Beginner Saxes Decisions on what to get

I was once on a course where Julia Mills was one of the tutors. She is an outstanding player and I found her to be a very good tutor.

I'm not sure where you're based Pixie but other teachers I know of from my Harrogate days are Debbie Scherer and Sarah Jobson (some on here will know them from Knuston/Alston), they are based in Harrogate, Richard Ormrod is in Leeds (Hyde Park area), Martin Little, I think is in Bradford. You could try Leeds College of Music, there will be a list there I'd guess, also Huddersfield University has a good saxophone department. Good luck in finding someone.
 
Hi Pixie,

Just followed your link and that tutor looks great but is VERY expensive at £35 per hour. I am sure she is worth it for a more advanced player but don't think you need to pay that much as a beginner, lessons are normally between £20-£25 per hour.

Good to hear you've got the tune a day book, work through that but try to resist the temptation to move to the next chapter until you've really mastered the previous one, there are some nice tunes further on.
 
Hi Pixie,

Just followed your link and that tutor looks great but is VERY expensive at £35 per hour. I am sure she is worth it for a more advanced player but don't think you need to pay that much as a beginner, lessons are normally between £20-£25 per hour.

Good to hear you've got the tune a day book, work through that but try to resist the temptation to move to the next chapter until you've really mastered the previous one, there are some nice tunes further on.
My tutor has just put his fee up to £35 per hour. A good tutor is worth the money.....IMHO
 
My tutor has just put his fee up to £35 per hour. A good tutor is worth the money.....IMHO

There are very few tutors who charge that much in this area, its possible prices are a bit higher round your way. I'm sure she is great but is it necessary to pay that much as a beginner?
 
Absolutely agree with you Kerry. It is never easy trying to get a good tutor and Berks is more expensive for everything unfortunately. Purely offering my advice if it is difficult to get a local tutor then "needs must". You and Pixie obviously know your own local area far better than I do, I just wanted to ensure that Pixie gets a good professional tutor from day one. I'll leave it to you locals now and wish you good luck with the search!
 
To be honest travelling is a consideration for me terrible sight for night driving. I could get to that tutors house by train. The Leeds tutors are further out and are about 24-27 miles away. The one above is 8 miles away.
 
Last edited:
Hi Pixie,

Just followed your link and that tutor looks great but is VERY expensive at £35 per hour. I am sure she is worth it for a more advanced player but don't think you need to pay that much as a beginner, lessons are normally between £20-£25 per hour.

Good to hear you've got the tune a day book, work through that but try to resist the temptation to move to the next chapter until you've really mastered the previous one, there are some nice tunes further on.
I'm definitely in no rush. I did wonder about the price and would only be able to attend alternate weeks .
 
I took a lesson before I started to play. That worked for me but we are all different. I then did Tune a Day and another tutorial (far more stuffy!) from my tutor. Only ever had a lesson every three or four weeks. One full hour was enough. Not played with two hands due to injury for over a year so I am going to start from basics again. That is, as soon as the surgeon says OK (which may be next week).
 
There's also this onehttp://www.musicteachers.co.uk/teacher/c68c9e315e18aaa984bd
I took a lesson before I started to play. That worked for me but we are all different. I then did Tune a Day and another tutorial (far more stuffy!) from my tutor. Only ever had a lesson every three or four weeks. One full hour was enough. Not played with two hands due to injury for over a year so I am going to start from basics again. That is, as soon as the surgeon says OK (which may be next week).
that would suit me better I think. What did you do to your hand?
 
There's also this onehttp://www.musicteachers.co.uk/teacher/c68c9e315e18aaa984bd

that would suit me better I think. What did you do to your hand?
You will work out what works best for you once you start Pixie. Just enjoy it all. I have had several ops on my right wrist after it was snapped playing rugby. Now there are problems with carpal tunnel and ligaments. Hopefully will soon be sorted.
 
I
There are very few tutors who charge that much in this area, its possible prices are a bit higher round your way. I'm sure she is great but is it necessary to pay that much as a beginner?
I don't know to be honest just looking for a good local teacher.
 
You will work out what works best for you once you start Pixie. Just enjoy it all. I have had several ops on my right wrist after it was snapped playing rugby. Now there are problems with carpal tunnel and ligaments. Hopefully will soon be sorted.
Hope so. I've broken fingers on both hands due to ropes/ leads on various animals resulting in loss of nerve function ( mainly back now) so can empathise. Rugby now there's a proper game.
 
Hope so. I've broken fingers on both hands due to ropes/ leads on various animals resulting in loss of nerve function ( mainly back now) so can empathise. Rugby now there's a proper game.
My right wrist has been fused with a bone graft from my hip so that it doesn't bend. That ensured my biking days were effectively finished along with my rugby efforts so I took up the sax! Then I joined here about six months into learning. There was only a couple of moderators when I joined! They have a few extra now! Great forum that puts up with me for which I thank all the members - and mods. Great advice and experience offered by all.
 
Last edited:
I do wonder what sort of teacher a raw beginner needs. A highly qualified and talented concert performer will be good for master classes and bringing a player on, but for a raw beginner at the very start of the journey without basic knowledge of finger positions and embouchure may be a conceit.

A good and talented player may be so far down the road, that diagnosing the issues a beginner has might be beyond them.

Some of the questions on here from beginners baffle me but the answers from the experienced teachers, fluent with the novice perspective, get right to the heart of the problem and point to the solution simply and concisely.

A good teacher for beginners may be better than a world class soloist. Less gaps in the calendar as they go off on tour too.
I know what you're saying I'm a bit of a horse rider but didn't head straight to John Whittaker or Carl Hester for lessons sadly, five years down the line there's no reason to change that.
 
To be honest travelling is a consideration for me terrible sight for night driving. I could get to that tutors house by train. The Leeds tutors are further out and are about 24-27 miles away. The one above is 8 miles away.

Pixie - Its entirely up to you but if I were you and travelling was an issue I would give the cheaper tutor a try and see how it goes, I know its contrary to what I said previously but you need the basics to be right and she should be able to help with that. You can always try the other tutor if it doesn't work out or move to her down the line when you feel you would benefit from her expertise. If its a toss up between weekly lessons or fortnightly, at least to start with I would go for cheaper and weekly providing you have time to do your homework in between lessons. Its just unfortunate you seem to live in a tutor black spot.

Whatever you choose good luck with it but no harm in giving either or both a try and taking it from there, but don't expect too much from your first lesson.
 
I've contacted the first one I have a lesson booked with her 28 th n she's given me some homework . Long notes, identifying BAG FED on the staves and making my own tunes up.to contact her if any advice needed in the meantime.
 
£35 per hour isn't unusual, mine charges that or £18 for half hour. After your first couple of lesson you may well find half an hour enough. I had weekly lessons to start but now only fortnightly, son at uni meant cut backs 🙂

Jx
 
Some parts of the country are cheaper. In other cases, better tutors charge more because they are in demand. Sometimes, people overcharge, but generally I would describe £35 as upper end of the range but not excessive.

By comparison, I had a cheap cello teacher at £20 and he didn't know how to teach adults. There's a teacher who is £40. He's extremely good (lead cellist with a well-known orchestra) but he's over 30 miles away, so too far for regular lessons.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,068
Messages
578,493
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom