Smooth & Fusion Blackbird

I was disappointed! Expected something great, but it's just different to me, but rather flat. The simplicity of the original is hard to beat IMHO.

Perhaps a more complex version (ie with more instruments) could find a way to make it really different and why not better. But here I also disagree.
 
It is a different arrangement and well worth listening to! I'd never heard of Jon Batiste but he's a very gifted musician. I'll look him up. Thanks for sharing this.

Very many years ago when I'd just moved into my first student campus accommodation, I discovered that my next-door neighbour played guitar too. I had always been an (electric) 'bedroom lead guitarist 😉) playing along t0 rock records but my neighbour finger-picked on steel-stringed acoustic which I'd never even heard of or ever learned. We started jamming and the very first song he played/sang was "Blackbird". I was absolutely stunned by his fingerpicking dexterity and the subtle chords and changes. He later taught me how to finger-pick (and to play a lot of fingerpicking tunes too). .So "Blackbird" as a song with a simple guitar fingerpicking background is not only the 'Beatles version' but also a personal memory for me too.

From the Jon Batiste video, it's clear that the audience thoroughly enjoyed listening to this arrangement/performance (which was masterful!). Personally, I prefer a "simple" (though not easy to play!) backing. It just seems to suit the intention of the original better.
- I liked Jon Batiste's singing (from 2 mins 28) and the variation in his tempo​
- I disliked his 'intro' (up to 1 min 10 sec.) clever, competent but for me a bit too frilly/bombastic for the tune​
- I disliked his continual bass tone between 1 min 10 to 2 mins 28​
​
Here's 'Sir Paul' doing it live. For me (personal memories) Blackkbird means guitar. BTW. I've always seen 'Sir Paul" as a bass player but this video shows that he's a competent 'picker' too.
 
I disagree with your opinion Kev and much prefer The Beatles original.. sorry.
I was disappointed! Expected something great, but it's just different to me, but rather flat. The simplicity of the original is hard to beat IMHO.

Perhaps a more complex version (ie with more instruments) could find a way to make it really different and why not better. But here I also disagree.
No probs, each to their own.
 
Out of curiosity, I trawled Youtube for other arrangements/covers of Blackbird that I liked but I've not come across anything I prefer to the original or to the McCartney live.

Crosby, Stills, Nash (and sometimes Young) did a close harmony version for years but I although I generally like CSN(Y), I don't really prefer their 'harmony version' to the simpler guitar + voice. There are a lot of covers on Youtube but the only interesting (instrumental) version I came across was this one by Swedish guitarist Gabriella Quevedo.

Somehow she manages to keep the original fingerpicking, chords and "feel" of the original whilst also adding in the melody line. Yes, you miss the voice but as a guitar arrangement (and execution) it's excellent IMHO. From my perspective, she's a very talented guitarist/arranger.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,449
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom