Reeds Can you guess the synthetic reed?

Which is the synthetic reed

  • Reed 1

    Votes: 4 22.2%
  • Reed 2

    Votes: 11 61.1%
  • I really can't tell

    Votes: 3 16.7%

  • Total voters
    18
Well, you got me.

Well, I didn't really get you. As I said before it wasn't a trick.

At least if I got you, I got me as well because I have to say this was a real surprise to me also as I've been staunchly prejudiced against synthetics reeds for years.
 
I understand it was no trick, just that for years I have been a staunch traditional reed user, having tried many types of synthetics and having not been convinced of their sound qualities (but realising their usefulness on a practical level when doubling for example) But with this comparism I was convinced "due to my prejudices" of the results being the other way round. I thought I could hear a "plastic" quality to the recording. So I am very pleasantly surprised by the results and that finally we might have a synthetic reed that one may rely on and feel comfortable with (in terms of sound) that is equal to a good cane reed. Again, thanks Pete for a great resource for us sax blowers.
 
Well, I didn't really get you. As I said before it wasn't a trick.

At least if I got you, I got me as well because I have to say this was a real surprise to me also as I've been staunchly prejudiced against synthetics reeds for years.

Pete

I see Lewingtons have these available now at £26.99, not cheap. I wonder how one decides on what strength is right to replace one's existing reeds, in my case Marca Jazz 3s. I can't find any comparison charts show both.

The price does seem somewhat steep also.
 
Pete

I see Lewingtons have these available now at £26.99, not cheap.

Have a look at Reeds Direct
http://www.reeds-direct.co.uk/instrument/reeds/tenor-saxophone.html

As for conversion from current reed, then you may need to find a chart that converts your current reed to one that does appear on the legere chart
(eg http://www.windplus.co.uk/supplies/legere_strength_chart.pdf )

But when I was looking into these, while many people were telling me to find my legere equivalent and then go down a quarter strength, others said they played softer than conversion strength.

Just proves everyone is different, and shows why there is a legere return policy to help you get the right one.

Chris
 
Last edited by a moderator:
H
Just proves everyone is different, and shows why there is a legere return policy to help you get the right one.

That's right. I am a bit concerned that the one I got at Frankfurt may be marked differently to the production models. I think this was a prototype.

But maybe David Beecroft (deebee) will be along soon to answer this.
 
Have a look at Reeds Direct
http://www.reeds-direct.co.uk/instrument/reeds/tenor-saxophone.html

Hi Chris,

These are the original two Légère reeds, the Signature is new and Reeds Direct don't yet stock of it.

As for conversion from current reed, then you may need to find a chart that converts your current reed to one that does appear on the legere chart
(eg http://www.windplus.co.uk/supplies/legere_strength_chart.pdf )

Chris

The strength chart hasn't got the Signature reed on it and Légère haven't updated their chart on their website so it's a bit difficult to make any judgments about the strength equivalent of this particular Légère reed at the moment. At best we know that Pete has a 2.4 and he usually plays a RJS 2M or is it a 2S?

From another thread:

2.4 on tenor, a bit softer on alto, but the Legere signature alto I tried at Frankfurt was not yet in production, and I don't think they'd finished working out the grading.

Just to clear up the grading thing... Pete received a prototype reed that had been measured at the factory as 2.40± in strength. It would be stamped as a 2-1/2. We brought a pile of reeds to the Frankfurt Musikmesse to get an idea of how hard the various players think the Signature reeds are. There is no real consensus between the reed makers as to what the numbers actually mean. With one marking of reed i.e. 2-1/2 you will always find a small variance in strengths. With cane reeds as much as a 1/2 strength between the hardest and softest reeds in a box. This is the same for mouthpieces as they all play a little differently. One mouthpiece maker calls this the "ghost in the machine". I personally think that the Signature tenor reeds are graded very similarly to the Java reeds. The grading system is like the rest of the Legere reeds, in 1/4 strengths. The Studio cut reeds played a little hard in the lower register and a little soft in the upper register. This is why it is so critical to get the strength just right with the Studio cut reeds. The Signature reeds are extremely consistent from the lowest note to the altissimo register. You can play from a whisper on low Bb (If you have done your longtones!) to a roar. The high notes are bang on. The reeds are also great on open mouthpieces. I normally play an 8* JodyJazz and tested the Signature reeds on a 10* Jody HR and it played great. O.K. I know, I am raving. I will say this though, since developing the reeds with Guy Légère in February of this year I haven't played a cane reed. Before then, I was a confirmed wood-a-holic and now I never touch the stuff.
As far as getting the Tenor Signatures is concerned I believe that they are just now shipping so it might be a short while yet before they show up. You also might need to inform your shop as they may not even know about them yet.
D.

I'm looking forward to trying one of these,

Chris
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just ordered a 3 and 3.25 from WW&R - I'll swap out the one that's not right for another of the same strength. WW&R suggested a 2.75 or 3 to match the Marca Jazz reeds I have been using but I've been thinking of moving to a slightly harder reed to help my upper register so I thought I give it a try.Price is less than £20 rather than the Lewington suggested retail which was a nice surprise.

I'll update here when I have had a chance to try them out.
 
Hi Ian,

I'm obviously being dense, WW&R as in the same company as Reeds Direct? Did you telephone your order? and it was the Signature you ordered? £20 seems a little more reasonable.

I'm officially out of tenor reeds apart form the two that are in my reed guard so now would be a good time for me if I can get to try one of these Légère tenor Signature reeds.

Best wishes,

Chris
 
Hi Ian,

I'm obviously being dense, WW&R as in the same company as Reeds Direct? Did you telephone your order? and it was the Signature you ordered? £20 seems a little more reasonable.

I'm officially out of tenor reeds apart form the two that are in my reed guard so now would be a good time for me if I can get to try one of these Légère tenor Signature reeds.

Best wishes,

Chris

You're too hard on yourself >:)

WW&R are a sister co to Reeds Direct. I called Lewingtons and they suggested WW&R would have the Signature so I called them. I think Reed Direct should have them also. Hopefully they'll arrive tomorrow, I normally get fantastic service from them.
 
I ordered my Signature Legere from Reeds Direct last week - wanted 2.5 but the softest they had in stock was a 3.0. That arrived next day and was something like £16.90.

The reed sounded and felt really good but it was a bit hard for me. I rang Reeds Direct to see whether I could take advantge of the Legere deal for exchange of a reed for a replacement in a different strength. They said that they are not sure what strengths are available, but to send it back and they will try to get hold of it in 2.5. Their source is actually Lewingtons, who show it being available in quarter strengths from 2.0 to 4.0, so I am hopeful. Not sure how Lewingtons can sell it for £26.99 and Reeds Direct for £16.90 !

Back to the reed - it seemed very close in sound and in strength grading to RJS, so I think that 2.5 should suit me well (I normally go for 2m or 2h in the Rico and 2.5 in Vandoren Java). I am quite hopeful that this could become my main reed - but I did pick on an Alexander DC for the gig I played on Saturday and it was great: reminded me just what a good cane reed can give you.

Rhys
 
HI Ian,

Thanks, I just gave them (WW&R) a call and apparently they don't stock them under strength 3 at the moment "well that's what we have on the system" I was told.

It was an amusing phone call in the end as the guy I spoke to said he's go and check the catalogue and promptly disappeared, for several minutes I was hanging on thinking when do I assume I've been forgotten and hang up when two other people in quick succession picked up the phone and asked how they could help!

The up shot is that they don't seem to be aware of any reed strengths below a 3, but if there are some, they will get them in due course...

I'm thinking of trying a 2.5 or 2.25, I'm currently using RJS-2M.

I'll keen to hear what you think when you've had an opportunity to try them.

All the best,

Chris
 
Looks like I'll be sticking with cane reeds then. I'm keen to try these new Signiture ones, but I play a wide open mouthpiece, and unavailability of anything under a 3 rules them out.

Legere don't seem to be making much of an effort to sell them here. Lewingtons aren't really a retailer these days, and their web site is awful, WW&R have limited stock, and Legere's own web site has 'Latest News' as April 2009! Maybe I'll look again in another few months to see if they've sorted their act out.
 
Well, as always, Reeds Direct/WW&B delivered in record minimum time!

First thoughts (I couldn't resist trying the Signature out despite supposed to be working!) are that the 3 is going to be about my limit and I may even need to drop to a 2.75. The overall sound is superb in the midrange, strong in the upper but low D and below require more support than my Marca Jazz reeds, though one new one out of the box this weekend blowed harder than usual and is similar to the Sig' 3 though a further one from the same box was very easy blowing. maybe nearer a 2.75 and was my choice for use.

The 3.25 Sig' is just too much and I struggle to tongue low C, B or Bb from a standing start, less so if I walk on down but the harder one is too much for me with my 7* mouthpiece.

Anyway, I'll have a proper blow tonight and report back.
 
I've just ordered a 2.5 tenor signature and looking forward to giving it a try, they said they'll try and get it to me by the weekend! Fingers crossed. I'll report back once I've had a chance to try it.

Chris
 
Well I can report favourably on the Sig 3. Having spent some hours blowing the sound is superb right from the off and totally consistent. I am debating whether to swap the 3.25 for another 3 or a 2.75. Reeds Direct expect to have them in stock any day now (they have 3s and above already).
 
I ordered a Legere 1.75 baritone reed as a result of this discussion, on 29 April from Reed Direct. It came next day - wonderful! I get bottom A and the top end much easier now. I've just received a 2.0 baritone reed. As expected, a little harder, but fine to play.
At the same time I got an alto 1.75. Seems to be much too hard for me at initial playing. Great pity, since I was looking forward to being able to pick up a 'dry' alto that plays instantly.
I always order over the internet, even though they are my local (14 miles) music shop.
Malcolm
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom