Saxophones Can we talk about GAS?

I would have one of each if I could.
I Played on my YTS-21 from middle school (1975) until 2002 when I started getting into vintage horns. Didn't really think much about it. My only regret is that I left that 1977 era tone edge in the case when I sold it! :blush:

Now, as a matter of discipline, If I get something new I make myself sell something old.
Currently for me it's the mouthpiece rabbit hole. I think I have found my "holy grail" alto mouthpiece (sure you did!).
I do feel that sense of loss when I drop those old ones in the mail though.

The bottom-line IMO is, the only reason to replace a horn is if it not playing well or is damaged AND the cost of the repair outstrips the cost of a new horn, or the horn was lost/stolen.
 
The bottom-line IMO is, the only reason to replace a horn is if it not playing well or is damaged AND the cost of the repair outstrips the cost of a new horn, or the horn was lost/stolen.
Overall what you state is a good rule of thumb. We have a few who have the means financially, who buy historic instruments for collecting and also playing.

Some will pay the additional cost of repair even if exceeds new because they prefer their older instrument, a "proven workhorse". (We have some who still use a Selmer Mark VI sax.)

Others have additional instruments as backups and "job site use" (stored on-site). Those in performance settings (pay and volunteer) need a backup so they can continue playing when their main instrument needs or is in repair.

And, some just love to have additional instruments. A few have additional to do / learn repair techniques. (I have 3 venerable Boosey & Hawkes Edgware Bb soprano clarinets, bought them "for a song", quite lovely but humble, a "Ramen eating" musician's doubling instrument.) 🙂

Anyway IMO, my 2-cents (USD). 😉

By the way, welcome to the forum! 😀
 
Yikes..Not been on here for absolutely ages...
I had an interesting look thru this thread as someone who appreciates older ( 'historic' 🙂 ) instruments.. I just realised my battered Hawkes & Sons XX century alto is 100 years old this year.
.. a while back I found some site which quoted serial nos / dates for those, mine came out as 1925 ( oddly I could never find that website thingy again when I tried to find it )
Anyway in my opinion ( of dubious worth no doubt ) I reckon the XX cent. is a cracking little alto with build quality you'll certainly never see again in this version of reality.
It's the one I've always kept even when flogging everything else, and whenever i've 'auditioned' it side by side with any other alto it's always the one you think without hesitation 'Yep that's the one to hang on to' ... Not bad for 130 quid as I recall !
As regards GAS for me now..a Baritone
'
 
( oddly I could never find that website thingy again when I tried to find it )
Problem is today that many of the standard, informative resources have evaporated on the 'net. Sometimes one can find them on the Wayback Machine, but not always. Hence, the Café has become an even more important source of info.
It's the one I've always kept even when flogging everything else, and whenever i've 'auditioned' it side by side with any other alto it's always the one you think without hesitation 'Yep that's the one to hang on to' ... Not bad for 130 quid as I recall !
I know the feeling. Until it got dropped about a year ago, now needing major repairs was my early 1950's Beaugnier Vito low Bb bari. Bought it for equivalent £237.30 13 years ago (roughly abused ex-school instrument, much of it was in shipping costs due to distance), repaired it. Not much to look at, but played beautifully in tune and one of the easiest instruments to play altissimo with.
As regards GAS for me now..a Baritone
It is why I have 2. 😉
 
... Those in performance settings (pay and volunteer) need a backup so they can continue playing when their main instrument needs or is in repair.
...
Not necessarily. I play regularly with a group but don't have a backup sax. My tenor lost a regulation cork last weekend, I got handed a spare tenor by a doubler in time for my solo, then a quick fix with a mouthpiece pad in place of cork sorted my horn until I could take it into the shop on Monday. I just got it back today, ready for another weekend.

Actually the more I think about it, the more I think a backup would be a good idea. But I'd have to take it with me to every practice session, which doesn't appeal. I think one backup horn for each section of a group is a good idea though.
 
Actually the more I think about it, the more I think a backup would be a good idea. But I'd have to take it with me to every practice session, which doesn't appeal. I think one backup horn for each section of a group is a good idea though.
Everyone's situation is different. For me, a backup instrument stayed in the car, was available if I needed it. If my instrument was in prime condition, I didn't bother with a backup, especially in rehearsals. Depending on venue, doesn't always have to be the same type instrument. Example, when I had a problem with my alto, my soprano fitted in nicely either busking or in a small combo. Community Band - need same type instrument.

4 years ago for kicks, I signed up for an undergraduate sax jazz combo lab class at Eastern New Mexico University with a senior tuition discount (65+ years old. Instructor accepted my military band credentials in lieu of audition.) My tenor sax became unplayable, there was insufficient time for repair. I brought my alto instead, played it in our combo during their Spring jazz concert. We received an outstanding ovation of applause. (Only fault was the program listed me on tenor - not a big thing.)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,379
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom