Tech/maintenance BW Not playing G properly

Re: bauhaus walstein owners club

I may have spoken too soon...

The lower G is playing quite nicely now, but upper G is playing hard to get. Crystal Ball to the ready...is it likely to be operator error, or is there somewhere else I need to look?

I can't wait for the manual to arrive, and I think I need to invest in a leak light, and do some sort of repair course next time we're back in the UK. There's nothing like a challenge to keep you going!

Sorry...:blush:

Sallie
 
Re: bauhaus walstein owners club

Assuming it's still the same problem, the felt is probably either too thick, or too thin... But is close.

Take a look at the A/C touchpiece. It closes 3 keys. All 3 must close together. Exactly together. A small gap under the A/C touchpiece won't matter, so don't worry about that. It's the point of closure you're interested in, not the start of the key movement. (at least it is to get this working). Just take a good look at the three keys as they close. Another way of looking at it without a leak light is to use cigarette papers, it's quite possible to get a piece under each of the three keys at the same time and then identify which opens first.

Does pressing the Bis Bb key as well help the problem?

Adjust felt by using a thicker piece, or by sanding with 400/600 grade wet and dry. Hopefully the felt is pretty hard. If it's not the felt under the touchpiece then tell us what's happening.

Also worth taking a look in your sax case - is there a piece of felt or cork in there that could have fallen off?
 
Re: bauhaus walstein owners club

Moderator,
As this concerns a BW, why isn't in the BW Club thread?>:)

The BW club thread should be about the BW club, e.g people to discuss their BWs in general.

But there is no reason why every post that relates to BWs has to be in that thread, and in this case it is a technical issue that applies to any saxophone so it does make sense to me that it's in its own thread.
 
Re: bauhaus walstein owners club

Well, despite the book, hours of patience, weeks of sourcing the right bits and pieces and loads of tlc, the darned thing (note it's demotion!) is still not playing properly. 😡

I am now awaiting a response from the supplier, who shall at this point remain nameless, and from B-W customer service. The end of the tether is in sight.

On the bright side, my neglected alto is coming out to play...
 
Re: bauhaus walstein owners club

Hi Sally,

I've just gone back through this thread to remind myself of the problem - the G2 isn't playing correctly? Can you describe what is happening? A thought occurred to me that you may be getting the 'harmonic' D instead of the G.......... More info might be useful.

Cheers,

Amanda
 
Re: The mysterious case of the 'G'...

I was going to embarrass myself and upload an MP3 of the offending note(s), but technology is also conspiring against me today!

Playing down from C, all is fine and tuned until the G button, when the note effectively disappears with a squawk. There is a higher pitch to it. The F is fine, but F# often does the same. Strangely, coming up, F# is OK, but the G reverts to type with the disappearing squawk. This also happens when playing across intervals, or when the G is the first note.

I am a very patient person, and have spent hours poring over Stephens' book, examining the sax, testing with fag papers, listening, tormenting my long-suffering husband (Bass player, and tempted to strangle me with a string!), and turning the air blue with Greek and Anglo-Saxon curses. Any words of wisdom or even ones of kindly abuse would be most welcome.

Becoming frustrated, and not in a good way! :shrug:
 
Re: The mysterious case of the 'G'...

If you've got an electronic tuner see if you can identify the note played when fingering that G2 - chances are it could be the D harmonic. G2 on tenor is a notoriously unstable note (the wiser forum members will explain why........!). So it COULD (not definite) be user induced issue!
I still have problems with mine occasionally, esp when a bit tense ie.when I play during my lesson!! More air support and mouth further onto mouthpiece has helped, and trying to ignore it when it does go wrong, so I don't expect it the next time....

Amanda
 
Re: The mysterious case of the 'G'...

Sallie

Could you confirm which G is the problem? Your post (#23) suggested that the lower G was now OK, but the upper G was a problem. Is that still the case?

If so, when you finger that upper G, does the pad on the neck come down and grab the fag paper over the tone hole as it should?

Chris
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,686
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom