Playing the saxophone Counting during improv

IGoddard

Member
Messages
140
Location
UK
Hi all.

Improvisation is something that i've put off for a long time. I've been working my way through the early ABRSM grades to fill any knowledge gaps and build some endurance and a sense of tone. I've got to grade 4 pretty quickly so now it's time to sit back a bit, play for fun and work on the dreaded improvisation.

I'm just starting to delve into it with my teacher and we are working on the simple tune "Blue Monk" with 12 bars of improv at the end using the G Maj blues scale for tenor. Rhythmic ideas and the notes are not so much an issue, I know exactly what I want to play. But can I count and keep track of which bar I'm in when I'm doing so? Hell no! Even taking the improv right back to basics; quavers, semibreves and equivalent rests only - I have a real tough time counting to 4 consistently! Is this is a common problem? How do people usually keep track of where they are when improvising?

It may be worth noting I played piano previously and therefore I'm really quite confident with sight reading. I tend not to count when reading sheeted music unless i reach a note spanning longer than a semibreve.
 
Is this is a common problem? How do people usually keep track of where they are when improvising?
Yes it's common. How to fix it is difficult and will take time. This is about your ear, not about mechanics of playing your horn.

Here is the thing about improvising - for a saxophonist (any soloist really), most people concentrate on what note they are going to play. But what note you are going to play depends heavily on what notes the other players are playing. So you have to listen to the rest of the band (or backing track or metronome or whatever) and keep track of where you are in the form of the tune. At the same time you have to decide what note(s) to play...

You should talk to your teacher about the form of the blues - it's basically 3 sections of 4 bars each, that's your 12 bars. While you can choose notes from the G major blues scale, you still have to choose them based on what chord is playing while you are improvising. So a B natural during a C7 chord won't sound good.

What I used to do with students just learning to improvise is have them play whole notes (semi-breve I think???) on the root of the chord. Try that. It will help you get through the form. When you are playing a solo you have to know where you are in the form at all times. Playing whole notes along with the backing track or your teacher if he or she accompanies you makes sure you are aware of the form and drills it in. I would not let them do anything fancier until they could do that every time.
 
As with Skeller's suggestions above you need to go beyond the notes. Trying to think about where you are in relation to the notes is not being in and part of the music. It must come from within you. Step back and take in the whole thing. Hear it all, then SING what you would play.

Rhythm doesn't come from what's written as an academic construct, especially in improvisation. Rhythm is in the body. That's what dancing is about. In West Africa if someone wants to become a drummer they must first become a good dancer! In "Western" music we still keep the remnant of the rhythm in the body by tapping our foot. Hearing and feeling the music and becoming part of it is easiest when we aren't trying to engage with music academically or force specific technical exercises on it. Improvisation is your singing voice transferred to your instrument.

Doing graded courses is OK for a while in learning the mechanical properties of the instrument, rudimentary reading, and basically how to play it. If your goal is improvisation, then you need to be able to sing what your mind/ear hears as fitting, and then be able to execute this with appropriate feeling on your instrument. What one plays against a rhythm can be "flexible" as long as it makes sense and there is a "flow". People are very good at picking up when the object is precise rhythm... and it's not happening.

Here's a humble example of a strong rhythm with a melodic improvisation that is mostly off the rhythm but attempts to flow through it. Just another way to think about rhythm and improvisation: wikiloops_jam_290381.mp3 | Powered by Box
 
Last edited:
Blue Monk is a 12 bar blues.
12 bar blues can be expressed as three chunks of four.
1.Hello.
2.How are you.
3.Goodbye.

12 bar blues is a common vehicle for improvisation. It's the omnibus for jamming.

Count it while listening. Once you've got it, don't count it while playing, feel it.

The 12 bar format is absolutely everywhere, from the early beginnings of blues and jazz to rock, pop and soul.

Once you hear it, it'll drive you nuts.
 
Keeping track of where you are in the form is one of the ongoing challenges in improvisation, especially in tunes with more static chord progressions that hang on one chord for extended periods.

As usual, the cure lies in more listening and more playing along with records. Whether you use Aebersolds or equivalent, or play along with actual records, or hire a rhythm section, or use Band in a Box, you need to add time simply playing the music.

12 bar blues is a good way to get started as there are chord changes, but not too fast or too many. You might want to pick up a copy of the Aebersold "blues in all keys" which is just that, but each track has both simple and complex blues forms, and there are several different rhythmic styles.

Personally I would ditch the "blues scale in G" approach and actually play the harmonies that are there. For example, Blue Monk is what we call a "quick four" blues; the second bar goes to the 4 chord. Now if you're playing the tune in G as you seeem to be, the thing that makes that quick 4 be there, is the note Bb which IS present in C7 the four chord, and ISN'T present in G7 the one chord. So if you want to emphasize the movement in and out of the four chord for the quick four, you'll want to play the Bb during the C7 and not play it during the G7. Just slathering the so-called blues scale all over the whole progression is like smothering your steak, potatoes, green beans, and pie with ketchup.

To finish off, I'd suggest you actually listen to MONK playing the tune. I bet you'll get some insights. One thing about listening to Monk is he doesn't play real fast most of the time, so it's pretty easy to figure out what he's doing. WHY he's doing it? Well, that's a bit more of a head-scratcher sometimes.
 
Unlike the other commenterz, I suck at this.
What helps me is not to think in notes but in 2 bar (outline) phrases, kind of like guard rails within, as Colin says, the form. So 2 hello phrases, 2 how are you and two goodby.
Within which you can introduce whatever variations feel good.

, I know exactly what I want to play.
 
Rhythmic ideas and the notes are not so much an issue, I know exactly what I want to play. But can I count and keep track of which bar I'm in when I'm doing so? Hell no! Even taking the improv right back to basics; quavers, semibreves and equivalent rests only - I have a real tough time counting to 4 consistently! Is this is a common problem? How do people usually keep track of where they are when improvising?

Developing from what others have said, you need to feel rather than count the beat, bars and structure. So put the saxophone aside and sing "what you hear in your head" while listening to the backing.

Rather than tapping your foot or counting to four in your head, move your body and don't feel self conscious about it.

It's a leap to being able to convert what you hear in your head into what you play on your instrument, so keep things simple to begin with.

And as a final piece of advice, let the music breathe, so don't try to cram in as many notes as possible. Leave space and "sing in phrases".

Rhys
 
I agree with Rhys sometimes what you don't play can be as important as what you do play.
You will eventually feel where you are with listening, playing just a few notes over a 12 bar blues is a good start because the chord progression is easier.
 
In addition to the above:
"To Mine the Mind."
Can you memorize the piano sheet music you play and then play it back correctly?
If not, then you are only mining your ability to read, which is what your mind has available.
Get a copy of the piano music to Blue Monk and memorize the tune, in the key you'll be playing on Sax.
That's the start of filling the mind.
Play it over and over and over and hopefully you'll begin to feel the tune.

It's called improvising but is the result of hundreds or thousands of times, playing tunes straight, variations by others and then the variations you've composed.
You don't need the horn to compose.

Write down a solo you have in your mind for Blue Monk, after writing the original melody from memory.
 
For the blues form, keep this in mind.

When you see me comin', heist your window high.
When you see me comin', heist your window high.
When you see me goin', hang your head and cry.

and THAT, boys and girls, is the 12 bar blues in a nutshell.

I'm serious.
 
I've practiced this tune recently as well. A couple of suggestions from my teacher to use as building blocks:

* like what @skeller047 suggested, after you play root notes, play chord arpeggios (1-3-5) over each bar. Then play inversions. Once you do this a few times you should have a better intuitive sense of the form. You can play with the rhythm of these as well, swing some, play some straight, drop some notes, etc.

* literally write down your improv. This isn't what you want to actually do in practice, but as a learning tool it'll help you see how your improv fits (or doesn't fit!) in the tempo/form of the tune.
 
There's some really fantastic advice in here. Thanks so much.

I'm somewhat aware of the 12 bar blues though i've never studied it specifically but I did suspect the 12 bars of improv was likely to be exactly that. My teacher provided a photo copy of a book page so I'm working to a metronome only, as with all of the old method books the backing tracks are provided on a CD in a world that has long forgotten about that technology!
 
Well, I'm in the world and I haven't "forgotten about CDs". What a strange comment.

So go buy yourself a $30 CD player and some headphones, and get after it.

Janey Aebersold has a wealth of play along records/books. Actually, I'd be surprised if you can't download mp3s from Aebersold.

At any rate, the most important thing in improvising is to start, and to play along with records (in whatever format you wish). Improvisation is about hearing the surroundings and making melodies that fit with the surroundings.
 
For the blues form, keep this in mind.

When you see me comin', heist your window high.
When you see me comin', heist your window high.
When you see me goin', hang your head and cry.

At a slow 4/4 tempo that could
be 6 bars. 😀

Always a fun project to put music to words/lyrics.
A buddy gave five Broadway composers a poem she wrote and asked them to write a tune for those words. It was for an exhibit in a children's museum for art/science and she also sketched a picture to go along with the poem.
The results varied from a Southwest Native American musical themed tune to a Wagner opera.
They all did it for free, but she then sent them all a check.
I was asked to write one as well, since we've been friends since childhood.
Mine was the Southwest Native American tune, in C major, so the kids could learn it with just the piano's white keys or a Chromatic harp without using the slide.

We should all write a melody for Turf3's lyrics. :clapping:
 
Last edited:
It's what they call a "floating lyric" - been used for generations. Same with "woke up this morning with the blues".

I've read references to Big Bill Broonzy using the "heist your window" lines but I bet it goes way back before him.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,511
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom