- Messages
- 18,052
- Location
- Sunny Southampton
It should be there nowThe page can't be found.
Last edited:
It should be there nowThe page can't be found.
Don't think so..
No ?Never seen that.
It’s certainly a gap in notated directionThe question posed in this thread really intrigued me. Throughout college when the band director specified a "breath entrance" or in a solo where starting a phrase without tonguing I just penciled in "don't tongue" or "no tongue" over the first note. I just spent a great deal of time researching online to try to find an articulation mark or sign directing a "breath attack" (I hate that word.) or "breath entrance". Finding none, I came up with my own as shown below. It is simple and intuitive and quite easily entered in a notation program.
View attachment 14560
That works very well. You probably only need to add the text the first time it appears. The slur/tie from a rest would be enough after that.The question posed in this thread really intrigued me. Throughout college when the band director specified a "breath entrance" or in a solo where starting a phrase without tonguing I just penciled in "don't tongue" or "no tongue" over the first note. I just spent a great deal of time researching online to try to find an articulation mark or sign directing a "breath attack" (I hate that word.) or "breath entrance". Finding none, I came up with my own as shown below. It is simple and intuitive and quite easily entered in a notation program.
View attachment 14560
The slur would make me think it's a scoop. This whole thing is such a rare occurrence. The words no tongue ought to suffice if for some reason that really is a meaningful direction. In 40 years of playing professionally I can honestly say I've never been given that instruction. Doing any kind of unconvenetional articulation is fine, but it's normally as a soloist making their own decision.That works very well. You probably only need to add the text the first time it appears. The slur/tie from a rest would be enough after that.
In 40 years of playing professionally I can honestly say I've never been given that instruction. Doing any kind of unconvenetional articulation is fine, but it's normally as a soloist making their own decision. . . If there is no tongue, the note will have an imprecise start so I don't see how it is useful for ensemble playing without some further direction about how to make "no tongue" more precise and meaningful.
In the area of symphonic band or wind ensemble playing, William Revelli had a great influence on conducting styles and interpretation. Listening to recordings of his groups the wind ensemble sounds very much like a string orchestra in slower, more melodic pieces.