Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

image.webp
image.webp


These are from his website (the other two are a soprano and a baritone).
(I think this is OK to do, since we're effectively advertising them?)
 
Is the C Mel really such a lost cause tone-wise?

What is it that makes a C Mel so tame when the alto and tenor on either side can scream?

I can play loud rock n roll on mine with ease. It's a 1920s Conn straight neck, but it has an aftermarket curved neck, modern metal reflector pads and modern blued springs. I play it with a metal tenor piece, a Brihart Level Air 9. Plays in tune, as well.
 
I have emailed and asked if he's decided what parts he wants me to play so I can transpose them in advance
Unless he wants that extra bit of range of the tenor, he might just be thinking in terms of brass - F parts on a Bb brass instrument makes sense, but I think I'd find it easier to transpose down a fifth than down a fourth - because I'm used to clarinets, and there's (and octave and) a fifth between the chalumeau and clarion registers - so the chalumeau F is the same fingering as clarion C.

I found a pic of it (at least I think it is).
Was that your C melody, Nick? It looks nice.
 
Last edited:
Jay mentioned the Rico Metalites. That seems like a good bet for a rock & roll sound - and a pretty cheap experiment to try.
I've yet to try that, but think I will. I tried a B7 Graftonite on the C mel and didn't like it. Mind you, my STM seems OK, and has the benefit that I'm playing on the same mouthpiece for both.
 
Or you could take up the French horn 🙂 I could recommend someone to sell you a nice one for a very reasonable price.
By all accounts a real pig of an instrument to master (or to play at all). The good news, if there is any, is that playing F parts on an Eb instrument is the same as plying C parts on a Bb instrument. You put everything a tone up
 
Jay mentioned the Rico Metalites. That seems like a good bet for a rock & roll sound - and a pretty cheap experiment to try.

Yup. I actually have one to use with the original straight neck, so it's had a cm sliced off the end. Works well. Not exactly subtle, but fun. If any of the new C mel players want to borrow it to try out, send me a PM/conversation message.
 
So: When a horn plays a written C, it sounds as an F (so a perfect 5th down). When I play a written C, it sounds as a Bb (so a major 2nd down). So in order to sound like a horn playing a C, I would need to play a G - ie a fourth down from what's written??
Or a 5th up, I don't know how horn parts are notated.
 
By all accounts a real pig of an instrument to master (or to play at all).
I don't expect I'll ever master it, but playing it at all isn't as hard as you'd think. You can find a range you're comfortable with fairly easily, and then try to expand it. The low end of the range is hard, and the not particularly high end gets harder because the partials get so close together, which is where the Bb side of the horn helps - it behaves like a bass trumpet - an octave lower than a normal Bb trumpet, if you think of it in Bb transposition - though you're supposed to think of the whole thing as an F instrument. The F side of the horn is a fourth below the Bb side.

Or a 5th up, I don't know how horn parts are notated.
I stick to treble clef music (for Bb brass or sax) and mostly regard it as a Bb instrument (like a bass four valve flugelhorn) transposing down further, but it officially plays a fifth lower than written (in F transposition) - i.e. it plays the F below the C that's written on the score for that note in normal French horn music. There were other keys for horns to be built in though, so there are some pieces in odd transpositions, apparently.

... but yes, I see what you mean. You end up in a different octave on the sax anyway, so playing a fifth up works too - read a C, play the G a fifth up (on a tenor), to give you a concert F, one octave up, or play the G a fourth down, to give you the F an octave below that.
 
Last edited:
... but yes, I see what you mean. You end up in a different octave on the sax anyway, so playing a fifth up works too - read a C, play the G a fifth up (on a tenor), to give you a concert F, one octave up, or play the G a fourth down, to give you the F an octave below that.
A fifth up is visually easier, IMO. Up two spaces or two lines.
 
I can't remember if we've covered this already, but saxophones were originally supposed to be in C and F, for orchestral use (like recorders - though F recorders aren't regarded as transposing instruments), and Bb/Eb for military band use.

Orchestral clarinetists normally have Bb and A clarinets, in the normal size, to cover more keys more easily, though not for the larger and smaller sizes. The same thing doesn't happen with saxes, but having ones built in any two different keys available, has to help - B major is just horrible, for example, but B major on a tenor is just A on a C mel, which is quite an easy key to play in.

There's a lot of prejudice against alto clarinets too, I've noticed. All other sizes are considered okay, just not altos, for some reason. I can accept that they don't project well, which could be a problem for playing live, unamplified, against other instruments, but that isn't the usual criticism that people level against them. Usually, they say the tone is horrible, which I don't get at all. I have a nothing special Vito student model alto clarinet, which I really enjoy, and which I think sounds great.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom