn't actually teaching the saxophone.

It's a pet peeve of mine that so many so-called saxophone teachers, just teach reading or improvising. That is fine if it's what the student wants but has blithering to do (specifically) with saxophone playing.
Well, when elementary school students first show up in the band hall, they usually don't know ANYTHING. So they have to learn the rudiments of written music, the fundamentals of rhythm, and the handling and operation of the instrument itself.

There's kind of no way to separate these at the early levels of instruction. Once one's approaching adulthood (or has achieved it), you can start separating the various aspects of music:

- Technical command of the instrument itself
- Creative matters (improvising, interpretation, etc.)
- Music theory (which varies a great deal depending on which genre we're talking about)
- harmony, voice-leading, compositional matters
- General musicianship - how to phrase, on and off stage behavior, practice strategies
- Technology of the instrument - minor repairs, care and feeding, etc.

As we got older (excuse me, as we accumulate experience) we become more developed in some areas than others, thus targeted instruction makes sense. We can all come up with examples of players who're strong in one area but not so much in others.

But going back to schoolroom instruction, with 20-60 kids all in one room at one time, the school band director has to provide a general instruction and so there's inevitably going to be a lot of "general music" instruction, that kids who are taking outside tuition probably don't need.
 
Well, when elementary school students first show up in the band hall, they usually don't know ANYTHING. So they have to learn the rudiments of written music, the fundamentals of rhythm, and the handling and operation of the instrument itself.

There's kind of no way to separate these at the early levels of instruction. Once one's approaching adulthood (or has achieved it), you can start separating the various aspects of music:

- Technical command of the instrument itself
- Creative matters (improvising, interpretation, etc.)
- Music theory (which varies a great deal depending on which genre we're talking about)
- harmony, voice-leading, compositional matters
- General musicianship - how to phrase, on and off stage behavior, practice strategies
- Technology of the instrument - minor repairs, care and feeding, etc.

As we got older (excuse me, as we accumulate experience) we become more developed in some areas than others, thus targeted instruction makes sense. We can all come up with examples of players who're strong in one area but not so much in others.

But going back to schoolroom instruction, with 20-60 kids all in one room at one time, the school band director has to provide a general instruction and so there's inevitably going to be a lot of "general music" instruction, that kids who are taking outside tuition probably don't need.
I think you’re agreeing with Pete, in that tuition specifically instrumental occurs alongside theory etc. A holistic approach.
Bear in mind also that the US band system model isn’t well-used in the UK. The norm here, or was, is to get to a certain level and then go and sit in with the band.
Again, pros and cons with both. Bandleader needs to be versed in fingerings, valve combos, reeds, etc of all instruments - again, this isn’t de riguer here. It probably should be - doesn’t take much really.
As I always say, every job is populated by the same type of characters, so there are music teacher equivalents of cowboy builders etc.
A head of music (age 12-16) once asked me if what she had written on the board for her next class was The Blues Scale. It was. Does it go up a tone for a clarinet. Yes it does. Would you do that for me….
 
What should they be doing in contrast? Especially in the setting of adult teaching?
They should first of all teach tone production, breathing, fingering technique. I would apply those things to playing tunes, but initially I would prefer to concentrate on playing tunes from memory or by ear rather than reading.

I'm not saying it isn't good to learn theory, reading, improvising but you don't need a saxophone teacher for that. Of course anything that stops a student from being otherwise bored is a good thing to have up your sleeve.
 
Last edited:
That isn't actually teaching the saxophone.

It's a pet peeve of mine that so many so-called saxophone teachers, just teach reading or improvising. That is fine if it's what the student wants but has blithering to do (specifically) with saxophone playing.
To "teach" the saxophone is very much about tone production, air support and to master the machine called the saxophone or "the organic synthesizer".

I'm more or less self-taught. Just a few hours with a saxophone teacher. But I have had many "teachers" through the years. I've been honking since 1968. From my father and the guy in music shop where I bought my used Conn alto sax ..... to players and teachers that I've met later in life. Just one guy that couldn't accept that I wanted to play Rock & Roll Saxophone and that was the saxophone teacher!!!!!

The blues and rock guitarist that came over to play with me opened my ears and eyes. I asked him; what do you a sax player to do when you are playing and singing? I got many suggestions what a tenor sax and the guitar could do. To play along with The Shadows and The Ventures guitar based music was something new for me. Try to play along with the guitar tones, that often came from a Stratocaster, on my The Martin with a high baffled mouthpiece. But to get a nice flow over the sax keys in the Rock & Roll keys I needed a sax player that told the things that you don't find in the saxophone learning books.

Internet and new media also changed music learning. " At what time are you going to be in the rehearsal room?, asked saxophone playing friend who lives in east USA. " 18:00 are we ready to play", I replied. " Let me know if you want me to watch and listen. I can spend an hour in the studio before a drive to Vermont for a gig". Covid19 pandemic changed the way to learn music.
 
Hi all. Being a teacher myself, not in music, I can only confirm that the process of teaching something to someone IS a sophisticated set of interactions.
I’m active in what we call « professional schools ». Young adults learn their craft 4 days/week in a company on the job, and 1 day/week is in a classroom, dedicated mainly to the theoretical aspects. Electricians, hairdressers or logistics specialists (my area), to mention a few, are trained and certified like this here.
We attend a compulsory pedagogy and didactics program to be allowed to teach in those schools. 1800 hours of training and homework. Not sure all music or saxophone teachers do that.
Teaching might be a natural talent, but it is also something you can learn and improve.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom