Miscellaneous Garageband and iPad model version.

DavidUK

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,133
Location
Near Evesham, Worcestershire
Just toying with the idea of buying a refurbed iPad for Garageband.

I can use it on my MacBook but would prefer a more portable tablet.

My old iPad 3 (2012) has a dead battery and won't accept updates any more.

What version of iPad would be a good compromise between cost and some future proofing?
I just looked at iPad 5 (2017 on) for £130, here: Apple iPad 5 32GB Wi-Fi Gold Good

But they have so many model options it's tricky to know what to go for. It's just for Garageband and some browsing.

I have a camera adapter for my old iPad which lets me charge it and connect another device (USB mic) at the same time. Not sure what a newer model needs in this respect?

Thanks all.
 
Two comments.
1, I would recommend getting an M1 iPad rather than the one you refer to. 2021 or so. Mostly because …

2, Logic is now available for iPad and it’s much easier to use than Garageband.

I understand it’s more money, but I use mine every day (I’m typing on it now…)
 
Is Logic related to Garageband?

I'll have a Google...

Anyone else moved from Garageband to Logic?

Had a Google... I don't record often enough to justify the ongoing Logic subs cost. For instance, at present I'm thinking of recording a brief play of three or four tenors using the same tune just to compare them, and maybe ask what others here think.
I could do this on my MacBook with Garageband.
But Logic could well be interesting for players recording regularly.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, for your use case Garageband is fine. It’s capable of quite a bit; as an experiment several years ago I recorded a complete tune in Garageband, and using the iPad internal mic for recording the soprano. View: https://soundcloud.com/skeller047/seventh-haven


However a better mic would have improved the sound quality of the sax track. A USB mic can plug directly in, or you can use an inexpensive audio interface if it’s bus-powered. These options eat battery life…. I put the iPad on a pillow, which was on a couch, for the Seventh Haven recording. The mic is omnidirectional, and this reduced ambient noise.
 
Is Logic related to Garageband?

I'll have a Google...

Anyone else moved from Garageband to Logic?

Had a Google... I don't record often enough to justify the ongoing Logic subs cost. For instance, at present I'm thinking of recording a brief play of three or four tenors using the same tune just to compare them, and maybe ask what others here think.
I could do this on my MacBook with Garageband.
But Logic could well be interesting for players recording regularly.
Yes GarageBand is the little brother of Logic Pro.

GarageBand has evolved a lot over the years - I think it started out not being able to record audio, and was based upon drag-drop loops etc

It’s the same as any software and depends upon how involved (complex) you get. Most entry level software these days seems to carry out basic tasks as well as the full fat ones. This is great, until you have a project that finally pushes too far and all of a sudden you find that the software is incapable of delivering what your creativity is demanding.

My only recent experience with the two back-to-back was a vocal with backing track. It was created in GarageBand and I am going to edit the vocal and re-score/rewrite/re-program the backing.
I thought it would be easier to keep in the GarageBand project but it was doing some odd things compared to Logic that really annoyed me, so I ditched it and moved it to Logic Pro.

I’ve had similar experiences when writing a book with images twenty years ago - MS Word was so clunky whereas MS Publisher was far nicer and quicker.

Same with photos. When I was a more serious photographer, getting the full Photoshop was a headache reliever.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,342
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom