Beginner Saxes Decisions on what to get

Any road

Putting my blatant heightism to one side for a mo', I agree with all said about choosing the tenor if that's what you want

I don't know if you will find weight an issue... There's a difference to be had between makes so it might be best to try a range before deciding what you want. A super-dooper Hanson belonging to @Jay that she kindly let me try was noticeably at the lighter end of the scale
 
I'm a knocking on a bit woman with a life long urge to play the sax. My superstar husband wants to get me one for xmas ( always early in my house) . I've had a go on one (1 hr lesson) managed to get a tune out and hit the low notes. I can't play a musical instrument or read music (yet). I like the sound of the tenor sax but they are more expensive than alto's, alto's are easier to learn on and I can't play at all, I'm 5foot 2 and had to rest the alto I played on my knees sat down couldn't hold it up ( neck strap not working on the one I tried). I have a choice of a YAS 275 cleaned and serviced by a well respected and experienced local bloke ( alder sons wood wind repairs Doncaster or a brand news YAS 280. Which to go for?
I am also a 'knocking on a bit' woman (52) and I play the tenor - started just over a year ago - because, like you, I just love the sound of it. The way I get round the weight is to use a jazzlab saxholder which makes such a difference! My teacher has swapped to one, having problems with his neck, and he can't believe how 'light' it makes a tenor feel.
My Hanson, that @Ivan refers to is a Hanson LX - which IS quite a bit lighter than the Hanson ST8 I had before.
 
The suggestion to try a few makes a lot of sense because weight varies dramatically. I have two tenors and they are very heavy in comparison to some that I have tried. If there is an instrument shop near you nip down and try a few.
 
Hi Pixie,
I too am knocking on a bit (rapidly approaching 51), short (5ft) and took up sax 9 months ago. I'm also just up the road from you in Leeds.

I went for the alto as I thought I might have trouble physically wielding a tenor and had a limited budget. Don't regret getting the alto at all but have tried a couple of tenors recently and can manage them fine, even though they do reach down to my knees when I'm stood up (do wonder if I could play one sat down though).As soon as money allows I will definitely be getting a tenor but will still keep on playing the alto.

I've also been getting urges to buy a curvy soprano recently, I'm very much a completest, always want the full set of everything (once bought some new mugs and ended up with the full dinner set, 12 place settings plus spares within weeks!) so with me its always been inevitable I would end up with the whole saxophone family, didn't seem to matter where I started and I like alto and tenor equally.

If you do have a strong preference, go with it but personally I don't think you need to get a Yamaha necessarily especially if you've never played an instrument before and don't know how you will get on with it. My alto is a Jupiter and I've been very pleased with it, as far as student saxes go they're supposed to be second only to the Yamaha and you would probably get a Jupiter tenor for the price of a yam alto, might be worth considering.

I second that a trip to woodwind exchange in Bradford might be a good idea, also "all brass and woodwind" in Leeds might be worth a try, ring first to see what they have in stock, you can save a lot by buying second hand.

Whatever you choose, I wish you the best of luck

Kerry.
 
Nice intermediate sax. A lot of good horns out there that don't hold their value (unlike the Yamaha). That is the beauty of buying a Yamaha, they hold their price because they are renowned for being consistent in both playing and build. Buying second hand has it's own dangers. But I would also recommend buying a second hand sax either via a teacher or a reputable shop (or look on the Yard Sale here).
 
Welcome, Pixie. Whichever you decide to start with you will eventually own them all. Just give in to the urge when it strikes; it is inevitable. (we all find our justifications; 'it is good for the economy' or 'what if I never tried this horn and it was really the one for me? I would forever wonder.' And so on.) You should probably insist your husband begins playing, in hopes he will succumb to GAS, too. Anyway, enjoy the journey.

The husbands GAS leans towards Guitars 🙂
 
Hello

I started on alto and then bought a tenor. I could already read music and was used to performing in a group (as a choral singer) so that was not an issue for me. Sax was my first attempt at playing a wind instrument.

I didn't have too much trouble starting to get noises out of it, but I would strongly recommend starting off with a teacher as bad habits are very easy to acquire and hard to eliminate once embedded.

My experience is that I find tenors an easier 'blow' than alto. I have tried a saxlab holder, not bought one yet and they do help. I use a Cebulla sling for tenor which doesn't press on the nape of the neck.

Might be worth finding at teacher before buying...

I have a Hanson ST8
 
Hello

I started on alto and then bought a tenor. I could already read music and was used to performing in a group (as a choral singer) so that was not an issue for me. Sax was my first attempt at playing a wind instrument.

I didn't have too much trouble starting to get noises out of it, but I would strongly recommend starting off with a teacher as bad habits are very easy to acquire and hard to eliminate once embedded.

My experience is that I find tenors an easier 'blow' than alto. I have tried a saxlab holder, not bought one yet and they do help. I use a Cebulla sling for tenor which doesn't press on the nape of the neck.

Might be worth finding at teacher before buying...

I have a Hanson ST8
I have had a previous bad experience with a music teacher over ten years ago and will be very particular in future. I had a lesson with a lovely lady in Whitby whose happy to help me.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,067
Messages
578,491
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom