Mouthpieces Current Otto Link Tone Edge tenor

Wai Lung

Member
Messages
25
Location
Ely United Kingdom
Hi, I want to ask if anyone has recently purchased an off the shelf, non-vintage or custom or limited line, the lowest cost tone edge. How consistent or well made (or not so) is the modern offering?

I'll elaborate a bit. Mine I bought it new some 20 years ago. I love that sound. But I think mine is one of the lowest quality one. Couldn't pass the "pop" test so must have uneven table or rails and the whole lot. No projection to speak of. I did sand the table a little bit and it did improve a bit. I still play with it at home, and I love the sound and I don't want to give up on it. I don't play with difficult reed setup, 6* tip opening 2.5 Legere Signature reed. I really don't want to go down that rabbit hole of keep trying £300+ boutique pieces and keep messing up my "boring" practice routine. My other old faithful is an off the shelf lowest tier Otto Link metal 6* with the same strength Legere reed.

Is it just the nature of thing? Or the old mantra still very much holds, "If you want projection, work hard on your breath support."

Thanks!
 
There's been a fair bit of chatter about Links on here, and it has usually touched on the quality control etc. I suggest you do a search of the site for a start - I'm sure there will be great info for you there before people reply en masse to your post.
 
I'm very inexperienced regarding MPs; but I bought a modern Tone Link for Tenor. It was fine with cane. I started trying Legere and it was a struggle. I went back to a Yamaha 6C and the plastic is great. I've tried again on the Tone Edge without success. It may be that the smoother plastic amplifies imperfections on the face or rails?
 
Thanks for the suggestion!. I did some search here, and kind of make peace with my "lesser" Link 🙂 I made serious purchasing mistakes when I first started, and spent way too much time reading threads looking for that magical piece of gear sprayed with angel's dust than practicing. Anyway I came across a thread called "Link Chops". I think there is some truth in that, and that extends to gear in general. I started with electric guitars long before I started with saxophone. I switched strings, amplifiers, effects, cable, you name it. Sax is so different; it is so much an extension of my chest and lung. It is not like changing an effect pedal to get a different sound. Yes of course changing picking dynamics changes the sound. Playing sax is just a lot more "visceral", for not knowing a better word.
Previously I used cane reeds, and recently for being too lazy to prep them I switched to Legere. I think I couldn't find much difference. Perhaps I'll go back to practicing than looking for some gear than could magically transform my lack of technique 😀
 
I'm very inexperienced regarding MPs; but I bought a modern Tone Link for Tenor. It was fine with cane. I started trying Legere and it was a struggle. I went back to a Yamaha 6C and the plastic is great. I've tried again on the Tone Edge without success. It may be that the smoother plastic amplifies imperfections on the face or rails?

My take on the greater success with cane reeds on your tone edge comes down to the fact that cane warps.
Or more to the point, it will shape its self when wet which can be (and usually is in my experience) advantageous if the facing is a bit off somehow. Where as a plastic (or whatever they are) reed will not do that.
Granted that when the reed vibrates against the rails it doesn't matter as much which type of reed you have for producing sound but how it sounds and how easily it lets you control it will be more consistent with a plastic reed for better or worse.
Personally, I stick with cane reeds that I like the sound of and so long as they work I don't judge them in the 1st 10 minutes or so.
 
Thanks for the suggestion!. I did some search here, and kind of make peace with my "lesser" Link 🙂 I made serious purchasing mistakes when I first started, and spent way too much time reading threads looking for that magical piece of gear sprayed with angel's dust than practicing. Anyway I came across a thread called "Link Chops". I think there is some truth in that, and that extends to gear in general. I started with electric guitars long before I started with saxophone. I switched strings, amplifiers, effects, cable, you name it. Sax is so different; it is so much an extension of my chest and lung. It is not like changing an effect pedal to get a different sound. Yes of course changing picking dynamics changes the sound. Playing sax is just a lot more "visceral", for not knowing a better word.
Previously I used cane reeds, and recently for being too lazy to prep them I switched to Legere. I think I couldn't find much difference. Perhaps I'll go back to practicing than looking for some gear than could magically transform my lack of technique 😀
Try no 2 plasticovers, work a rmtreat and no prep
 
My experience with Link Tone Edge is restricted to soprano, but I have bought several STMs for tenor over the years. The issue with the pop test is likely that the table isn’t flat. All Links I have bought since about 2006 or so (3 soprano Tone Edge, 3 STM tenor), have problems with the table - some severe, others not so much. I assumed that I would have to reface them when I bought them, so was not disappointed.

The thing is, the facing curves were all done well. But in 3 cases, the tables were so bad that there were obvious leaks at the base of the window. In one case, a “vintage” model tenor STM, the table was acceptable, and I did not reface it. It plays very well.

@Wai Lung - you say you sanded the table - did you attempt to blend the curve of the facing back to the new table? @Saxlicker ’s comment about cane reeds is well taken.

With a reasonably OK table, a stock Link can be quite good. But the likelihood of getting a “good one” is pretty low. Back when I was a young man, we expected to have to try many mouthpieces to get one that worked. In fact, the first tenor Link I bought was chosen out of 5 or 6 that I tried at the store. Very few places exist like this now. Stock Links are inexpensive enough that buying one and having it refaced is still less money than a boutique piece.
 
My experience with Link Tone Edge is restricted to soprano, but I have bought several STMs for tenor over the years. The issue with the pop test is likely that the table isn’t flat. All Links I have bought since about 2006 or so (3 soprano Tone Edge, 3 STM tenor), have problems with the table - some severe, others not so much. I assumed that I would have to reface them when I bought them, so was not disappointed.

The thing is, the facing curves were all done well. But in 3 cases, the tables were so bad that there were obvious leaks at the base of the window. In one case, a “vintage” model tenor STM, the table was acceptable, and I did not reface it. It plays very well.

@Wai Lung - you say you sanded the table - did you attempt to blend the curve of the facing back to the new table? @Saxlicker ’s comment about cane reeds is well taken.

With a reasonably OK table, a stock Link can be quite good. But the likelihood of getting a “good one” is pretty low. Back when I was a young man, we expected to have to try many mouthpieces to get one that worked. In fact, the first tenor Link I bought was chosen out of 5 or 6 that I tried at the store. Very few places exist like this now. Stock Links are inexpensive enough that buying one and having it refaced is still less money than a boutique piece.
I only sanded the table, not the rails. I think I don't have the skills to do it well and could totally ruin the piece. I just run the mouthpiece flat on a flat sanding block, with fine sanding paper stick on, and did it slowly and lightly. from the marks on the sandpaper and the mouthpiece table, it was definitely not flat. I stopped when I saw the marks are even and straight. Just visually looking from the side, it looks me the curve of the rails to table are smooth, not like having an sudden turn or drop off. After sanding despite not having great improvement sonically, the piece becomes quite a lot more controllable, not having some sudden squeaks or unexpected change in volume.
 
I only sanded the table, not the rails. I think I don't have the skills to do it well and could totally ruin the piece. I just run the mouthpiece flat on a flat sanding block, with fine sanding paper stick on, and did it slowly and lightly. from the marks on the sandpaper and the mouthpiece table, it was definitely not flat. I stopped when I saw the marks are even and straight. Just visually looking from the side, it looks me the curve of the rails to table are smooth, not like having an sudden turn or drop off. After sanding despite not having great improvement sonically, the piece becomes quite a lot more controllable, not having some sudden squeaks or unexpected change in volume.
Good, you are probably in the right ballpark then. Not-flat tables are kind of a signature feature of Links.

The squeaks and volume changes you mention could have been due to an incomplete seal against the table, so sanding corrected that. Still I would consider contacting a refacer (there are a few people here on the Cafe who do this work) because a few small tweaks to the baffle, and possibly a correction of the facing, you can end up with a piece that really sings.

I do know that's a rabbit hole though... if you like the piece as is, then messing with it more might create more problems and you end up with a doorstop. Don't do it if it's your favorite piece, get another one and send the worse of the two out.

Regarding "Link chops" - yes there is such a thing. To me, this means keeping your jaw loose, but the muscles of your lips and face firm - so strong support with low pressure on the reed. And making sure you take in enough mouthpiece. All with good air support.
 
I purchased a New Vintage HR link from a member on here, that Phil Tone had worked his magic on and it's belting. I also bought a large chamber V16.

The V16 is slightly brighter, probably with more projection... But I play the Link, it's got a darker deeper, fuller sound, there's just something about it.

@skeller047 is right on the "Link Chops", that's how my teacher has taught me to play regardless of piece, the Link does seem to be less forgiving. I find the tenor less forgiving than Alto, I can be quite lazy playing Alto, the tenor needs that air support.
 
Good, you are probably in the right ballpark then. Not-flat tables are kind of a signature feature of Links.

The squeaks and volume changes you mention could have been due to an incomplete seal against the table, so sanding corrected that. Still I would consider contacting a refacer (there are a few people here on the Cafe who do this work) because a few small tweaks to the baffle, and possibly a correction of the facing, you can end up with a piece that really sings.

I do know that's a rabbit hole though... if you like the piece as is, then messing with it more might create more problems and you end up with a doorstop. Don't do it if it's your favorite piece, get another one and send the worse of the two out.

Regarding "Link chops" - yes there is such a thing. To me, this means keeping your jaw loose, but the muscles of your lips and face firm - so strong support with low pressure on the reed. And making sure you take in enough mouthpiece. All with good air support.
It sounds cliche, but yesterday I lower the strength of reeds on my three favourite pieces. It was a game changer.

I started playing some twenty years ago, and only recently picked up my horn again after a long hiatus. I think most teachers would say lower your jaw and don't bite. Mine always stressed that too. I didn't get it. I just progressively increased the reed strength for the full, warm sound of the great masters. And of course mouthpiece GAS didn't help.

Now with much softer reeds, I get that "lower your jaw" and relaxing the throat muscles is the way to go. I always practice playing to wall to get the sound reflection and hear my sound. Sound qualities improves a lot too.

My re-learning process is FUN! Thanks guys!
 
I purchased a New Vintage HR link from a member on here, that Phil Tone had worked his magic on and it's belting. I also bought a large chamber V16.

The V16 is slightly brighter, probably with more projection... But I play the Link, it's got a darker deeper, fuller sound, there's just something about it.

@skeller047 is right on the "Link Chops", that's how my teacher has taught me to play regardless of piece, the Link does seem to be less forgiving. I find the tenor less forgiving than Alto, I can be quite lazy playing Alto, the tenor needs that air support.
100%, there is something with an HR Link. It is impossible to describe sound, yet I would say it moans and it roars. "Link Chops" is pretty much like the Zen of sax playing.😀
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,436
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom