Playing the saxophone Having a teacher = different mindset?

I think a lot of people are intimidated by the idea of lessons and music theory etc.
They don't want the expense and are impatient to just get on and play for fun and not at what they consider an advanced level.

Then you need to factor in people that are neuro divergent and think differently -this can include people with dyslexia, obsessive compulsive disorder etc.

Then further factor in a previous negative experience -perhaps group music lessons at school, bad teachers etc.

A good teacher will obviously be able to tailor their approach to get the best out of the student and cater to their specific needs.

People are always looking for a quick win and many people think there's a quick 'hack' for most things, this is not helped by many people promising afore mentioned 'life hacks'. The reality is there is no one size fits all and no universal method that will work for everyone.

There are many teachers out there, not all of them are good teachers, not all of the good ones are right for all students.

Bottom line is music takes hard work and practice, but should be enjoyable and not a chore.
 
I think for adults, many haven't learnt/studied in depth since finishing school/college. It does take a certain mindset to be receptive to learning.

My teacher has been blunt in the past "You can stop there, that's sh*t", to be fair it was, but I'm told why it wasn't great, and then how to work on improving it. I'm reminded about the same mistakes I'm making, at the same time I'm praised when it's (occasionally) due.

Ultimately though I've seen huge progress in my playing, and I'm enjoying my journey. I don't know whether my teacher would be the same with other students, but we do seem to share the same sarcastic, dark humour.

Within the group I play with, you can spot the players in the section who are self taught. Particularly when it comes to rhythm & timing, even confidence. On the other hand, one self taught player in our group is a whizz on the theory, scales, key signatures, transposing, where most of look with a blank expression as they try and explain it.
 
If you take lessons from someone who knows what they're doing and has been doing it a long time, you need to leave your preciousness at home. Most such people learned on the bandstand where if something sucked you got immediate feedback, without sugarcoating.
 
I started just playing stuff from YouTube. I bought the Complete Beginner course by Simon Currie and that is what got me started. Since I have purchased from Johnny Ferreira. I support Yasuhiro Fujii. I have really improved using his YouTube easy solo songs and jazz progressions. I have TomPlay and that has helped. I also have the Complete Music Reading Training app on my android cellphone. I am now listening to another Udemy course on music theory.
I am pretty sure that in a few months I will need some individual instruction to help me with technique and correct some of my bad habits.
 
Learning basics (fingering, embouchure, tone) can certainly be best facilitated with teaching. Bad habits are hard to break!

Beyond that, it's best if the student defines their goals if they wish to achieve proficiency in as short a time as possible. The skill of becoming a proficient reader is possibly more straight forward, yet still best facilitated if the student has a style/genre goal (classical, big band, orchestra pit, etc.). Too often it seems like "able" (talented?) students are "directed" on a specific path that may not be of their choosing and wind up not achieving their potential.

The teaching mantra that "anyone can play an instrument" if they practice and are determined is somewhat true, yet can be the musical equivalent to "paint by the numbers". Being able to read (an eye to hand trained reaction) is not the same as being able to play a tune by ear that has not been practiced...which takes being able to hear the music in your head, and be one with your instrument so that it's the same as singing. What's difficult to teach is creativity and the ability to play what one can hear in their head.

Teaching improvisation as an academic discipline has been very popular, and can certainly give some students the ability to play along with tunes by learning riffs, arpeggios and how to string these together to fit the changes in a tune. However it's simply a reverse engineered observation of what creative players did that can be fitted together as "cut and paste" without engaging creative or melodic thinking/playing.

Creative musicianship isn't engineering. Improvising via "theory" has its place for players who aren't capable of otherwise improvising or playing lines that they could sing. If it gives the player pleasure then it's a goal accomplished. One can hear these players at open mike jams regularly, sounding similar with varying degrees of proficiency, yet all lacking the spark that made their copied heroes great...originality and their own voice.

It's possible that some teachers can assist in encouraging creativity. To the best of my knowledge there is no method of syncing one's internal voice to their instrument, it probably just takes a lot attempted playing by ear for some years.

It seems a shame that the potential of some advanced players becomes sidetracked by (hopefully) well meaning individuals who teach theoretical improvisation rather than encouraging melodic and creative playing. The idea of "copying the greats" seems equally flawed for aspiring professionals. Who wants to listen to a "tribute player"? "The greats" had their own identifiable voice. They played as themselves, not like some sax player from the 1920s!

Maybe it's time for some turnarounds in teaching and the way aspiring players let themselves be directed?
 
Last edited:
It seems like harmony is taught but rhythm is overlooked.
I suppose because harmony is the clever, technical bit.

I think I've learned just as much about soloing from Fred Astaire and Sammy Davis Jr as the great players.

A dance teacher or just watching dancers may be able to put just as much sparkle on your playing as a music teacher.

I think my inability to get on with teachers is due to not wanting to learn what they're teaching.

A sit in with a six piece New Orleans band with an average age of eighty is the sort of lesson that suits my temperament.

I learn more from a bad session as a good one.
 
It seems like harmony is taught but rhythm is overlooked.
I suppose because harmony is the clever, technical bit.

I think I've learned just as much about soloing from Fred Astaire and Sammy Davis Jr as the great players.

A dance teacher or just watching dancers may be able to put just as much sparkle on your playing as a music teacher.

I think my inability to get on with teachers is due to not wanting to learn what they're teaching.

A sit in with a six piece New Orleans band with an average age of eighty is the sort of lesson that suits my temperament.

I learn more from a bad session as a good one.
Good observation about rhythm, yet a good teacher should cover that too. Just seems often overlooked when conversations are happening... like here. I've had some interesting learning sessions with a master Ghanaian drummer. He emphasized that rhythm is in the body, not the head. To become a drummer you must first be a dancer. Ties in well with your learning from relating to Fred and Sammy. Unfortunately you left out Ginger, who did everything Fred did but in high heels and often dancing backwards... worthy of a mention!
 
Good observation about rhythm, yet a good teacher should cover that too. Just seems often overlooked when conversations are happening... like here. I've had some interesting learning sessions with a master Ghanaian drummer. He emphasized that rhythm is in the body, not the head. To become a drummer you must first be a dancer. Ties in well with your learning from relating to Fred and Sammy. Unfortunately you left out Ginger, who did everything Fred did but in high heels and often dancing backwards... worthy of a mention!
I think there are many paths Wade, though dancing can only ever help rhythmic feel.
Bernard Purdie was around dancers and singers much of his life, whereas Keith Carlock, it seems, not so much.

Sanborn has impeccable time, and he talks about hearing the subdivisions in his head as he plays. Getz had great time too. Brecker also. Mind you, I can’t really think of a great player who had questionable time.

The subdivisions may be the key. At any point while you are playing you might be feeling a rhythmic undertone - which is a backbeat I guess.

I do agree though - rhythm; groove; feel are often the things at a higher level that can cause a player to trip at the final hurdle.

Then you move on to placement, which can be quite defining in some styles. Take the snare in Reggae. It’s waaaay back.

Also some music only grooves when time is slightly loose or floaty.

When using a DAW it’s quite shocking to see how far “out” something is when it sounds right. It’s bizarre. I find this part of it to be completely illogical.
 
There's a reason I opted for a face 2 face teacher. I'm accountable.

I've been busy with work this week, and barely touched my saxes, but I know I have a lesson Wednesday so will make time over the weekend and next week to practice.

I know if I was doing an online course, it'll be alright I'll do it next week, and next week will be the same.

Same with working on things, I can play pieces and they sound alright, some even like it, but my teacher keeps pushing to improve, which improves all aspects of my playing.

Not saying it's the same for everyone but I know myself what I am like, and what's best for me.

Re: timing & rhythm it seems to be a long, slow process, but as it improves I'm enjoying playing more.
 
I was 'forced' to play an instrument, the flute, at school at 14. I hated having to learn a new piece every week and resented this immensely. I was crap at it.

At 50+ I chose to take up the saxophone and soon after chose to have lessons from Dave Plummer locally.
For technique, problem solving, finding music, being critiqued, it was excellent. I still hated having to do 'homework' for the next fortnightly session though. But I knew why I had to do it... to progress.

Dave moved to the IOW and my lessons stopped. I do think about having more now, but until I drop my other interests and concentrate on sax playing (which may never happen) I struggle to motivate myself to get motivated by another tutor. I'm still crap, but happily so.
 
Last edited:
Why are adult/grown up persons taking lessons from a teacher? Most of the students doesn't have enough time to practice and their goals are not to be professional and not even the best sax player in the block.as they were a kid that, The methods to learn or teach are pretty much the same.

Teaching saxophone, here around, is much about to learn to read and play melody from a book/sheet music. It's not unusual that a 19-20 years saxophonist sounds in the same way as they did when they were 12 years old. Of course, the music the read and play is more advanced compared to when they were beginners. And when they show up on a Rocksax workshop in their middle age it's a new stuff to learn or deal with. Playing by ear, more volume, rock & roll keys, playing a solo or in a band with 1-3 wind instruments ..... .

Many sax players are looking for help or advice to solve a problem. It can be get the tone they want, technique (fingerings), help with some songs ...... . They are not looking for a teacher that tell them to learn the song in all 12 keys, universal embouchure or right mouth .... .

We need more alternative ways to learn how to play the saxophone.
 
Why are adult/grown up persons taking lessons from a teacher?
Many of the above post give perfectly good reason why some people take lessons, and why some people don't.

People, especially older people, vary widely in theirs; objectives, abilities, expectations, etc. and the concept of
Most of the students
(And several people have thrown out unsupported generalisations) Isn't useful.


As you say, there are many alternatives; which is great for the many kinds of people out there.
 
They are not looking for a teacher that tell them to learn the song in all 12 keys, universal embouchure or right mouth ....
That’s a skewed view Thom, not many will want that or anything like it.

There are a few basics that most won’t have a clue they’re doing:

- Biting
- Not supporting/breathing properly
- Not playing in the middle of the note (arising from either or both of the other two)

Often really hard to fix, especially if you don’t know it needs tinkering with.

Putting the instrument together, fingering, theory - all can be learned from a book.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom