Saxophones De-Mythifying the Purple Logo

Re: De-Mythifying RAW

So the difference is down to neck changes (the G1 was hardly a Budget move though as it`s with the Z series and 875 too - also Necks Can be replaced) and a change to MOP to plastic (hardly sound or playablility related), I can`t blame Yam for wanting to save in an area which is of little consequence, the pearls .. the Mk3 Update must have cost them money though, they improved the action and had to R&D a new neck ..

Merryfisher - In what way don`t the Mk2s and Z horns stack up against the 61 or Mk1 in your opinion ? . I found the 61 if anything a bit on the overly brash side with little in the way of warmth to the bottom end and lacking depth there too, I preferred the 62 Mk1 to it to be honest and way preferred the Selmer MkVII at that end of things (but always preferred all the Pro Yams at the upper register however) . I find the Silver 62 I have now (a mk2) more balanced than the older Yamahas I`ve played (better bottom end without losing the top) and a lot more balanced than the MkVII which wasn`t great above A in the upper reg .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: De-Mythifying RAW

This is a curious thread, what difference does it make whether or not a certain saxophone, made between certain dates, or within this and that serial number takes on a mythical status? Who does it hurt? At the end of the day, does the audience care, would they even be able to tell the player is playing the student or the professional end of what ever makers range?

Looking at the 61/62, it started production in the 80's. I suspect little if any of the original machinery is still used in it's production today, as I would suspect Yamaha is quite cutting edge with it's CAD and CNC machines these days. It would make sense for them to take advantage of this stuff to enable them to make the saxophone more efficiently and more consistently, and yes that would also mean cutting costs, possibly through more efficient use of material and so on or using plastic touch pieces. Would it also make sense to use this new technology to model the acoustics of the saxophone and 'improve' it's design. Each new version will be built on the last and be a step away from what it was, the direction will either be seen as an improvement, or not, and people will buy or not.

Who's to say the new 'Hard steel springs' used on the Mk III are better than the 'Blue Spring Steel' used on the Mk II or the 'stainless' springs used on the Mk I? And the use of the 'Integrated Key Posts' sounds like someone worked out they could cut and shape one bit of metal and fit it rather than two bits of metal, possibly saving a bit of time or material or accuracy, luckily though it according to Yamaha it 'makes the horn blow with moderate resistance while delivering a solid core with deep tone color.' So there we have it, I'm sure it's a great saxophone, different in subtle ways from the MK2, even more from the Mk1 and probably even more from the 61.

I think I lost the point of what I was attempting to say somewhere in all of this... Oh well
 
and it got to a state of insanity when someone said that the older student horns were better than any of the current Pro models (Yamaha must be really dumb if they can`t make a Pro horn better than an 80s student one !) , I`ve played 23s and they`re really good but the 61/62 regardless of vintage or logo colour is in a different league for handling and open-ness - maybe these people just don`t like the modern sound (they`d hate a Yani) ..

It's true that I'm insane 🙂
-in case you refer to post #9 @ http://cafesaxophone.com/showthread.php?11700-YAS-23-Yamaha-Vito-differences -
I'm the one that said that.

And I will try to explain what I mean.
275s and 475s even Japan made ones sound to me "thin" . So do later 62s in comparison to the 70s- early 80s models.

Something changed. I'm not expert to say what it is, but I have made A-B tests and the sound is different.

The 80s models sound to me neutral. Neutral in a really good way. Meaning they have no certain identity and the sound can get to fat from thin, dark to insanely treble just with the appropriate mouthpiece and embouchoure adjustment. I feel they are in the middle and I can move my sound easier wherever I want. My 23 has no luxurius keywork no engravings and no purple logo.

It screams though. It holds it's regulation a LOT better than many "pro" horns. It's intonation is perfect and makes my life easy.
So for me it's not a student model. It's my dream sax. But don't take my word for it. What's suits me maybe not be good for anyone else.

I've seen in the past "fools" like me comparing mk6 with yts-23 at sotw , and if i'm correct stephen howard who is a respectable technician in the UK said it was his weapon of choice.

The later models , while being wonderful, they sound to me brighter and thinner, and they don't have the absolute versatility the 80s models have.

It's true though what Ads says maybe I'm not among the ones that want that definitive bright sound that cuts though the mix and most contemporary players and producers need.
Even though I think Yani's are state of the art saxophones in terms of quality and keywork sense, I find them bright as well. I don't hate them, but it's not for me. 🙂

Concluding, thank god all saxes are different 🙂 - We just tell our opinions to help others find their way.

And hopefully saxophone finds it's way more and more in contemporary productions.
Purple logo or Violet logo, Yani or Yami or whatever 🙂
 
Re: De-Mythifying RAW

Merryfisher - In what way don`t the Mk2s and Z horns stack up against the 61 or Mk1 in your opinion ? . I found the 61 if anything a bit on the overly brash side with little in the way of warmth to the bottom end and lacking depth there too, I preferred the 62 Mk1 to it to be honest and way preferred the Selmer MkVII at that end of things (but always preferred all the Pro Yams at the upper register however) . I find the Silver 62 I have now (a mk2) more balanced than the older Yamahas I`ve played (better bottom end without losing the top) and a lot more balanced than the MkVII which wasn`t great above A in the upper reg .

mine is a small voice in a big world & so much can influence things... reeds, mouthpiece, player, the whole combo etc - personally, i just find my two purple yams just seem to have a bigger voice then the newer ones i've tried they just seem to breathe easier, certainly no compromise at the bottom end and they definitely take off for me in the higher registers. the 61 is sweet and soulful, the 62 soulful but with a big voice and a real edge when needed. With regard to the my recent experience with the '82, it kind of felt like driving with the hand brake slightly on in comparison, really having to push it to get a response, and again it felt a little one dimensional tone wise, but very quick under the fingers. probably just it was me, maybe a different mpc would pay a different dividend, probably a more accomplished player would have got more out of it - but it certainly nailed any curiosity i had for the '82 much to the good wife's relief.
 
It wasn't permanent. It could scratch or rub off -- I had a 62R soprano where it was completely missing. Someone probably applied some sort of polish or cleaner to the horn and off it came.

Don't purple logo saxes sell at a substantial premium? If so then that could be a spendy spot of polishing.
 
And thats your prerogative or course.

But in the world I live in, every manufacturer is looking for ways to reduce costs and I'd still suggest the example I used of Mother of pearl being replaced by plastic represents exactly that.

I'm not trying to knock the MKII 62, just offering experience and 1st hand knowledge rather than myths.

And of course........mother of pearl really makes the difference in sound?!
 

That says it all, no change for sound making parts of the actual Horn (necks are replacable) . the differences between 62/62II soundwise are therefore merely the differences which exist between samples of the same horns in general (EG:- two MkVIs can sound like totally different horns) and the rest would appear to be a combination of the general human love for mythology and wanting their own horn to be something special . It certainly makes the purple logo business look like Guff as Mk1s ran from 1978 to 2002 as there were a lot of Purple-Free Mk1s made in that time.

Again, this is taking the horns with the same neck fitted as that can make a dramatic difference.

This explains why you can line up a row of (Even) Yamahas and pick a gem from the bunch and why the 61 I tried a while back left me a bit cold and found the 62 MK1 better, it could have been reversed with two different samples . the prob is that there seems to be a concesnsus that Yamaha have a lack of sample Variation perfected so if a MK1 sounded better than a sample of a Mk2 then the Mk2 must be inferior (whereas it`s just the two horns in question like it would be with a Selmer , Keilwerth etc) . as I said in the beginning

I think the bottom line here is that even with Yamaha 62s , you have to take things on a horn to horn basis and ignore the date it was made or the colour of the logo and choose by sound of the actual instruments in front of you same as you would naturally do with with European or American makes . as for the cheaper models, same goes - a good YTS-21 could easily sound better than a dud 82Z much as a good Weltklang Soloist could "Blow away" (to use a popular piece of Hyperbole) a sour MkVI . as for Purple logo 21s, 23s and 32s - it would appear that it was Yamaha saving money on Stamping & engraving.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That says it all, no change for sound making parts of the actual Horn (necks are replacable) . the differences between 62/62II soundwise are therefore merely the differences which exist between samples of the same horns in general (EG:- two MkVIs can sound like totally different horns) and the rest would appear to be a combination of the general human love for mythology and wanting their own horn to be something special . It certainly makes the purple logo business look like Guff as Mk1s ran from 1978 to 2002 as there were a lot of Purple-Free Mk1s made in that time.

Again, this is taking the horns with the same neck fitted as that can make a dramatic difference.

This explains why you can line up a row of (Even) Yamahas and pick a gem from the bunch and why the 61 I tried a while back left me a bit cold and found the 62 MK1 better, it could have been reversed with two different samples . the prob is that there seems to be a concesnsus that Yamaha have a lack of sample Variation perfected so if a MK1 sounded better than a sample of a Mk2 then the Mk2 must be inferior (whereas it`s just the two horns in question like it would be with a Selmer , Keilwerth etc) . as I said in the beginning

I think the bottom line here is that even with Yamaha 62s , you have to take things on a horn to horn basis and ignore the date it was made or the colour of the logo and choose by sound of the actual instruments in front of you same as you would naturally do with with European or American makes . as for the cheaper models, same goes - a good YTS-21 could easily sound better than a dud 82Z much as a good Weltklang Soloist could "Blow away" (to use a popular piece of Hyperbole) a sour MkVI . as for Purple logo 21s, 23s and 32s - it would appear that it was Yamaha saving money on Stamping & engraving.

But a MK VI......









Isn't purple
 
I thought You`d recently listed that Vito YAS23 on Fleabay . I`m sure I saw it there, the Yam YTS23 sold anyway . and as I said, that Mk1 62 must have been a total lemon . every alto you`ve played since has beaten it .
 
I thought You`d recently listed that Vito YAS23 on Fleabay . I`m sure I saw it there, the Yam YTS23 sold anyway . and as I said, that Mk1 62 must have been a total lemon . every alto you`ve played since has beaten it .
No, it's another Vito listed. I had two, plus a YAS-23, all playing very nicely, but have kept the one in the most mintiest condition, almost as new. Love the deep gold colour too!

I'll try another 62 when I come across one....
 
Ads, How do you find the 62 MkIII Alto compared to the older models?

I`ve only played the older models in Tenor , I`ve only relatively recently added alto (and Sop), I find the Mk-III is a very sweet and refined horn right through the range, handling is impeccable as you`d expect, I preferred it to the Yani 902 for greater depth at the low end (and doesn`t sacrifice open-ness) . I`m not in much of a position to judge Altos unfortunately, only played a few, current competition to the 62 and a couple of cheapies..

BTW what`s a Yamaha AS-100 Alto ? Australian name for an 82Z or something ?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom