Mouthpieces Got a new tenor mouthpiece

They weren't squeaks, they were 'nuances' :rolleyes:

It sounds stilted to me, less so on the second verse, and overall a bit flat. Should have used a backing track to help my rhythm and timing.
I thought I was 'flowing' well enough playing with the band but I now think the other players cover my limping.
Work to do...........
 
They weren't squeaks, they were 'nuances' :rolleyes:

It sounds stilted to me, less so on the second verse, and overall a bit flat. Should have used a backing track to help my rhythm and timing.
I thought I was 'flowing' well enough playing with the band but I now think the other players cover my limping.
Work to do...........
“overall flat” >> Have you found the sweet spot on the cork for the new mouthpiece? Don’t rely on the old markings to indicate where the new mouthpiece needs to be.
 
Always (or nearly always) a good idea. The use your your embouchure, relax a bit, to lower the pitch if necessary. The opposite doesn’t work IMO.
Thank Pete, I read something about that. Push mpc in more and lower the pitch centre by relaxing the embouchure and jaw and throat more.

If I got it right, the high notes have more pitch flexibility so best to tune the low notes correctly as they have less flexibility and 'adjust' the higher ones which are more flexible?
 
Thank Pete, I read something about that. Push mpc in more and lower the pitch centre by relaxing the embouchure and jaw and throat more.

If I got it right, the high notes have more pitch flexibility so best to tune the low notes correctly as they have less flexibility and 'adjust' the higher ones which are more flexible?
Yes that sounds about right IMO
 
Thank Pete, I read something about that. Push mpc in more and lower the pitch centre by relaxing the embouchure and jaw and throat more.
Checked and adjusted the mpc position today. Played B1 and checked against B3 and adjusted until both in tune., then blew B2 to see if I could bend it up and down easily. It's now a few mm further on than the optimal point for the 5C. The high notes are a bit sharp but more controllable and the low notes not sounding flat.

Out of curiosity (I know...) I looked on-line for 'optimising mpc position tenor sax' and the three entries I read all said:
  • If your note is too sharp, pull your mouthpiece out along the neck cork.
  • If your note is too flat, push your mouthpiece farther in along the neck cork.
This is contrary to the advice I've read here and in this article: https://www.yamaha.com/yamahavgn/Documents/BandOrchestra/Wind_Tips_Duke.pdf

Surely to place the mpc further out means you play flat and have to tighten the embouchure to go sharper, whereas Steve Duke's advice is to push mpc on more, and relax jaw and throat to reduce the sharpness (which is easier as high notes have more variability in pitch?

Comments most appreciated.
 
You only pull out if you are playing sharp and push in if you are flat. Pulling out lengthens the tube and lowers the pitch. Pushing in shortens it and raises the pitch. This does not take into account changing your embouchure. Adjustments will always have to be made on some notes.
 
I was flat at the low end and slightly overall so pushed the mpc in more and relaxed my throat and jaw. I'm sure with lots of practice it will come right. This mpc is much more flexible and malleable than the 5C so I need to get used to it.
 
I think the article's point was that students tend to play initially with a high pitch center, which throws off what their ideal intonation (particular to their horn) should be. If you blow just the MP you can get an idea of what your 'natural' pitch center is.

Another tuning technique I learned here on the Cafe is to play low B, then overblow it to the next octave, adjusting the MP to get those in tune with each other.
 
I think the article's point was that students tend to play initially with a high pitch center, which throws off what their ideal intonation (particular to their horn) should be. If you blow just the MP you can get an idea of what your 'natural' pitch center is.

Another tuning technique I learned here on the Cafe is to play low B, then overblow it to the next octave, adjusting the MP to get those in tune with each other.

I guess that makes more sense now. I'm learning to relax my embouchure, jaw and throat more to lower my pitch centre.

Steve Duke wrote:

".....if you play sharp in the upper register then PUSH IN and LOWER THE PITCH CENTER! This is the opposite of what everyone is taught – if you are sharp then pull out. If your pitch center is high and you pull out, then you only add to the problem by forcing your pitch center even higher."
 
I was flat at the low end and slightly overall so pushed the mpc in more and relaxed my throat and jaw. I'm sure with lots of practice it will come right. This mpc is much more flexible and malleable than the 5C so I need to get used to it.
Yes, what you did is a good solution. You practice well and learn quickly. You will get it together pretty soon.
 
Also bear in mind you don't need to believe or follow everything you read on the internet. My first advice would be if you are sharp, do not push the mouthpiece further on.
My thought as well. There are two somewhat separate issues being discussed here. One has to do with embouchure & voicing adjustments to play in tune and the other with where to place the mpc on the cork. These work in tandem to some extent. Obviously, if you are biting too hard, it's going to have an effect on the intonation. So, that issue has to be addressed.

But as a general rule, it can't be denied that pushing the mpc in will raise the overall pitch and pulling the mpc out will lower it. If you're playing outside on a very hot day, you'll have to pull the mpc out a bit to avoid playing sharp. If it's really cold, the opposite is true, and you'll have to push the mpc in to raise the pitch or you'll be playing flat.

Once the mpc is in the optimal position, you'll still have to make subtle adjustments, largely subconscious, using your ear to stay in tune. Training your ear using a drone & matching tones is a good way to develop that skill. And in doing so, it will be obvious if you are biting too hard in the upper register. You'll have to relax your embouchure to stay in tune up there.

Probably all this has been covered already earlier in this thread. But I don't think it's correct to deny the fact that pushing the mpc in raises the pitch and pulling it out lowers it. That's a fact you can prove with a tuner if you have any doubt.
 
My thought as well. There are two somewhat separate issues being discussed here. One has to do with embouchure & voicing adjustments to play in tune and the other with where to place the mpc on the cork. These work in tandem to some extent. Obviously, if you are biting too hard, it's going to have an effect on the intonation. So, that issue has to be addressed.
Another factor is the chamber size and saxophone/mouthpiece matching.

See:


OK, so that is about people using modern mouthpieces on vintage horns, but it does show how complex the whole issue is.

What we often find with smaller chamber mouthpieces is you need to pull them out a bit more on the neck to tune the notes (based on a note in the low/midrange). Because there is less of the shank covering the cork, that extra bit of internal bore adds to the chamber volume to help make up the missing cone. In this case we now basically have a longer saxophone. It seems to be that this affects the higher register more than the lower register. If you want to delve more deeply into the acoustics, you will find that:

  • Length of air column (in the cone or tube) affects the high register more.
  • Volume of air column affects the low register more.
If the air column is too long it mainly affects notes above G, which may tend to be flat. But you often need to push larger chambered mouthpieces on more to tune to a low/midrange note . This may not affect the low notes so much (as they are affected more by volume rather than length) but can make the high notes sharp due to the shorter air column.

So:

  • Thin mouthpiece pulled off the neck to tune = high notes are flatter relative to low notes
  • Fat mouthpiece pushed on to tune = high notes are sharper relative to low notes because air column is too short
We need a compromise.
 
But I don't think it's correct to deny the fact that pushing the mpc in raises the pitch and pulling it out lowers it. That's a fact you can prove with a tuner if you have any doubt.
Proven today when I tried different positions against the tuner, and to be fair something I knew.

What confused me was the conflict between 'if sharp pull mpc out' vs 'push mpc in and relax jaw more'. However Duke does say to push in if sharp in the upper register when comparing B3 to B1.

Also bear in mind you don't need to believe or follow everything you read on the internet.
Generally I agree, but since this advice was from an accomplished player under the Yamaha banner I thought it might have some credibility.

Practice more, surf the net less!
 
This is contrary to the advice I've read here and in this article:
I didn't read all the article, small print hard to read on a sleepy Sunday afternoon. 🙂

What the ariticle is referring to is to give you enough leeway to adjust intonation throughout the range. Thus relaxing the embouchure a touch to compensate a wee bit of sharpness gives you more latitude, a place to go. Plus it makes scooping up notes easier.
 
Rule of thumb is always "tune sharp, play flat".
Most of the reasons have already been discussed here in this thread but there is another one, which is, that when your embouchure tires, you start automatically playing flat.
Especially when you play longer sessions, or gigs, this becomes a real issue because after 90 min of blowing you will inevitably feel fatigue and that's only halfway through most gigs. So why not make it a feature, save energy in the process and stay in tune for most of the gig.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,324
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom