Reeds Can you guess the synthetic reed?

Which is the synthetic reed

  • Reed 1

    Votes: 4 22.2%
  • Reed 2

    Votes: 11 61.1%
  • I really can't tell

    Votes: 3 16.7%

  • Total voters
    18

Chris J

Member
Messages
194
Location
Southampton, UK
Makes the point very well. There is nothing to really distinguish between them. They both sound perfectly good reeds.

My guess, and it can only be a guess, is that the number 2 recording is the synthetic - only because the bottom notes remind me of my Légère

Chris
 

Morgan Fry

Senior Member
Messages
447
Location
Leeds
Smallish but noticeable difference on my laptop speakers. The first one tone is more even throughout, and more centered. Response is better, too. Might have as much to do with the difference in cut as material.
 

Jules

Formerly known as "nachoman"
Messages
4,450
Location
brighton by the sea
I reckon number one's the synthetic.... there's a bit of 'hollowness' to the low notes which,well, reminds me of my own experiences of synthetics (by the way- re your article- have you tried Fibracells?)
 

Chris98

Senior Member
Messages
1,076
I'm going against the trend, but I think the synthetic is reed 1, it sounds very consistent and even up the scale, where as reed 2 has that occasional cane quirk that throws a curved ball towards the top of the scale making it slightly less even.

But to be honest the differences are so slight that I'd reckon you would have equally minutely different soundclips if you used the same reed and had just taken the reed and ligature off and put them back on again.

Pete the tone is one very important thing, but how does it feel against the lip and when using articulation?

Best wishes,

Chris
 

Bari251

Member
Messages
71
Location
Norwich
I would choose reed 1 as the 'better' reed. I've never tried one. Mainly because you can guarantee that I would have to buy five or six, in order to find one that suited my embouchure. How do most people cope with this problem, or is it just my difficulty in finding the right combination of mouthpiece/reed/ligature?
Malcolm
 

old git

Tremendous Bore
That Pete Thomas knows something. Enquired whether a medium soft or soft Fibracell would work on a PPT 9* and Pete said he didn't know. Tried the 9 with a medium soft for quite a while but then noticed that Pete was using RJS 2 Medium. Found that 2 Soft to 3 Medium were on my reed shelf so tried 2 Soft, then 2 Medium and 2 Hard but that nice Mr. Thomas knew his stuff. Now must get YC to have a go and confirm.
Whichever is the synthetic, I'm getting one.
 

kevgermany

ex Landrover Nut
Subscriber
Messages
21,997
Location
Just north of Munich
This from the page:

Both wood and metal were quickly accepted as an ideal solution to the problem of replacing an unstable material, as the sound was either not affected or to many people⁽s ears, the sound was actually better.

Should it start 'Both ebonite and metal...'?

Preferred the sound of the first reed, so my guess is that it's the cane one.
 

AlanT

Senior Member
Messages
234
Location
Mechanic Falls, Maine
I hear the first as cane, the second as synthetic..I say this because there are sound quirks in Fibracells that I've played that I believe I hear in the second sample. If I'm wrong oh well, I'm an amateur what do I know.
 

rhysonsax

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,518
Location
Surrey, UK
I voted for reed 2 as the Legere, purely because the very first note seemed a touch hesitant to speak and that was my experience with Legere reeds. Other than that I heard little difference between the two on my small speakers.

Rhys
 
Top Bottom