Playing the saxophone Does Growling affect your Throat

… my Hmmm turns to something vaguely Vvvv-ish when I start a Hmm then part my lips the smallest amounts and let air through my mouth - lips vibrate like a reed. Too early to try it with a sax, but something before @jbtsax wakes up and sees your comment.
 
That's actually my point - you can't make a V sound without using your lips and my lips are too busy not letting any air out where air shouldn't be escaping and cushioning the reed to do anything else as, I assume, are those of everyone else.
 
Must apologize, I always make the same mistake, it's the Uvula and not the Epiglotis that needs to waggle.
All three methods and more besides can be found demonstrated by Steve Douglas on his "Rock and Roll Saxophone" VHS produced by HOTLICKS. Unfortunately seems to be no longer available.
What a shame it’s no longer available! I wonder if EBay has any old copies? Although I don’t have a vhs video player any more.
 
Okay, field report: I can’t growl at all following those instructions (the ‘humming’ ones)
[BGCOLOR=transparent]- [/BGCOLOR][BGCOLOR=transparent]different strokes for different folks. [/BGCOLOR]
[BGCOLOR=transparent]What I [/BGCOLOR]used[BGCOLOR=transparent] to do for a growl, and it still works for me, is simply sing along with my playing, but my old preferred method of dirtying up the sound was to allow the higher harmonics to sound through the note (can’t go there until I trust all the notes in ‘basic’ pitch🙂)[/BGCOLOR]
 
I'm really sorry but I don't understand your explanation at all. How are you supposed to make a Vvvvv sound? I can only assume what I'm describing as argh, you're describing as Vvvv.

Please don't overthink it. It is really very simple. Blow a fast airstream at the palm of your hand. Now do it while you are humming a pitch. Vvvvv is the closest way I can think of to describe the sound. Once the lips close it goes instantly to hmmmmm. When the lips open it goes back to the Vvvvvv sound. What your vocal cords are doing is identical in each instance.
 
I think we're describing the exact same thing, using different phonetics because we have different accents.

As it happens, at 1.57 Ferreira gives the answer to my question as he, too, says he can feel the resonance at the back of his throat. Hmm, resonance; I think that may be the better word to describe the sensation.
 
My goodness me this is not rocket science.
Simply purse your lips and blow a stream of air into the palm of your hand.
Now do the same thing and make a sound with your voice box/vocal chords at the same time.
If you "do your dishes with fairy liquid for hands as soft as your face" you may be able to detect a vibration in the airstream. You'll certainly feel it in your lips.
Now do the same thing making a more guteral sound with your voice box/vocal chords and you should be able to detect an even more pronounced vibration in the airstream.
It's this vibration in the airstream that causes the distortion in the note.
You haven't changed anything in the way you've produced the airstream you've simply added the sound from your voice box/vocal chords to it.
Since we play with our top teeth on the mouthpiece you will also experience a resonance in yer old cranium skull bones, as well as being able to hear the note you're singing in the back of your throat.
I rest my case yer honour, may the saxophone force be with you all and sundry - okay it's wensday but never mind 😀
 
Last edited:
Oh dear, how embarrassing - thanks @kevgermany for spotting my typo. I owe you a Bavarian beer or two 😱 the next time you're in the Nähe von High del Berg.
The intentional typos in the last line are of course a play on words. 😉
 
Last edited:
Rather drastic, methinks. Or do you mean purse?
Better than piercing you epiglottis though.

1522859805164.webp
 
It's all spike's fault for mixing up the esophagus, the epiglottis and the uvula.
I was always very good in biology until they started cutting up rats, after that I spent most of my time hiding in the art room.
I could've quite easily become a talented brain surgeon but it was that one lesson cutting up rats that lead me to being a musician.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,616
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom