Playing the saxophone Does Growling affect your Throat

Talking about it seems to cause some confusion.
Maybe this will help somebody - it's a lesson on the subject by Johnny Ferreira.
He demonstrates how to do it by humming, growling and even adding some flutter tongue

Johnny Ferreira is great. He just looks and sounds like he's lived a life and just about survived.
 
you can hum instead of growling and it's not so bad on the throat
The note created by the vocal chords should just be sufficient to produce a distortion in the airflow.

Humming at the same time one is playing produces a "Growl".

This cropped up for me recently.

It is true that actually growling should not be necessary, and will be bad for your throat if you do a lot of growling on the saxophone (which I have done).

Humming plus saxophone tone does create a growl, but very often it's down to which note you are actually humming relative to the saxophone note. I don't think there is an exact formula so I prefer a trial end error approach rather than a dogmatic " hum a major 3rd above the note" approach.

I find if you practice playing a single note while varying the hum you find the "sweet growl spot" and sooner or later it just becomes second nature.

This is what I advise here:

 
When I have a high pressure power gig with a lot of driving Rock & Roll (love it) and use a fair amount of growl (hum technique-pitch above the sax note) I do have a little throat irritation the next day or two (clearing the throat). I have had it for many years.

I read on a sax message board years ago that if one has throat irritation after using it that one is doing it (the growl) incorrectly.
Guess I have been doing it wrong since 1956 :clapping: when I learned how to do it by a local blues player in 1957.

I also used that example (hum) in my Rock & Roll book-2nd Edition but also noted some other ways of doing it such as humming a 3rd above the note being played (I have seen that description) or clearing your throat. Hey if it works for you that is all that matters. There is always more than one way to make these effects (flutter, subtone, etc.)

Regarding the growl I do suggest (for a beginner) that you start with only the mouthpiece/reed first then the m/p attached to the neck then the entire sax. That can make it a little easier on the coordination of the airflow. But just a suggeston.

I also read some sax players talking about using it (growl) sparingly. Not sure how many low down dives they haved gigged in. No one ever tells a guitar player to use his fuzz tone, metal tone or grunge tone sparingly and the crowd loves it!
Have some fun :sax:
 
It is true that actually growling should not be necessary, and will be bad for your throat if you do a lot of growling on the saxophone (which I have done).
No, is not true. It can be bad to your throat if you're not doing it right. Some guys can growl a lot without having any problems. My friend had to take a 4-5 week long break for some surgery vocal cord surgery. Can you imagine to just have soup for 5 weeks. He is now back growling but he does it in a more gentle way. "More vocal cord friendly".

Play a low tone and then hum the tone one octave up. You get a "growl" with a multiple tone. I think that was one of Clarence Clemons secrets.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom