Playing the saxophone Diminuendo Long Tones - Cheek Workout

Interesting that you mentioned Wye, there's a SOTW thread mentioning him with this quote,

Tone tolor, dynamics and pitch are interrelated. As much as we flutists would like ultimate flexibility, acoustic physics says these 3 factors are not completely independent. If you want to play quieter, you need less air volume. But you need to deliver it a higher velocity else the flute will go flat.

The OP mentioned "Seems like as the air pressure is dropping I need to work harder (with my cheeks/face muscles) to keep a seal so the note can keep sounding."

So if I have this right one doesn't want to reduce air pressure/velocity when playing. You might have to increase it -- like how @skeller047 mentioned control with the abdomen. What you do decrease is the air volume.

That said @cjR may have meant air volume when they said pressure.
 
Like you I don’t know how everyone may experience it but

you have to agree that if you feel you need to bring to their attention, and tell a beginner in the process of playing a slow ballad ( or something within their technical abilities) that you have to listen to yourself is somewhat absurd.

I fully acknowledge that you don’t get it.

If you and I were sitting in the same space, I would demonstrate and discuss the various aspects of tone with you.
 
I’m not sure I understand this statement, why would it be necessary to bring it to their attention. ?
It may be the difference between hearing and listening.

The book came about because I noticed people doing long notes but not really benefitting from them because their mind wanders and so they stop actually listening.
 
Tricky to start with but as I got it and could sustain a very quiet note I noticed a lot of warbling in my cheeks. First thought, cool I've found a strength building exercise I should keep doing.
Embouchure muscles are very small so you don't feel much when they get tired or cramp. Compare it to the muscles in your hand when you use a hammer for a long time and it is difficult to loosen your grip.
It is a good idea to stop when you feel this warbling as it is possible to overextend these small muscles.

Another aspect of long tones is that the CO2 content of your breath increases. This changes the speed of sound in your saxophone and the frequency. It is possible that your ears want to compensate this but your embouchure can't do this yet. This is more likely for a restarter than for a beginner.
 
Last edited:
It may be the difference between hearing and listening.

The book came about because I noticed people doing long notes but not really benefitting from them because their mind wanders and so they stop actually listening.
Yes, as I mentioned earlier, I Don’t know how other people experience it. Although I can see the analogy with driving. Some drive and are busy anticipating possible trouble scenarios and are fully involved, compared to some drivers who are distracted using their phone while with one hand on the wheel and a beer in the other.
 
I fully acknowledge that you don’t get it.

If you and I were sitting in the same space, I would demonstrate and discuss the various aspects of tone with you.
I don’t need to sit down and talk, I use my ears. The same way I approach playing for example. AVE MARIA or something from the American song book. The sound or vibe if you like is different.
 
When I feel that I'm in the zone and sounding just right, the bubble often bursts when I'm too busy listening and forget it's me playing.
This made me realise that the advice I sometimes give about listening (mindfully or visualising) when playing long notes is aimed mostly at practising. When performing it may or may not be something I'd say you should be doing. What goes on in your mind while performing is a whole different topic altogether. But fascinating anyway.

EDIT: here is the thread I just started on that
 
Last edited:
Like you I don’t know how everyone may experience it but

you have to agree that if you feel you need to bring to their attention, and tell a beginner in the process of playing a slow ballad ( or something within their technical abilities) that you have to listen to yourself is somewhat absurd.
I think it's something you need very much to bring to the attention of a beginner.

I know when I started out, I focussed concentration on reading and counting I didn't really listen to the sound I made.

I listened if playing a long note but once there was more to think about it came further down the list.

We are all different though 🙂

Jx
 
I think it's something you need very much to bring to the attention of a beginner.

I know when I started out, I focussed concentration on reading and counting I didn't really listen to the sound I made.

I listened if playing a long note but once there was more to think about it came further down the list.

We are all different though 🙂

Jx
Perhaps when I first started playing, I may have not listened/heard the noise I made as you say concentrating on other things, but I don’t think so. I think of playing a wind instrument as singing.

I don’t do that when I play the guitar, I think it’s a breath thing.
 
Perhaps when I first started playing, I may have not listened/heard the noise I made as you say concentrating on other things, but I don’t think so. I think of playing a wind instrument as singing.

I don’t do that when I play the guitar, I think it’s a breath thing.
I get used to listen to myself and ... Surprise ... You learn yourself how to improve and fix your intonation, then the sound you liked to achieve. But calm down. It takes years to understand and get to the point !
 
Another aspect of long tones is that the CO2 content of your breath increases. This changes the speed of sound in your saxophone and the frequency. It is possible that your ears want to compensate this
But... that tiny rise in CO2 as you continue to breathe out does not affect intonation or musicality in a way that your ears can hear. The slow rise in CO2 during a deliberately prolonged breath is dwarfed by the much, much bigger CO2 changes that happen unnoticed during normal playing

After you take a breath, the notes you play are powered by room air that hasn't been pulled in far enough to reach the gas exchange area of your lungs. The first 150ml of air you breathe out, and play notes with, contains 0.04% CO2. Then, once you have pushed out the air that hadn't delved deep enough to reach your alveoli, you suddenly expel 5% CO2 lung air for the rest of your breathful of musical magic

Your ears don't notice the switch from dead space air to alveolar air. Then you take another breath and yet again your notes resonate on 0.04% CO2 and then 5% without detection. Your ears don't notice the dramatic see-sawing of CO2 during normal play, and they won't notice a tiny and slow rise during a long note

If changes in exhaled CO2 had the slightest effect on our intonation we would already talk about the 'first notes breath effect'

But we don't

Because it isn't a thing

But, as always, scientific references to support a scientific proposition are always welcome, and may change opinion, if they are any good
 
Last edited:
But... that tiny rise in CO2 as you continue to breathe out does not affect intonation or musicality in a way that your ears can hear. The slow rise in CO2 during a deliberately prolonged breath is dwarfed by the much, much bigger CO2 changes that happen unnoticed during normal playing

After you take a breath, the notes you play are powered by room air that hasn't been pulled in far enough to reach the gas exchange area of your lungs. The first 150ml of air you breathe out, and play notes with, contains 0.04% CO2. Then, once you have pushed out the air that hadn't delved deep enough to reach your alveoli, you suddenly expel 5% CO2 lung air for the rest of your breathful of musical magic

Your ears don't notice the switch from dead space air to alveolar air. Then you take another breath and yet again your notes resonate on 0.04% CO2 and then 5% without detection. Your ears don't notice the dramatic see-sawing of CO2 during normal play, and they won't notice a tiny and slow rise during a long note

If changes in exhaled CO2 had the slightest effect on our intonation we would already talk about the 'first notes breath effect'

But we don't

Because it isn't a thing

But, as always, scientific references to support a scientific proposition are always welcome, and may change opinion, if they are any good
A change of 5% volume O2 (1.3 kg/m3) to CO2 (1.8 kg/m3) increases the density of the air approximately 0,025 kg/m3).
At the density of air at sea level (1.2 kg/m3) this changes the speed of sound 1%. 4Hz on a middle A.
 
A change of 5% volume O2 (1.3 kg/m3) to CO2 (1.8 kg/m3) increases the density of the air approximately 0,025 kg/m3).
At the density of air at sea level (1.2 kg/m3) this changes the speed of sound 1%. 4Hz on a middle A.

I'm confused by this - wouldn't the relevant gas composition apply not just to the breath immediately near the reed but all the way inside the saxophone ? Isn't that why players have to warm up the instrument and the air within it ?

I'm guessing that someone has breathed in helium-rich air and then played the saxophone - I wonder what happened.

Speed of sound in various gases 20 Deg C, 1 Atm:
  • Air 343 m/s
  • Nitrogen 349m/s
  • Oxygen 326 m/s
  • CO2 267 m/s
  • Helium 1007 m/s
And in Air at 0 Deg C 331 m/s

Rhys
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,552
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom