Playing the saxophone First Lesson Let-Down.

I'd wait and see how this new teacher deals with his unprofessional start, but I'd also start looking for another!
I think the first 'lesson' is likely to be longer than subsequent ones, as there is quite a lot of discussion required, especially for beginners....but 2 hours seems a lot.

I doubt I'd find as good a teacher around here, but, being lazy, I'd probably benefit from someone a bit stricter who sets clearer 'targets' and expects more from me.
It's 'comfortable' to have a laid-back teacher, but some(most?) of us need to be pushed a bit.
I have gone from weekly to fortnightly lessons, nominally 1 hour each (including 'chat'!).
I must have funded a new car for him by now.....and my playing/reading is still cr@p!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As to tough teachers, OG knows of mine and Griff does know her. I had been playing for a year before I started taking lessons but my first one was a shock to have all my bad habits and poor technique pointed out. A year on and she has got me to being technically a much better player and begining to understand what playing is about. She also tutored me to pass Grade 5 theory with distinction. Sometimes it is good to get a teacher who's style is very different to your own!
YC

Other than your sax coach having an opposing personality to yours YC, I would agree. She is excellent and provided you with what you needed. Other clients, describe her as a complete pussy cat.

The difference between those who think of themselves as a teacher and a coach, is teachers push you in the direction they believe best for you from the point of their superior knowledge, whereas a coach helps you to find your route by allowing you to feel the differences between various techniques and encourages you to make the decision.

My brain hurts Colin.
 
Yes, I was a management trainer as well and being used to taking a coaching approach with adults it comes as a double surprise to have someone taking a directional teaching approach with you; one because someone is telling you what you are doing wrong and two because you are told what to do to put it right, as opposed to being offered options and making up your own mind to fit the circumstances.

Your brain only hurts me when you hit me with it, Bill.
YC
 
Blimey, this thread grew! I got a text back from the guy, it basically states that he had a last minute engagement at the school where he works and that he didn't have my details to call me...etc. I wasn't really happy with this excuse, he obviously just plain forgot which is bad enough but then states that on second thoughts he can't take me on anyway because he's too busy this term. Well I wish he'd worked this out sooner! It's interesting to note that he is a "Premium Member" on musicteachers.co.uk.....premium member, indeed.
Anyway, I called a another teacher and we're set up for a 1 hour session next week. He originally said 1/2 an hour as he thought the muscles in my mouth might seize up for any longer as I've only been playing for 2 weeks but I reassured him that I have been playing every night (between 1/2 an hour and an hour) since I bought my sax and using one of the many DIY beginner books....saying that, maybe I've got it all wrong so far and after 30 mins next week my face will explode! I really hope not.
 
I certainly think you need an hour, at least the first time, because of things your 'coach' should, IMO, do....like, for example, having a blow of your sax to be sure it is OK, identifying your starting level and obvious 'bad habits', and discussing your aims and 'aspirations'.
(I found it encouraging to hear how good my sax could sound, in the right hands!)
 
Yes, I was a management trainer as well and being used to taking a coaching approach with adults it comes as a double surprise to have someone taking a directional teaching approach with you; one because someone is telling you what you are doing wrong and two because you are told what to do to put it right, as opposed to being offered options and making up your own mind to fit the circumstances.

Your brain only hurts me when you hit me with it, Bill.
YC

One probably needs a bit of 'direction' in the early stages of learning an instrument; the 'discussion of options' comes when you become more competent to make such judgements.
Management is (or should be!) much less 'prescriptive' and based more on ...dare I say it?... common-sense, so can involve a lot more discussion.There are very few 'one solution fits all' answers in managing people πŸ™‚

Where music 'coaches' need flexibility and sensitivity is in identifying the appropriate 'style' for motivating and communicating with individual students ....as I said earlier, I personally would probably have benefited from being pushed harder.
 
Blimey, this thread grew! I got a text back from the guy, it basically states that he had a last minute engagement at the school where he works and that he didn't have my details to call me...etc. I wasn't really happy with this excuse, he obviously just plain forgot which is bad enough but then states that on second thoughts he can't take me on anyway because he's too busy this term. Well I wish he'd worked this out sooner! It's interesting to note that he is a "Premium Member" on musicteachers.co.uk.....premium member, indeed.
.

Leave it a few months then book him again with a fictitious name and an address out in the middle of nowhere.
 
On the matter of motivation, my teacher/tutor does just that, he is quick to offer constructive criticism and praise. He has to do so in order to make sure I do things the correct way and to keeps me in the right direction.
Last week I spent an afternoon with a friend of mine who plays keyboard and I was endeavouring to accompany him, I came away very depressed as I soon realised I had so much more to learn and was nowhere as good as I thought I was.
I have not felt like practising since, but I shall,( today) and my tutor will pick me up and relight the enthusiasm I have.
I will never give up but sometimes you need the support that only a professional can give.
 
I'm quite excited about my lesson on Wednesday now. The guy seemed really nice and easy to talk to on the phone. I do wonder what he'll make of my playing so far though. I've got this horrible feeling that he'll cringe at my efforts! I'm sure he won't or at least he'll hide it well!
 
Hi all i also have a concern over my teacher. here goes, I have been takeing lessons with a teacher from my village he is very good
[i think] he was concentrating on my reading and my timeing. i paid Β£65 for 6half hour lessons. about april of this year i was not very well and after that iv had to put all my spare money into my gradsons ice hockey. Anyway after spending all that money i have never had as much as a call to ask how i am, or if i am coming back, ect Now that make me think they dont think anything of you its just money nothing more. when i was teaching as a driving instructor i cared for my pupils i they cancled a few lessons i would call and see if they were ok and encourage them to keep up there lessons if money was a problem i would try and help in anyway i could. So do i go back to him or not ???????????????? thanks Tom.
 
It can be a mistake to judge others by your own standards. In this case it may be that he thinks you don't want to be nagged into more lessons...

If the lessons went well, and you got on well I'd go back. seems a fair price to me. If there were pobalems with the lessons, I'd look somewhere else.
 
I think it's up to you, Tom, to re-establish contact....after all, it is your money, and he may have simply forgotten.
Did you explain at the time that you were not well and would need to postpone starting?
If not, then all the more reason, IMO, to be 'conciliatory', as it would have been the courteous thing to do.

Driving instruction has, again IMO, a different sort of 'culture', where the instructors are more expected to 'drive things along' (sorry about that!!).

My sax coach is very laid-back and is inclined to let me decide when I wish to resume lessons after our regular 'Summer & Christmas breaks', although he might just phone to find-out, so that he can schedule me in.

(More or less simultaneous post with Kev, and much the same advice!)
 
Speaking from the other side of the story, often I get let down gently when people don't want to continue lessons. I think it reflects well on the student (it's much nicer than a student just quitting, anyway) when they have the courtesy to explain why they're taking a break from my tuition. I suspect that in most cases the stated reason is only part of the story, but that's fair enough, I know from my own experience with tutors of various disciplines that life takes over from hobbies like sax playing.

I do think that learning to drive is a little different since for one thing a learner driver is not allowed to drive unaccompanied, and also since obtaining a licence is a definite one-off goal. Neither is true for sax lessons, a student is quite at liberty to put their own effort in at their own pace, with or without a tutor.

While I perhaps should enquire as to the health of students who have 'taken a break', I don't think it would always be welcome. I'm not the friend of the student, it's a professional relationship on their terms, and I tend to speak when spoken to - if someone mentions health problems of their own or of loved ones I'll enquire then, otherwise it's not really my business, is it?

Am I doing this all wrong? You've worried me now!??

Nick

P.S. Tom, if you were a student of mine I'd be really happy if you decided to restart lessons with me! Shows I must be doing something right.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No, I think you have it absolutely right, Nick. Keeping it 'friendly but professional and impersonal' is IMO, most appropriate, in most cases.

I have a more personal relationship with my teacher, because we have become, over a couple of years, friends as well as teacher/student ...there is not all that much difference in our ages and there is no danger of 'friendly comments' being 'misconstrued'.

Actually, I am going to hear him play tonight, in a Glenn Miller/Frank Sinatra Tribute concert.

But it is simple courtesy, on both sides, to keep each other informed of, for example,any changes in scheduling or 'objectives'.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just to update for anyone that's interested. I have a new teacher as of two weeks now, he's great, he addressed a few beginners bad habits I picked up, such as; scooping. This was corrected by going back to the more traditional bottom lip over teeth method that I'd neglected (stupidly). Once my embouchure was improved, a good tone came along too as well as decent volume control and what is apparently a good subtone. Nice.
He's got me going through scales and warm-up/fingering exercises as well as chucking in a few songs too (pink panther, walking on the moon, summertime). I'm really enjoying it and have been practising every day for almost 4 weeks with a couple of exceptions.
I really am loving learning the sax and I can't stop (evidently) banging on about it.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,510
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom