Theory & Impro Do you know your 4ths?

I enjoyed his playing, but now I can try that at home.

12! is quite a big number, and we are not considering notes' length.
And neither are we considering that you can repeat notes. Or that we play over more than one octave. Or that "blue notes" sometimes don't exactly fit onto the 12-tone system. Or that there are different articulations and tone qualities available...

If all the theory we could use was "try everything and discard what you don't like" we'd all be lost.
 
Funny thing to try: take any 12 tones series and play soulfully on a slow jazzy blues. It works.

Actually, awhile ago I toyed with the concept of improvising
with 12 tone rows. I've used them in composition but I wanted to try them
in improvisation. I realized that, that would be extremely difficult and nearly impossible
to make sure that we don't repeat a tone until we've gone through the 12 tone row completely.
So what I did do was write my own tone rows, approx. 10 or so and worked on them for two weeks, inversions, retrogrades, etc.

The only improvisation that I could come up with when I decided to use them, as in their spontaneity,
was like picking them out of a hat much like we do when we've memorized jazz lines. I had no preconceived idea which 12 tone row would come first or next, etc....12 tone is a nice technique but one I wouldn't want to bog myself down with again.

I did two actually.
Cereal-ism.......Which is part serialism on the sax......The bass however, is 12 tone rows.
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_songInfo.cfm?bandID=1176814&songID=10696621

Schoenberg Shuffle....which is total serialism with no deviation whatsoever.
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_songInfo.cfm?bandID=1176814&songID=10946641

Anyway, I'm very big on allowing my ear to figure things out. However, theory plays a vital role in many aspects of learning music.
It truly cuts to the chase and I've found this to be evident in more times than I can remember. Any sequence that we can practice, whether it's fourths, or anything that appeals to the musician's ear are worthwhile practices. Nothing can ever be lost in picking up your instrument and trying to work on something. Picking up your horn is always the key!

For me, some told me that working on 12 tones was a ridiculous waste of time. No one really uses them much in classical work and in jazz? Forget it....Only a small handful have experimented with it. However, I wanted to try it out and see for myself. In improvisation it's ridiculous actually and so much memorization is involved. Unless of course like in my Cereal-ism you could stray from it and come back to it which is probably better suited and logical.

I have a lot of respect for music theory but it's not the essence in learning how to play. Trust your ear more than you trust theory. Theory is only there to help you along and nudge you bit.....That's has been my experience....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Let's repeat a previous discussion.

If theory is so important and believed in, surrender your driving licenses until you hold a Motor Mechanic's NVQ, have completed a course in on the limit handling, spent at least six months as a racing or rally mechanic and qualified as a Road Safety Officer.

This would indicate your committal to theory and an ambition to improve your driving for the added protection of your fellow road users, surely more important than a grade eight music diploma.

Sign up here. >:)
 
Don't confuse the octatonic with the Half Diminished. The Half Dim is B to B with no alterations.


oops...wrong terminology; but I did get your hint (and that "half/whole" is a clue) - the B to B is the Locrian (aka Half Diminished) the one in questions are the Diminished (symmetrical with only 2 modes).
I've included them in my 4ths practice today and apart from getting better and faster at finding my perfect 4ths (no matter what patterns or scales) I've noticed nothing special between this exercise from others (e.g. building perfect 4ths from Pentatonic, Major, H. Minor or Neapolitan)....
Then, I thought of using the actual tones within a Diminished scale - but that is basically a pattern of a perfect 4ths next to thirds.
Still, there might be some interesting findings by mixing random scales and forths...

Just a point about the theory v practice debate:
No much theory involved as such...just the juicy challenge of nailing those 4ths.
 
Did you not enjoy his performances before?

Jazz improvisation is supposed to be a spontaneous performance, not a carefully planned, emotion free equation.

Is TV a mathematician? If so could he work out the number of different note sequences that can be played. Nearly three quarters of a century so can't be bothered to work it out but doesn't it start 12 x 11 x 10 x 9 etc and that is only using West European notation. Tuners of accordions used in Egypt have to get used to quarter tones, but Jai and Kay used them in their music so what does that do to the number of sequences?

Why not use your ears as the main judging medium?

Not that I'd noticed... and C15th isorythmic motets where that kind of game was played make my head hurt
 
Guess I'm goign to get shot down again, but to me music which relies on artificial constructs is not music. 12 tone/atonal.... a lot of modern jazz.

I need to hear the sould and emotion. and the intellectual side leaves me cold , except where it supports the emotions.
 
Hi Andy

these are diatonic 4ths in the scale of C major so not necessarily all perfect fourths: if you think only white notes, these are fourths in the sense of play a note, miss out two notes, play the next note. If you were doing the equivalent pattern in C ascending melodic minor, one of the diatonic fourths B-Eb would actually be just 2 whole tones like a major 3rd though still a fourth within the scale: CFGDEbABFGCDABEbFC

Pete
 
Hi Kev,

Diatonic just means that they are fourths coming out of the parent scale. In C major, C to F is CDEF 4 notes a fourth F to B FGAB also 4 notes is still a fourth though one is a perfect fourth, the other a tritone.

In the major, most are perfect 4ths (C-F, D-G, E-A, G-C, A-D, B-E) but one is a tritone (F-B). This is analogous to playing all the thirds in the major scale: some are major, some are minor. The value of learning the diatonic fourths in each key is that you can play the fourth based patterns while staying "inside" the harmony.

In the ascending melodic minor scale you have 4 perfect fourths (C-F,D-G,G-C,A-D), 2 tritones (Eb-A, F-B) and a major third (B-Eb).

Perhaps a classically trained musician will be able to tell us what the correct names for the tritone and the major third are in this context: diminished and double diminished?

hope that helps,

Pete
 
On the wider question of being intellectual about the music, I find it useful because trying out things like patterns in fourths, takes my ear somewhere it might not otherwise go by itself. Once I have these things under my fingers, then I do start to hear them and then they become integrated into the rest of the musical language I use. Just as when I started playing, I learnt major scales and arpeggios (i.e. patterns in 3rds), going onto stuff like this seems like a natural progression.

Pete
 
In the ascending melodic minor scale you have 4 perfect fourths (C-F,D-G,G-C,A-D), 2 tritones (Eb-A, F-B) and a major third (B-Eb).

Perhaps a classically trained musician will be able to tell us what the correct names for the tritone and the major third are in this context: diminished and double diminished?
(assuming the first note is the lower one)
Eb-A = augmented 4th
A-Eb = diminished 5th
B-Eb = diminished 4th (same as major 3rd)
Eb-B = augmented 5th (same as minor 6th)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Guess I'm goign to get shot down again, but to me music which relies on artificial constructs is not music. 12 tone/atonal.... a lot of modern jazz.

I need to hear the sould and emotion. and the intellectual side leaves me cold , except where it supports the emotions.

Hello Kev, and how are you this fine morning?...............lol
I wouldn't call 12 tone music artificial, although you certainly won't be alone in your perception of it.
Yes, 12 tone has been prfoundly treated in a negative light and the purpose of it is still debatable by many, such as yourself.
The purpose for me personally, is that it paints a different picture that you won't normally hear if played diatonically/tonally. I love it's non-resolve which is characteristic of atonality. Just another collection of colors that add to the mix. Professional artists, as in illustrators, mix all sorts of colors that may not be ordinarily mixed to get that right catalyst of color that would represent their illustration more coherently. 12 tone music is just that. But I will agree with you if 12 tone is tried to be applied in an improvisational setting. Yes, it can be cold and it's highly laborius to even want to attempt to present it. I personally find nothing wrong with music that is presented in a cold light. I like opposite ends of the spectrum. We can't play flatted 5th's our whole life.
Let me ask you? Do the ambient sounds of nature around you leave you cold? Nature exudes atonality every waking second of the day without interruption. It's indeterminate and I would give that the same benefit as anything determinate as you would classify as music. Kev, every sound you hear and regardless if you enjoy the sequence or not you are hearing nature at work. You're nature and I'm nature and there is nothing you could do or think that will ever remove you from being nature in how you think and what you produce.

In no means is it artifical, or synthetic. Synthetics are a misnomer because synthetics always have to arise from anything natural. Man made will always be natural. Sound can never become artificial no matter what is used or how it's applied. All sound really does is to tell us our ears are functioning and it's great that we are actually able to hear sound at all and I never take this for granted.

People of all nationalities, races, etc. enjoy so many variations of music which are definitely not of a universal acceptance which I find beautiful. But the one important thing to remember is that this is nature at work and it provides something for everyone. I would hate to live in a world where only the non-challenging aspect of art, or anything at all, was always presented. With that kind of non-experimental, non-contemplative thinking we would still think the world is flat! Kev, I happen to think the world is round.....Possibly it could be called a 12 sided circle.....

I need to hear the sould and emotion. and the intellectual side leaves me cold , except where it supports the emotions
Who is the judge to indicate it supports emotion or not? You said 12 tone leaves you cold and void of emotion. I say it supported my emotion because I was emotional while experimenting with it. My emotions drove me to experiment. Am I off the hook then?
 
Let's repeat a previous discussion.

If theory is so important and believed in, surrender your driving licenses until you hold a Motor Mechanic's NVQ, have completed a course in on the limit handling, spent at least six months as a racing or rally mechanic and qualified as a Road Safety Officer.

This would indicate your committal to theory and an ambition to improve your driving for the added protection of your fellow road users, surely more important than a grade eight music diploma.

Sign up here. >:)

With my driving license I am allowed to drive, with a NVQ maybe I would dare crossing the Sahara desert on a BMW R80GS alone.

Same as in music.
 
I'm with OG on this one.

I've been reading a fair bit recently about the history of music and music notation. The general view seems to be that theory evolves to catch-up with practice. It's difficult to find cases where the reverse is true.
 
I'm with OG on this one.

I've been reading a fair bit recently about the history of music and music notation. The general view seems to be that theory evolves to catch-up with practice. It's difficult to find cases where the reverse is true.
2nd Viennese school?

But in any case, does it matter if the theory comes later? The theory is a codification of previous practice and a good theory can suggest future developments. And the best of those developments become the basis of the next wave of theory and so on. Could Beethoven have written what he did if he hadn't studied Bach's use counterpoint, for example? I'm betting he had a pretty good theoretical understanding of that. Could Mendelssohn and Brahms have written as they did without studying Beethoven's use of key relationships, sonata form, etc etc? I doubt it. Could Charlie Parker have done what he did without a thorough knowledge of the hamonic structure of the tunes he was playing? If everyone had to invent it all from scratch every time there would be no progress.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom