Saxophones De-Mythifying the Purple Logo

I have a decision to make that I should really be concentrating on right now... So I’ve decided to adopt the subtle art of distraction in a way of allowing the important decision time to mature in my subconscious ready for when I can’t procrastinate any further...

As this thread has maneuvered itself into the Yamaha neck territory I thought I’d bring myself up to date... As you can see I’m really avoiding that decision...

So here we go:

My old Yamaha catalogue showed a number of custom necks:

For Alto:
G1 and M1

For Tenor:
G1 G3 M1 and F1

These are all Customs, the 82’s came with the G1 neck as did the 875 alto, but the 875 tenor came with the G3.

The catalogue gives no information on the difference between any these necks or the F1 and M1. My suspicion is that the M1 is close to the old 62 neck before they came up with the non custom G1.

Looking on Yamaha’s site they seemed to have realised they were missing out on offering different necks and actually given some details about their necks this time... But they have also done away with the old models, so today we have:

AE1, AC1, AV1 if you want them in sliver add AG at the end (AG being the symbol for silver in the periodic table! Personally I think using 47, the atomic number would have been a bit more classy.)

Can you imagine it...
“Hey sax god what you playing?”

“Well I got me this here AC1-47 on my 62 with a 4C refaced to 9*”
​

It just sound just so much better than:
“yeah I got this AC1AG” - That sounds like a moped.
​

But I might be digressing a bit here....

For the tenors substitute the A for a T and you’ve got the swan neck.

E is the medium bore “quick response and superb intonation.”
C is the smallest bore and based on the original 62.
V is the largest bore “free blowing and extremely flexible”

Yamaha do a rather fine job of visually representing the differences:

A8F431CFA050427299CF832089A390B0_12074.jpg



As C1 is based on the original 62 neck, it is perfectly clearly that the original 62 neck was intended for beginners, hence it's popularity with a few professional players here and there that you don't often hear about.

So there we are... Or so I thought....

The 62 MkIII comes with a new 62 neck. The MkII had G1 stamped on the neck and the new one has 62 stamped on it, which is presumably different from the original G1 and the new E, C, and V custom models, so where in the graphical representation of tone does it sit? And how about the old G1 and G3 necks for that matter?

The Custom Z now comes with the V1 but the Custom EX still comes with the G1 for alto and G3 for the tenor.

For those looking for the Classic 62 neck... well according to my old Yamaha sax catalogue the 475 series of horns came with... “a classic 62 style neck for optimum sound and playability.

I’m not sure how the 480 series fits in, they have obviously updated the neck socket as it can now accommodate the custom necks, but if the neck is the same as the 475 or not, I do not know.

I'm not sure I'm much the wiser after any of this...
 
YYEEEEAAAAAAAAAGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHH Is there a Necrologist in the house ????? a Necromancer ????? ... Thanks Chris , I`m even more confused about the Yam Neck situation than I was before ..... your tenon would wear out testing all that lot !

It was easier a few posts ago when it was ..... Get 2 Necks, the Original Mk1 for a bright projected cutting sound and the MkIII (62) new one for a warm more selmerific sound ...
 
I was thinking it was time to de-mythify the Yamaha Purple Logo in one thread.. there`s talk about them being setup alongside Pro players instead of in the workshop (but a trip to SH would equalize that) and even about having better quality action .. Steve Howard mentions the purple logo as a means of cheaper labelling . this seems more logical to me .

1:- If any of the better action business is true does it onlu relate to the 61 and 62 models
2:- there are 21, 23 and 32 Purple logos horns too , does "Purpleness" apply to those ? if so How
3:- if you got SH to setup a 62 Purp and a 62 Mk1 would they handle the same , sound the same ?
4:- is all this down to Specific horns ? (comparing a cherrypicked MK3 to a Purple with same neck, would the Mk3 win)

Etc etc .. I know the subject has come up loads of times but usually along with the grips of Purple fever or Purple Hatred from the posters involved . It`d be good to de-mythify the purple logo once and for all as either truth or bunkum , Pro horns only or the 32s and students as well .

there is a very good looking one on ebay just now - and the bids are mounting.
 
personally i ain't bothered if a neck is geared for a beginner or a pro just as long as it gives the sound direction i want, and i stick by my love of the original purple logo neck for tenor, for my playing style and sound it is brighter, fuller and more free blowing than all the others i tried from Yamaha, but on alto i have a preference for a copper neck i use and not the original purple logo neck.
 
While we're on the purple subject there's an alto here for £1200 ono ☞ http://marshallmcgurk.blogspot.co.uk/p/saxophones.html

I love the comment ""This is very close to a MkVI sound at a fraction of the cost. "" . LOL !! . the whole point about getting a Yamaha is that it doesn`t sound anything like a MkVI and the Purple Logo Mk1 the least of all .

I`m gonna hunt me down a Purple Logo neck for the Tenor next , preferably a silver one though I`ve never actually seen a Mk1 silver Yam Tenor , Gold will be fine of course , the neck will stand out.. Buying different necks is cheaper than horns, can actually make more difference (depending on the horns) and they take up less room .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, The Purple era Alto neck has arrived and after a quick A/B comparison using the same piece and reed, Mr Howard was (of course) bang on , it`s like taking the brakes off , the horn opens up and the dynamics (which were exellent to begin with) are even wider . the upper register literally screams, I like this but can see why many may not and likely why the G1 and later necks were designed to tame things , the lowest registers actually gain power but harden up a bit (like I experienced with the the 61 and Mk1 tenors) .. The neck as in Steve Howards pic on his site is shorter than the later ones, you really have to get that Mpc right up the cork to be in tune ...

The Mk3 (62) neck I`d happily refer to as the "Selmeficator" or at least the De-Yamifier , they`re aiming at a wider market than the Yamaha fan base , I don`t know where the G1, M1 and F1 fit in all this..

The older Purples may be more refined in build than the later Mk1s, the Mk2s and IIIs (at least the gold finish ones) but the important diff (Sound) it would seem is in the Neck , this is the only Purple era neck I`ve seen for sale in Alto or Tenor but I`d suggest MK2/III owners keep their eyes peeled ...
 
I`d just like to add that having these two completely different necks really has effectively given me two different sounding horns (I guess this is why Canonball give two with the albright - is the fat neck more like the Mk1 Yam ?) , but both with the near perfect Yamaha MkIII action and excellent ergonomics of course so no compromises and as I saif, necks take more less space than horns so you`ll always have both "horns" with you . I want a couple of tenor ones now as that`s my main horn and what I gig , I`ve got the G1, adding a MklIII and a Mk1 ought to do it .....
:sax:
 
indeed another case why the original purple logo neck which was supposed to be a box standard neck actually turns out to be in my opinion the best neck yamaha have made, i have owned and was asked to trial all the yamaha range and the purple powerhouse neck stood proud over all the likely new comers, just goes to show no need to fix what aint broken in design and the purple logo neck to me suits my needs perfect on my tenor, tho on alto i prefer my copper neck.
 
I think the issue was what defines "Broken" . I guess in Yamaha's term , by the 90s, not sounding "like a Selmer" would constitute "Broken" ..

I believe "in wanna selmer ?- buy one !! " .. I guess you can`t blame Yam for wanting to smooch-out their Pro saxes to appeal to a wider audience but personally , especially on alto where I feel dynamics, unleashed frequency range and brightness are most needed, I think they should have left things be .. the new necks seem to act like a low pass filter though at least the MkIII one does seem to add to the bottom end thickness , but I feel it`d work better on tenor than Alto . the MkIII neck does sound Sweet , nice to have it for ballads .

Yamaha (and Yani to a greater degree) may just have been Taming the Saxophone a little too much
 
I suspect that Yamaha have made changes to their instruments as a result of consultations with the pro players who endorse them. So blame Eugene Rousseau, Mindy Abair, Jeff Coffin, Phil Woods, Dave Koz and all the others who feature in the Yamaha brochures...
Although you'd think by now the'd've come up with a decent mouthpiece...
 
Yeah !!!..... I can`t believe they still give the 4C away with the 62s and 82Zs .. my guess is that it`s put in so you have a piece to give away with your old wreck or budget horn when you sell it ......

If they`ve GOT to give a cheap plastic piece away with the horns why not supply one with a decent gap, 6C would be better than nothing but , you`re right, one of the HR ones ought to be the supplied item .
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,673
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom