Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Chinese/Japanese pads are thinner - Pisoni do a J series especially.

If the pads aren't the right thickness, they don't contact the tone holes properly. So a lot of key bending is needed to make them work.

If they're too big, they won't fit. If they're too small, you may get away with it - as long as they cover the tone hole properly, but it looks really ugly and you'll find it difficult to keep them centered over the tone hole.
 
Yep. I probably should have shimmed the last two I did, but I just used extra shellac, which worked but wasn't ideal. I didn't want to just use cardboard, in case it got water into it, but I suppose I could have coated it with clear polyurethane varnish. Mostly, I just got carried away with wanting to get it done, once I had bits taken off the sax.

The singles at Dawkes are all 4mm thick, as are the ZhengHao synthetic membrane ones I linked to. They do others, but I haven't looked properly. Hopefully the ebay Chinese ones are what my Venus soprano uses.
 
she won't do legato between D2 and C#2 but will if you use C#1 fingering with the octave key. Suspect a bit of a leak on the G key, playable but needs additional pressure.
I'm having a similar issue with my "new" soprano - playing down from D2 to C#2 or C2. I haven't quite decided why, though I have some ideas (including just me being clumsy) but I've found some sort of solution, for now.

The octave key helps with starting D2, but isn't needed at all, once it's playing, so if I let go of it asap, before going down to lower notes, I get a much smoother transition.

I can play D2 without using the octave key at all, of course, but that gets confusing and I sometimes get it wrong, so it's good to just use it to kick the note off in the right octave. If the next note is higher, I can hold on to the octave key, if it's lower, it seems it's best if I let go of it early.
 
Hmm... I'll have a go at that next time I get it out, Colin. I've played D2 like that, but it seems pretty muffled, and mostly just useful for short fast notes, or grace notes.

The other thing I sometimes do is go from D2 to C#2 just lifting my fingers off the BAG keys, and thumb off the octave key, if it's still on it, but keeping some or all of them on the FED keys.

It's a touch flat, I guess, but it works well enough. It's especially useful if I want to play D2 -> C#2 -> D2, rather than trying to lift all six fingers (and left thumb) off and put them back down again smoothly.
 
The standard way of doing this is to lift off just 1 and 2 and keep the octave key on.
I was getting a C2, doing that today, but it's possible the top part of my C# key was sticking, if that's the right term - the one that's a small key sat on top of a key with a hole in it, above the LH1 B key. I noticed the smaller key didn't always separate from the one below it, when I pressed the octave key. I'll have to try it again, now I've fiddled with it a bit more...
 
Erm, no. That key is held closed (both parts) by the Bis key, so any of the right hand finger keys keeps it closed - so my "new" soprano just does play a C2 with that fingering. In tune, and not too strained too, so I guess that's what it's meant to do.

I'll have to do a survey of my other saxes, at some point 🙂
 
Thanks, Nick. I think my straight sop is probably part Yani rip off, in design - it looks similar to the S880 that Stephen Howard reviewed, but with some differences in the shapes of keys. Maybe playing C2 for that fingering is just a Yani / Yani clone thing?

I normally limit myself to one sax per day, and I don't get to play every day, but I'll check the rest of them soonish. I'll probably play the straight sop again next, to check the small tweaks I've been doing to it this evening - replacing a couple of small bumpers and adjusting spring tension.
 
I tried that fingering on my Trevor James alto today (Rev II), and yes, it gives a C#, not a C when I lift off LH1&2, while playing the D2 (keeping my thumb on the octave key).

I notice it doesn't have a split key for C# - small key closing a hole in a bigger key, just above the LH1 B key - like on my "new" soprano, and the Bis key doesn't close that key, like on the soprano (also slaved from any of the FED keys) - only B and A (LH1&2) close that key on the "Trevor".

So, there's a dilemma. Do I learn to use that fingering but remember it does different things on those two saxes? I'll try the other saxes soon. I don't have many - it just takes me a while to get around to things 🙂

I decided to try my Zinner C melody mouthpiece on the alto today - with the Legere Signature #2 reed. I could get it in tune, once it warmed up - leaving about 1/4" of cork left. It felt a bit more resistant, but actually not that bad, and quite playable, with quite a nice warm / dark sort of sound.

I then tried my Yamha 4CM on the alto (ebonite 4C + a tiny bit more tip opening), with the same reed. I've had that a while, but I gave up on playing it and bought a Selmer Super Session F, second hand. It wasn't bad - brighter sound, and easy enough to play high up, but I was still struggling to get good sounding low notes, which is why I stopped using it originally.

I've ordered a Yamaha 7CM alto mouthpiece for "Trevor", which I've been thinking about for a while (remains to be seen if they're really got one). I'll try both on the Thomann C melody too, soon. They look like the shank might just be long enough to stay on the neck, in tune. We'll see.
 
... I thought I'd better get my old Wurlitzer out and give it a blow, the first time for over a year. Impressions:
1. My sling still feels like a cleric's dog collar when I have it high enough for the C-Mel
Giving this some more thought, my Venus curved soprano is a bit like that - if I use a normal sling, it feels like I'm being gently strangled.

I bought a cheap harness on ebay - about £6, which was better, but the strap across roughly where my sternum is would pull forwards, so it wasn't holding the strap hook close enough. So, I added a bit of wood, and a velcro strap, to keep the hook closer.

Here's a couple of pics. I keep harnesses like that on a coat hanger, so I don't have to solve a puzzle every time I put them on. Next to it is my SaxHolder 3, which does the same job if I pull the knots of the strings through, from the back, bring them round to the front, and tie them in a bow. For my straight sop, alto and C Melody, there's no need to do that, but you might have to for yours, by the sound of it.

P1010082.webp


P1010087.webp


Incidentally, some of those cheap harnesses come with nasty plastic hooks, that break easily. This one came with a metal carabiner style hook (snap hook) - I asked, before I bought it.

You're welcome to borrow the harness, if you like Richard, to see if it helps. If it does, the SaxHolder will probably work too. Harnesses can feel a bit uncomfortable at first, but once you get the straps adjusted, and get used to wearing one, they're really not that bad. I always preferred it to having all that weight on the back of my neck, even with just an alto.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom