Theory & Impro Do you know your 4ths?

Here's a ridiculous thought. Let's go waaaaaaaaaaaaaay back in time. If a Dmaj scale was always played to a Cmaj chord and everyone played it because they didn't know any better, it would have conditioned their brains to think in those terms hamonically. Then some radically thinking individual comes along and decides to play a Dmaj scale to a Dmaj chord. It would hurt to hear it only because of the conditioning process. Am I off base in this assumption?

Since I listened to a couple of your compositions, and I am aware of your desire of having them played in lifts, I can safely say that you must borrow the Schönberg and read the part about parallel fifths. You will love it.

About the conditioning process, in music there are some "natural" elements that bias our cognitive approach. I don't think Dmaj/Cmaj would have been acceptable for uneducated ears, but we took few centuries to accept a self standing 9th on a chord.

In general I agree, though.
 
Here's a ridiculous thought. Let's go waaaaaaaaaaaaaay back in time. If a Dmaj scale was always played to a Cmaj chord and everyone played it because they didn't know any better, it would have conditioned their brains to think in those terms hamonically. Then some radically thinking individual comes along and decides to play a Dmaj scale to a Dmaj chord. It would hurt to hear it only because of the conditioning process. Am I off base in this assumption?

Or, would they 'automatically' feel 'right' to hear the Dmaj scale played with the Dmaj chord? Is there something inherent in us that decides harmonic cohesion on a collective level?

Presently, if any particular musician wants to play a Dmaj scale to a Cmaj chord, even if it's considered crass to do so, it just might sound good to the musician who is deciding to play it that way and there isn't an individual alive who could definitively state that it's incorrect. It's that musician's right to create that type of tension, even if that particular choice is stacked against the elements!

Extreme thinking? Not at all...

If we can't agree on which temperament to use, what chance has this got? Each proponent of non-standard temperament uses that argument that they sound better, usually based on ratios between frequncies, and the resulting intervals. I don't think this is conditioning, rather it's sensitive ears.
 
Okay, if you say so! Conditioning has nothing to do with it.......
Ratio's between frequencies are decided by condition, In my humblest of opinions...
If it bothers you all that much then simply prove that my assessment is incorrect.

Let me ask you a question. In my experience those that respect atonality have no problems whatsoever with tonality.
In fact they co-exist quite nicely in an elegant balance. yet those who are grounded in tonality have issues with atonality.
I've always found that quite odd, as in musician's/composer's who place limitations on their craft. It seems to defy your signature.
 
aldevis .. with all due deference as I am a newbie. Traditional 12 bar blues is all dominant 7 chords in a major blues. Yes when jazz got hold of blues all sorts of chord subs came into play. 6 or 69 chords would be way to0 sweet and settled sounding for most of the blues we play.

The rhythm section got it after and found it quite entertaining as well. Now If I had done the F# (on alto) the tune is in Bb for the whole chorus I think maybe the listeners would have found that more than passing strange. My point was only to illustrate that our audience is OFTEN uncomfortable if a piece gets a long way out of the box for a prolonged period.

But then I just play for the joy of making music.

Oh and to bring us back on topic, I do practice 4ths. but not in the way that others have described here. I do an interval etude where I start on a root and go up or down first a semi then to root then whole tone root min3 root etc.

Tritone practice anyone
 
Last edited by a moderator:
aldevis .. with all due deference as I am a newbie. Traditional 12 bar blues is all dominant 7 chords in a major blues.

No deference due, please. I am on this forum because anyone might have something to teach me.

About the "traditional" blues... listen to 12 bars forms from 1920 till now... dominant 7th is a formalized form from the late 50s. If you analize Bix Beiderbeck you will be surprised.

I was joking about the rhythm section, but up to a point. If you know what you are doing a good rhythm section will follow you.
And that is REAL pleasure.
 
Bix is not exactly my idea of a really bluesy guy although he was pretty decent in the right company. I just listened to Singing the Blues Frankie Trumbauer and his Orchestra with Bix It's a little pretty at times but definitely dominant sounding

My ideal early blues guys playing real blues were Charlie Patton, Robert Johnson, Lonnie Johnson, Son House, Big Bill Broonzy if you want the influence in Britain, certainly early Pops and Bechet on the jazzy side. Bessie Smith Ma Rainey Bessie Smith filling in for the ladies.

In the late 60's I played Chicago style electric blues (mostly bass and vocals) for several years. Really loved that style. Still do a few really bluesy blues numbers although I suspect my solos have been somewhat contaminated by jazz now. LOL

When I go back to school next week I will check with Eric LeBlanc our jazz history instructor. He is an acknowledged world authority on the blues and has just come out with a new book on the subject and will give me a detailed insight.

Mike my understanding of music history is not great but I believe that in Western music listeners have,over the last 4 centuries, become more comfortable with dissonance. I read in one of my horrible tomes that I have to read for school that it was during the 18th century that the major third interval came to be thought of as consonant.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mike, I'll give you an example. My son's teacher gave him Satie's Jack In the Box to play on clarinet. He hates it. Because it doesn't flow or have patterns he can relate to, it flies off in odd directions. It's not conditioning - it personal preference. While I wouldn't consider it atonal, I find it difficult as music, for similar reasons. It won't be on my playlist, and it won't be on his. It won't be on his practice list for much longer, either.
 
My ideal early blues guys playing real blues were Charlie Patton, Robert Johnson, Lonnie Johnson, Son House, Big Bill Broonzy if you want the influence in Britain, certainly early Pops and Bechet on the jazzy side. Bessie Smith Ma Rainey Bessie Smith filling in for the ladies.

In the late 60's I played Chicago style electric blues (mostly bass and vocals) for several years.

Dominants, you are right. I was referring to a jazz environment, where the practice of maj 7 on the blues went lost in the 60s.
I still squeeze it when I can, though.
 
Mike, I'll give you an example. My son's teacher gave him Satie's Jack In the Box to play on clarinet. He hates it. Because it doesn't flow or have patterns he can relate to, it flies off in odd directions. It's not conditioning - it personal preference. While I wouldn't consider it atonal, I find it difficult as music, for similar reasons. It won't be on my playlist, and it won't be on his. It won't be on his practice list for much longer, either.

Sure it's conditioning. Your son has been bombarded by music and sound all his life and his brain assimilates this incessantly and organizes patterns that are well suited for your son to coincide with his environment, which is called conditioning. The beauty of it is how the variances exemplify themselves.

He cannot help but be influenced by every little nuance that comes across his ears. You don't call that conditioning? You're conditioned, I'm conditioned, no one is exempt from conditioning. Personal preference is a result of conditioning. I'll add another important aspect to conditioning and that word is environment. Environment dictates to us, not the other way around. Do not get this confused by not having free will, which I assume you are. We all have free will to do with what we want within that conditioning process, or in those parameters.

Is your reasoning here, as in your example that Jack in the Box is not atonal, which it's not, is a good example of tonality being displayed and not accepted being that it's tonal? Personally, I'm not big on the piece either, but it does flow, and that's merely my own opinion. I would have to understand your son, and his tastes to pinpoint why he doesn't like it. Maybe because it's difficult for him to play? Maybe if he found it easier he would be less critical of it? I don't know, because i don't know your son. But I don't have to know your son to know that whatever it is he does and doesn't like is a direct result of his environment as well as how he was conditioned within his environment.

Hey, I wanted to stay out of your hair, but you beg the issue....

Jazzaferri wrote:
Mike my understanding of music history is not great but I believe that in Western music listeners have,over the last 4 centuries, become more comfortable with dissonance. I read in one of my horrible tomes that I have to read for school that it was during the 18th century that the major third interval came to be thought of as consonant.

Yes, I believe this to be true. I can only relate to that as being, dissonance over time, is disseminated more which allows the ear to 'adjust'. I'd say in the last 80 or so years dissonant sounding sequence has made an impact as a viable alternative in expression. The ear is evolving and evolution is a very slow process but it is a deliberate process. I think John Cage has made a huge impact, relatively speaking, on the concepts of sound and how sound relates to each and every one of us, in respect to what we take for granted and what we choose to use as important.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think that thirds were regarded as dissonant (4ths were until quite late on). Thirds are regarded as "imperfect" as they cannot be defined by a simle ratio such as 1:1 (unison) 1:2 (octave) 3:2 fifth etc. Thsi concept of "perfection" through the ratios goes right back to Plato and is a theoretical "ideal", not necessarily related to actual performance practice.
 
Is your reasoning here, as in your example that Jack in the Box is not atonal, which it's not, is a good example of tonality being displayed and not accepted being that it's tonal? Personally, I'm not big on the piece either, but it does flow, and that's merely my own opinion. I would have to understand your son, and his tastes to pinpoint why he doesn't like it. Maybe because it's difficult for him to play? Maybe if he found it easier he would be less critical of it? I don't know, because i don't know your son. But I don't have to know your son to know that whatever it is he does and doesn't like is a direct result of his environment as well as how he was conditioned within his environment.

He's a lad with very strong musical ideas and a really good ear for music, even though I say it myself. He picked up his first clarinet and picked out March of the Toreadors by ear, with no prior experence or notes. Up till the he'd done little more than a few ditties on the recorder.

The point with the Satie is not whether it's atonal (but I agree with you), but that it doesn't flow - for him. It's irational and makes him really angry. Personal choice - his. Not us putting him off.
 
Many would say they are in equal temperament. And it's that we're conditioned to treat them as OK by their ubiquity. Personally I like them and always have. Just enough tension to avoid being bland.
You're right. In ET thirds are borderline out-of-tune as they are way too wide. This is something that is very obvious on stringed instruments.

The only word that describes a really good third in a chord as played by a good viol consort or string quartet (or vocal consort) in something like Velotti or 1/6 coma meantone is "euphonious" it really does provide that melting sound that makes the hair on the back of your neck stand up. A properly tuned chord really pings in the way that an ET one doesn't....
 
Found an interesting exercise playing 4th over a blues scale...initially I've found it very tricky playing the diatonic 4ths (those within the scale as opposed to the perfect 4ths) - but then I've realized that in practice we are playing only 3 couples of intervals which are then reversed - so in a C blues scale (C Eb F F# G Bb C) we'll be playing 3 couple of intervals: (C F#), (Eb G), (F Bb) which are then reversed to: (F# C), (G Eb) and (Bb F) and back to the previous bunch and so on....
It might seem a pointless association but it really helps nailing this pattern (at least for me).
 
It might seem a pointless association but it really helps nailing this pattern (at least for me).

It sounds "quartal".
It reminds me of Vol 2, the one on pentatonics. It is not about 4ths, but it sounds like.
http://www.jerrybergonzi.com/books.htm
 
Last edited:
If I want to think fourths over a blues scale then I find it easier to think in terms of the related pentatonic scale and play the diatonic 3rds as many of them are actually perfect 4ths.

So for your example C blues, ignore the F# and think Eb pentatonic. Playing diatonic thirds from C would then give you C-F (4th); Eb-G (maj 3rd); F-Bb (4th); G-C (4th); Bb-Eb (4th) and by playing around with these intervals, inverting them etc, you will find some very musical phrases.

Pete
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom