We shall just have to agree to disagree about the suitability of the saxophone in playing classical music. I think to pigeonhole it as a an instrument only suited to playing jazz and pop music shortchanges the wonderful versatility and range of expression that is possible from this amazing invention. Not only is there a wealth of classical music written specifically for the saxophone nowadays, there are many excellent transcriptions that fit the instrument as well.
One of the first recital pieces I played as a university student was the 1st movement of the Bach A Minor Violin Concerto. Just because my chosen instrument was invented much later than the others shouldn't deny me the opportunity to express myself through all of the wonderful literature that came before.
I agree that it's very fine playing, and it's fair enough to wax lyrical about a sax ensemble playing a well known classical piece, after all it is a Sax Forum.
I am not a purist when it comes to classical music and find it interesting to hear transcriptions, in fact I have in the past arranged and recorded bits and pieces including Beethoven Violin Concerto. Chopin Piano Concerto in F Min. For Clarinet. And I learned a lot from that. I have played Clarinet professionally in Orchestras and Ensembles as a straight legit Clarinetist So my opinions re the Sax in classical Music are formed by my background. I have a feel for Jazz and the Sax to me is the natural choice to express that. I am just simply giving an opinion and putting things into perspective as I see it. I mean by putting things into perspective is when a popular piece like Barbers Adagio is used by a film such as Steven Spielberg in Platoon he will use the original composition for full emotional impact and not a Sax ensemble, no matter how well it is played.
