old git
Tremendous Bore
- Messages
- 4,008
Was going to put the BIG ONE in this morning but surely music is improved by experimentation and not the history of that experimentation.
music is improved by experimentation and not the history of that experimentation.
But music theory is more than just history. It's a distillation of previous practice into a form which one person, a composer or improvisor, can take in. That person is then better equipped to do interesting experiments than if all they had was "Listen these 5000 peices of music and try to do something better".Was going to put the BIG ONE in this morning but surely music is improved by experimentation and not the history of that experimentation.
I bet you don't succeed ;}.If I have to write something I try to forget ALL the theory I know.
For me music is about emotion. It lifts me or it depresses me, it calms me or it makes me mad. I can't hear music without being affected by it.
2nd Viennese school?
But in any case, does it matter if the theory comes later? The theory is a codification of previous practice and a good theory can suggest future developments. And the best of those developments become the basis of the next wave of theory and so on. Could Beethoven have written what he did if he hadn't studied Bach's use counterpoint, for example? I'm betting he had a pretty good theoretical understanding of that. Could Mendelssohn and Brahms have written as they did without studying Beethoven's use of key relationships, sonata form, etc etc? I doubt it. Could Charlie Parker have done what he did without a thorough knowledge of the hamonic structure of the tunes he was playing? If everyone had to invent it all from scratch every time there would be no progress.
Is serialism such a cold technique that you don't feel anything? Nothing at all? If you do in fact feel nothing I can understand. You're not alone. But it appears these things annoy you. I'm assuming Kev, that's all.
If music does indeed anger you you're an extremely passionate soul. I don't believe I've ever reached the point of having music of any kind anger me. The farthest I've ever gotten was, I didn't think it was any good.
How do you hear tonality in an atonal environment? Just asking.....
It's just noise. That often needs to be shut out or drowned out...
Enough.
I bet you don't succeed ;}.
Black and white as well
IMO the more rules there are in writing a piece the more difficult to sound unconstrained, intellectual possibly
How does this apply to Bach's 48 preludes and fugues?IMO the more rules there are in writing a piece the more difficult to sound unconstrained, intellectual possibly
How does this apply to Bach's 48 preludes and fugues?
more rules you have, more pleasure you have in breaking them. (extreme position, I know)
Yes, the aspect of breaking rules is ludicrous. They never existed in the first place.
A sadistic approach in music practice. Excellent book.Rules are alive and well in music IMO. Just try playing Lydian and alt chords in bluegrass or adding 1 1/2 bars to a twelve bar blues
Our listeners tend to like what is familiar and get a thrill if we go a little out of the box. Just not too far. Thes week I played the maj 7 in an offbeat rhythmic pattern same note in the first four bars of a slow blues. Hmmmm ooops did he hit a clam, then, odd looks and discomfort til in bar 5 came back in with a more accepted bluesy line. Intellectual, yes, it was an experiment in human reaction to unexpected vibrations...... musical well I thought it rather fun watching and had a hard time playing by bar 5 as I was starting to laugh.
