Theory & Impro Do you know your 4ths?

Mike, morning, the next day...

I feel this way about it. 12 tone/atonal was a sideways step. The rules remind me of an exercise in a composition course. But they exclude so much of what went before. Schoenberg wrote beautiful, melodic work af first, these works appeal to many people. But he changed, and led others, like Berg in a very (to me) unmusical direction.

But we'll be repeating an earlier discussion. For me music is about emotion. It lifts me or it depresses me, it calms me or it makes me mad. I can't hear music without being affected by it.

I'm a big nature lover - spent years in Africa, and most of my holidays were in the bush. I love the sounds. Perhaps there's an atonal element, but there's a much larger tonal element, even if it is the raucous duet of black collared barbets. But I didn't listen to the sounds as music. They told me things - it was a separate language. Sure, by it's nature, natural sounds have been incorporated into music, and have inspired many pieces. But, for instance, Messaien's magic birds leaves me cold. Perhaps it's too far from my roots. I don't know.

Each to his own. Pace.
 
music is improved by experimentation and not the history of that experimentation.

Totally agree. theory is a mean, not a goal. Thanks to theory I can work out what to do in a studio in a quite limited amount of time and get money for it.

If I have to write something I try to forget ALL the theory I know.
Musical background comes out also if I don't want, though. So I definitely prefer to have many theory-supported forms to choose from. Otherwise would probably still write 1/5/1/5 songs.
 
Was going to put the BIG ONE in this morning but surely music is improved by experimentation and not the history of that experimentation.
But music theory is more than just history. It's a distillation of previous practice into a form which one person, a composer or improvisor, can take in. That person is then better equipped to do interesting experiments than if all they had was "Listen these 5000 peices of music and try to do something better".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For me music is about emotion. It lifts me or it depresses me, it calms me or it makes me mad. I can't hear music without being affected by it.

If music moves you in a negative way, then that too qualifies as having emotive qualities. Music can anger some and in that response there is emotion or they wouldn't have acted so 'emotional' about it. When Stravinsky wrote the Rite of Spring, upon it's premier people rioted! Extreme, yes...but emotional nevertheless. They were just being emotional to an emotional piece of music. They didn't have to feel emotionally elated but they certainly were free to be emotionally disjointed.

Is serialism such a cold technique that you don't feel anything? Nothing at all? If you do in fact feel nothing I can understand. You're not alone. But it appears these things annoy you. I'm assuming Kev, that's all.
If music does indeed anger you you're an extremely passionate soul. I don't believe I've ever reached the point of having music of any kind anger me. The farthest I've ever gotten was, I didn't think it was any good.

How do you hear tonality in an atonal environment? Just asking.....
 
2nd Viennese school?

But in any case, does it matter if the theory comes later? The theory is a codification of previous practice and a good theory can suggest future developments. And the best of those developments become the basis of the next wave of theory and so on. Could Beethoven have written what he did if he hadn't studied Bach's use counterpoint, for example? I'm betting he had a pretty good theoretical understanding of that. Could Mendelssohn and Brahms have written as they did without studying Beethoven's use of key relationships, sonata form, etc etc? I doubt it. Could Charlie Parker have done what he did without a thorough knowledge of the hamonic structure of the tunes he was playing? If everyone had to invent it all from scratch every time there would be no progress.

I think the point I was making has been either misinterpreted or misunderstood.

Developments in musical theory usually follow the development of musical practice. It might be less obvious to us as we live in an age where we are used to immediate communication and the ability to have radio, TV, Internet etc disseminate ideas very quickly.

In earlier times, information and ideas travelled much more slowly. It was common for musical ideas to take 50 years to travel from say northern Europe to southern Europe: a musician at say Notre Dame Paris or the court of one noble family would visit say Florence or the court of another noble family and hear what was going on there. Eventually, someone would happen to write some of this down in a place which has survived and to which we have access. the point at which it is written down is when it becomes 'documented' but is unlikely to be the same as the point of 'invention'.

So, was recitiative invented as a device for communicating text in a "high literary style" invented in 1600 by Cavalieri et al? Unlikely. Was the use of passing and cadential 6/4 chords invented in the Baroque era when the use of bass continuo developed and the modern "rules" of harmony were codified? No - their use can be traced back at least a century further back than that, if not more. It's just that we're not aware of it having been written down much earlier.

Throughout the history of "literary" music (what we would call "art music" today) generations of composers have learnt by studying the masters of the past.

My personal gripe with a lot of 'art' music that was written mid-C20th (Second Viennese School and after etc) is that "theory" seemed to take precedence over "communication" and detached it from its audience.

No doubt there are those for whom serialism and atonal music is music. For me, most of what I have heard in that space is not music that I can get on with as it fails to communicate anything to me.
 
Is serialism such a cold technique that you don't feel anything? Nothing at all? If you do in fact feel nothing I can understand. You're not alone. But it appears these things annoy you. I'm assuming Kev, that's all.
If music does indeed anger you you're an extremely passionate soul. I don't believe I've ever reached the point of having music of any kind anger me. The farthest I've ever gotten was, I didn't think it was any good.

How do you hear tonality in an atonal environment? Just asking.....

Serialism - generally doesn't flow, doesn't move, just jerks around. Leaves me nothing to hang on to. No continuity. A bit like Mahler, who just gets going in one direction, then wizzes off in another. These things annoy me a lot. Compare this to Bach, which flows.... Goes places, smoothly.

Music moves me a lot. I think I first become aware of it when America released 'Holiday' in the mid 70s. When I put that on, didn't matter how bad I was feeling, by half way through the world was good, and by the end I was good as well. Compare that the Darth Vader theme, based on a funeral march. That angers me a lot, because something solemn and sad was turned into a trivial movie theme, maybe it's meant to stir up forboding and fear, but it cheapens the reverence and grief in the theme. Add to that it brings me back to many of the darker things in life and yes - I get mad when I hear it. Passionate I am. Black and white as well. There's very little in the middle with me. Strong feelings, strong reactions. You've probably already worked out that I can't listen to a requiem. Or most of the trivia that passes as pop. Mendelssohn has so much joy in his music..... Lifts me as well. Same for a lot of spiritual & sacred music.

I don't really here tonality in an atonal environment. It's just noise. That often needs to be shut out or drowned out...

Enough.
 
It's just noise. That often needs to be shut out or drowned out...

Enough.

I apologize Kev....I shouldn't have wrote what I originally wrote.
I was using ebonic slang in terms of you telling me enough.

I'll stay out of your hair. I simply thought it was interesting dialogue between us...
No harm, no foul....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
more rules you have, more pleasure you have in breaking them. (extreme position, I know)

Actually, it's extreme if the main intent was to break them for the sake of breaking them. If it's apparently 'broken' as an indirect approach to specific content, then that's not extreme at all.
A personal pleasure in breaking them can still be maintained as art but without much integrity, which art may be better suited to run parallel with.
Sure, art, at times, can be looked upon as an exercise in sequence, primarily. But this approach can become void of any real semblance into the character of the composer. However, it's still a viable approach to sequence for the sake of sound manipulation, but that's not a promising venture in the long run. The well can run dry real quick without any real purpose other than to break a rule for the sake of it.

Rules never existed. A rule is merely a musical representation of a particular composer that took hold and was applauded. Rules are the personal thoughts of an individual who just so happens to use sound as their point of personal expression. 'Hey, that sounds good.....let's make that a rule!' Foolishness!

Yes, the aspect of breaking rules is ludicrous. They never existed in the first place. Only individuals who partake in the ritual that only this can be done or that can be done are the frontrunners of an illusion. Anything outside those parameters are considered non-musical gibberish. Again, foolishness!
History has played an awful joke on musicians/listeners in creating a musical peer pressure that must be upheld. If it's not upheld then varying degrees of obscurity will follow to those who understand that the general musical scope is based in illusion. Public opinion verifies this.

It's always wonderful to understand how another composer thought. That's what theory actually is and it's nothing more than that, along side of popular opinion. What about minority opinion? In my opinion minority speaks louder than majority.
It's quite easy actually. If we don't want to know or understand how another composer thought musically, we don't go into their score, or transcribe their solo, or even better, lock ourselves away from any type of media so it does not create an influence.

When we learned how to talk we learned by listening to others and we mimicked them and ultimately we created our own patterns of speech that work best for us. It's primarily our own, aside from some cultural environmental cliche that most adapt to as a result of infused media.
If we don't go and try to understand a particular musical language, we're setting ourselves up for some rough times ahead in trying to speak that language. Once we learn a particular musical language, then and only then will we be able to speak it our own way.

Learn it, then let me hear what YOU have to say!
 
Rules are alive and well in music IMO. Just try playing Lydian and alt chords in bluegrass or adding 1 1/2 bars to a twelve bar blues

Our listeners tend to like what is familiar and get a thrill if we go a little out of the box. Just not too far. Thes week I played the maj 7 in an offbeat rhythmic pattern same note in the first four bars of a slow blues. Hmmmm ooops did he hit a clam, then, odd looks and discomfort til in bar 5 came back in with a more accepted bluesy line. Intellectual, yes, it was an experiment in human reaction to unexpected vibrations...... musical well I thought it rather fun watching and had a hard time playing by bar 5 as I was starting to laugh.
 
Yes, the aspect of breaking rules is ludicrous. They never existed in the first place.

At this point I am afraid that my limited control of English language might not allow to express myself properly. My apologies.

The law of gravity (Newton) and the criminal law are not the same: one is descriptive, one is prescriptive.

Musical rules are good as long as they are descriptive (if you want to sound like that you don't use parallel fifths). Less good if they are prescriptive (never use a ascending semitone on the top voice because you go to hell).

When someone decided to break the rule of parallel fifths polyphony was born.
On the other hand, some prescriptive rules are useful: if you do not respect some music writing rules, performers are very likely to play it wrong.

An interesting insight on the subject (and extremely mature) is in Schönberg harmony book: where rules come from, why we MUST follow them and why we should break them. It is an approach more traditional than expected.

On a more personal aspect, I try to break rules as a mean to find a more original, personal approach to music. Hopefully it will take forever, since I really like exploring.
 
Rules are alive and well in music IMO. Just try playing Lydian and alt chords in bluegrass or adding 1 1/2 bars to a twelve bar blues
A sadistic approach in music practice. Excellent book.
The 1/2 bar would work great if people are dancing: hip dislocations all over the place.


Our listeners tend to like what is familiar and get a thrill if we go a little out of the box. Just not too far. Thes week I played the maj 7 in an offbeat rhythmic pattern same note in the first four bars of a slow blues. Hmmmm ooops did he hit a clam, then, odd looks and discomfort til in bar 5 came back in with a more accepted bluesy line. Intellectual, yes, it was an experiment in human reaction to unexpected vibrations...... musical well I thought it rather fun watching and had a hard time playing by bar 5 as I was starting to laugh.

Here comes a forgotten rule: The chord on the first 3 bars of a blues is a 6th chord. It becomes a 7th chord on the 4th bar if you want to give the dominant sense to the IV.
I am not making this up. If you listen to Lester Young, he puts Maj 7ths continuosly. Hence the "Blues for Alice" progression.

I recommend you to practice how not to laugh and how to look at your rhythmic section on stage.
Remember that usually the saxophone player found the gig and the others are simply underpaid employees. if you start in the wrong key, or the wrong song, they are supposed to follow.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I guess my point is being missed. Yes, how we conventionally hear harmony
we expect specific tones to be played. If those tones are not presented, it 'hurts'
to listen to them. Isn't that more of a conditioning process than a rule process?

When Charlie Parker came on the scene some thought he was playing all wrong. Parker didn't feel that way because he trusted his ear.
Essentially, those who had a conditioned way of listening were vehement that it sounded ridiculous.

No one is 'bound' to merely adapt the way it's been done because we expect it that way. Even at the cost of total alienation. It's quite possible that in that psychosis of insurrection there may come something that has the potential to revolutionize something we originally thought to be ridiculous.

Here's a ridiculous thought. Let's go waaaaaaaaaaaaaay back in time. If a Dmaj scale was always played to a Cmaj chord and everyone played it because they didn't know any better, it would have conditioned their brains to think in those terms hamonically. Then some radically thinking individual comes along and decides to play a Dmaj scale to a Dmaj chord. It would hurt to hear it only because of the conditioning process. Am I off base in this assumption?

Or, would they 'automatically' feel 'right' to hear the Dmaj scale played with the Dmaj chord? Is there something inherent in us that decides harmonic cohesion on a collective level?

Presently, if any particular musician wants to play a Dmaj scale to a Cmaj chord, even if it's considered crass to do so, it just might sound good to the musician who is deciding to play it that way and there isn't an individual alive who could definitively state that it's incorrect. It's that musician's right to create that type of tension, even if that particular choice is stacked against the elements!

Extreme thinking? Not at all...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom