- Messages
- 3,431
- Location
- West Midlands
Ignore this comment, just realised you would probably be on your summer break.I can't believe your Uni has not stepped in and suggested this.
Ignore this comment, just realised you would probably be on your summer break.I can't believe your Uni has not stepped in and suggested this.
Thanks for the long and thoughtful reply! I will definitely try all of tips and advice thanks. I haven't changed any of my gear in a while so I don't think that's a cause. I do practice for long periods without drying the reed.. I've heard that saliva and constantly wet lips/chin can cause a rash! So I think I'll try sandpapering and drying the reed more frequently! Thanks again it's much appreciatedHydrocortisone or Betnovate (both steroidal creams/ointments) will clear that up in no time at all. However, you need to let the medication do its job and that means taking a break from playing. If all goes well it may be less than a week. If you're unlucky, two weeks. If you don't let it heal, especially doing 5 hours every day, it simply never will.
And once you're healed, you can then find the cause.
Are you biting?
Are you playing while rarely taking the mouthpiece out of your mouth so the reed and lip is constantly wet, causing chapping?
Is the reed too rough?
Are you playing for too long?
Is your emboucher too tense?
Are you taking too much lip over your bottom teeth?
I also suffer from sore/damaged bottom lip from time to time, too. Thankfully it's become less frequent but it still happens. Oddly enough, when I first started, I had irritation in exactly the same place as you.
For me the solutions were to not let the reed become too wet when practising for long periods of time, relax my emboucher (otherwise you're basically grinding your lip into the reed) and play with a much more 'lip out' technique. I always polish my reeds on paper, which helps a lot and I always address any soreness before it becomes a problem. Usually this is little more than lip balm and a day or two off from playing.
When I saw your pictures, I saw chapping that hadn't been allowed to heal. First the skin becomes dry. If it's not addressed immediately, that dry skin starts to itch. Once the itching starts the skins becomes red and inflamed. At this point there is no other option than to stop irritating it. The weeping you describe is the skin trying to heal.
Imagine you have an itch on your finger caused by a piece of grass tickling the skin. Rather than remove the grass you scratch the itch. And then continually scratch that itch for the next two months. You can imagine what the skin on your finger will look like. That's what you're doing with your lip. The reed is constantly rubbing the already sore and delicate skin.
When you started your BMus, did your practise regime suddenly jump from an hour or two every day to five? That's a big jump and would explain the sore lip. Continuing to play for five hours a day explains why it's not had chance to heal.
Did you go from playing relatively quietly in your practise room to regularly playing at volume with other musicians? This would also explain how the lip initially became sore. And, again, if you continued to play at volume without allowing the healing process to take its course, why it's still a problem now.
Have you changed instrument or had it checked for leaks? These may sound like strange questions but I recently changed instrument and found my new sax allowed me to radically relax my emboucher. My old tenor had no leaks yet when I went back to it I found I had to put a lot more effort into playing it. My lip is a much happier appendage now thanks purely to my new horn. 😉
Our uni years in SA are very different to European/American ones, so I'm not on break at the moment. I took a break from playing in the jazz band last week, but unfortunately my solo stuff has to go on. I'm playing a concerto in 2 weeks time so a break wouldn't be idealIgnore this comment, just realised you would probably be on your summer break.
I had your problem a few years ago. GP's and several derma-gurus didn't help 🙁I think I'll try sandpapering
So I think I'll try sandpapering
Good news indeed, and thanks very much for the updateThank you everyone for your help and concern!
You'd think that unless an allergy to reeds suddenly came on (which I've heard can happen) that another explanation is the reed company have changed supplier. Or maybe one batch of cane was different, such as they started using a pesticide. It's probably not going to be easy to say exactly what. Or it may be totally unrelated to reeds.two months ago she developed a rash below her bottom lip as well.
Thank you. Its so strange, she stopped playing for over 3 weeks and it never really went away fully. I am going to try her with synthetic reedsYou'd think that unless an allergy to reeds suddenly came on (which I've heard can happen) that another explanation is the reed company have changed supplier. Or maybe one batch of cane was different, such as they started using a pesticide. It's probably not going to be easy to say exactly what. Or it may be totally unrelated to reeds.
I would try either a different cane reed or maybe a synthetic reed as above. Alternatively have a break from playing for a week or two (might not be an option if there are exams or performance coming up).
you never know. She did have a different brand of reeds actually but it was awhile ago and its still not healing 100%.Can't do any harm of course and may work as it did for @cailinrabie
There is also nothing to lose from an allergy clinic test. My wife went for one and learned that she was allergic to birch trees and dog, something never suspected.
That could be it. But whether it is an allergy to something or else maybe just something as simple as the roughness of the grain I can't say. If it's the grain then maybe polishing that part of the reed a bit maybe by just running your finger nail back and forth could help. Or a bit of fine emery paper or whatever someone more experienced than me is about to suggest...you never know. She did have a different brand of reeds actually but it was awhile ago and its still not healing 100%.
