Mike, I'll give you an example. My son's teacher gave him Satie's Jack In the Box to play on clarinet. He hates it. Because it doesn't flow or have patterns he can relate to, it flies off in odd directions. It's not conditioning - it personal preference. While I wouldn't consider it atonal, I find it difficult as music, for similar reasons. It won't be on my playlist, and it won't be on his. It won't be on his practice list for much longer, either.
Sure it's conditioning. Your son has been bombarded by music and sound all his life and his brain assimilates this incessantly and organizes patterns that are well suited for your son to coincide with his environment, which is called conditioning. The beauty of it is how the variances exemplify themselves.
He cannot help but be influenced by every little nuance that comes across his ears. You don't call that conditioning? You're conditioned, I'm conditioned, no one is exempt from conditioning. Personal preference is a result of conditioning. I'll add another important aspect to conditioning and that word is environment. Environment dictates to us, not the other way around. Do not get this confused by not having free will, which I assume you are. We all have free will to do with what we want within that conditioning process, or in those parameters.
Is your reasoning here, as in your example that Jack in the Box is not atonal, which it's not, is a good example of tonality being displayed and not accepted being that it's tonal? Personally, I'm not big on the piece either, but it does flow, and that's merely my own opinion. I would have to understand your son, and his tastes to pinpoint why he doesn't like it. Maybe because it's difficult for him to play? Maybe if he found it easier he would be less critical of it? I don't know, because i don't know your son. But I don't have to know your son to know that whatever it is he does and doesn't like is a direct result of his environment as well as how he was conditioned within his environment.
Hey, I wanted to stay out of your hair, but you beg the issue....
Jazzaferri wrote:
Mike my understanding of music history is not great but I believe that in Western music listeners have,over the last 4 centuries, become more comfortable with dissonance. I read in one of my horrible tomes that I have to read for school that it was during the 18th century that the major third interval came to be thought of as consonant.
Yes, I believe this to be true. I can only relate to that as being, dissonance over time, is disseminated more which allows the ear to 'adjust'. I'd say in the last 80 or so years dissonant sounding sequence has made an impact as a viable alternative in expression. The ear is evolving and evolution is a very slow process but it is a deliberate process. I think John Cage has made a huge impact, relatively speaking, on the concepts of sound and how sound relates to each and every one of us, in respect to what we take for granted and what we choose to use as important.