Playing the saxophone Avante-guard or Free Jazz

Art has a particular problem of its own - often you have no idea where or what it is and can easily find yourself being warned by security that you’re defacing an exhibit.
I walked through a load of cardboard boxes at the Guggenheim years ago, oblivious to what a wonderful art installation was before me.
“Whitewashed Wall” was also on display. My house must we worth millions…
I think it’s both cheeky and disrespectful when it plummets to these depths - and no, I’m not drawing any parallels with Free Jazz.
There is a lot of substandard music on the classical platform though. It seems that if you are “out there” enough it’s beyond being judged as a poor piece, as everyone else has a yardstick with which to be judged.
 
Last edited:
“a primary function of art is to communicate with its audience”. True enough. Sometimes the communication is “stay far away”. Many artists feel their duty is to protest and object. I think some of so-called “free jazz” falls into that category.

FWIW I don’t think any of Coltrane’s music is protest or nihilism, I do think he was on a profound spiritual quest. I can’t listen to much of it, but I think he was searching instead of making a statement. Another function of art...

I’m glad you didn’t start that clause with “the”…
 
Composers write music for different reasons and I think that is sometimes lost in the discussions on the subject. It's not always written for an external audience: some is written purely for the composers own internal reasons. That is perfectly valid.
I always think that any matter for internal reasons has to remain just that, internal. The moment it hits the public it is open to debate and criticism. Trane’s works and life have been written about in so many books and reinterpreted by the authors that noone knows what he meant for his own spiritual journey and for his audience. For the Live in Stockholm I quoted I can hear the tune, see where he’s going with it and then he completely loses me halfway. I wonder if that’s where his journey starts unaccompanied, if you see what I mean.
 
For the Live in Stockholm I quoted I can hear the tune, see where he’s going with it and then he completely loses me halfway.
I think from there 60s through the 70s there may have been quite a lot of that certain subgenre of freeform that had a tune at the begging and end, but the iipro between was free instead of the conventional chord structure of the tune.

OTOH maybe those people doing it did have the chords in their head even though to a lot of us it sounded "out" from the chords. I'm thinking of Eric Dolphy, Charles Lloyd, Joe Harriett but also various big band pieces where there was written head and then "free" sections.
 
Last edited:
When Benjamin Britten wrote a piece (I can't remember which one) which became 'popular' in the 60s he was heavily criticised for not being 'challenging' enough. His next compositions were suitably atonal and execrable.
I'd quite like to hear his execrable pieces. Could you point me in the right direction?
If only someone with a Ph.D in music analysis can appreciate your music, then I think that's just self-indulgent and deliberate elitism.
I have no music qualifications apart from grade 8 sax. I've never attended music college and my knowledge of theory is less than extensive. I don't need any of that to know if I like the sound of a piece of music. Again, if you can point me in the direction of self-indulgent, elitist music I'd be grateful. Thanks.
 
Don’t be blinded by music Ph.d’s. I know a couple of people that have a Ph.d in music and consider their grasp of harmony and composition to be relatively basic. I don’t think that they can be any way equivalent to a Ph.d in any form of science.
 
Personally, I don’t want to be conned by any of the arts. There’s much music and art that I don’t like, but still, it has required an ability greater than my own to create it.

Similarly with concerts in the big concert halls of the world - I’m disappointed if the players are of less ability than me or a mate of mine (unless you had mates like Phil Woods, Harry Connick, Roy Hargrove etc).

Jazz is less about the composition (though it can be of course) and more about the performances and contributions of the players. Classical music is about the compositions as well, because as good as the players are, they won’t be re-writing during the performance if it isn’t particularly good.

We should keep standards high. Oh, and whilst I don’t listen to his music, I’m under no illusions that me or my mates play better than Ornette Colman…
 
Last edited:
I'm about to go listen to these guys at my friend's place. My friend is a bass player and jazz teacher.

I hope the heat is not gonna be unbearable. It's almost 35°C/95°F right now and I doubt his garage/studio is air conditioned... :w00t:

I'll bring some cool white wine from Bandol for the after and plain water for the concert itself!
 
I'm about to go listen to these guys at my friend's place. My friend is a bass player and jazz teacher.

I hope the heat is not gonna be unbearable. It's almost 35°C/95°F right now and I doubt his garage/studio is air conditioned... :w00t:

I'll bring some cool white wine from Bandol for the after and plain water for the concert itself!

sounds great! Have fun!
 
I’m not sure you meant to, but this implies that all four are missing from avant grade or free form music.

Most of the "free" workshops and gigs I've taken part in did involve those elements along with at least one other I mentioned earlier, ie texture.

Granted the word "freeform" may imply there is no form, but I think that his why many proponents of the genre do not like or use that label. It can imply the worst kind of generalised caricature of the genre, ie formless cacophony. I'm not saying that doesn't exist, just that it is not really what a lot of the genre is about.

Perhaps my old "fuddy duddy" definitions can help explain where I am coming from. and the types of music I understand and prefer listening to. 😉

As I walk out of the concert hall I can remember and hum the melody of songs that were performed.
I can sit down at a keyboard and work out the chord changes that define the harmony I heard.
I can also tap the underlying recurring rhythm(s) of each piece.
I can sit down and write the form using, A, B, C, etc. to denote the sections.
I can identify the textures contained in the music as monophony, homophony, polyphony, or (ugh) cacophony.
 
Perhaps my old "fuddy duddy" definitions can help explain where I am coming from. and the types of music I understand and prefer listening to. 😉

As I walk out of the concert hall I can remember and hum the melody of songs that were performed.
I can sit down at a keyboard and work out the chord changes that define the harmony I heard.
I can also tap the underlying recurring rhythm(s) of each piece.
I can sit down and write the form using, A, B, C, etc. to denote the sections.
I can identify the textures contained in the music as monophony, homophony, polyphony, or (ugh) cacophony.
I'm not sure why you'd want to do any of that.

Edit: I should say that I can't see me wanting to do any of that. 🙂
 
Last edited:
I’m not sure that John is saying that he would do that Nick, merely that the music he prefers makes sense and fits with his lifetime of learning about the building blocks of music.

I guess it comes down to how many strands you can sever before your own taste (or sense of what is right for you) cries that it has gone a step too far.

It was one of the Marsalis brothers who had a pop at Rap music (I think it was Rap) years ago, saying that they didn’t believe that the culmination of music by Bach, Mozart, Beethoven etc etc etc was Rap.

I’m try to think of an example where I’d be counted out of standing with John in his preference, and I can’t think of one.

For me, as I’m sure it does for John, much of the enjoyment of music is hearing how a player or composer navigates their way through or “around “ the harmony; how they place their notes within the groove etc. If these elements are taken away then personally, I have less to enjoy.
 
I’m not sure that John is saying that he would do that Nick, merely that the music he prefers makes sense and fits with his lifetime of learning about the building blocks of music
Which is absolutely his prerogative. Im also a fuddy duddy when it comes to many things.

Don't get me started on TV documentaries and Police procedurals.

It's anyone's right to stick with the traditional forms
 
Last edited:
These topics are always fun for me, as a pretty much full time "free jazz" musician who's also done plenty of other music as well including straight ahead jazz and occasional "legit" work.

A couple thoughts...

As far as breaking down music into these four elements, form, melody etc... All music has that. You simply don't like what they're doing with those elements. Maybe a stupid distinction to make, but I think it's meaningful and can be telling about our abilities to engage with these concepts.

Free improvising musicians focus on these elements as much as any musicians. I mean, maybe some focus more on one than another, but generally speaking...
It's actually funny to me, if we talk about form, how much of jazz music is based on absolutely banal and utterly simplistic forms? 12 bar blues. Rhythm changes. Head solos head. This is kind of composition 101. Or intro to form if you compare it to the developments in "classical music" of the past 500 years. I'm not saying that's a bad thing, that's absolutely fine, and it functions, but talk about a glass house. I mean what is the formal justification for head, tenor solo, trumpet solo, piano solo, trading 4s with the drummer, head? There is none. It's just about giving everyone a solo. Every once in a while you might even throw in a bass solo so people can go to the bar. Perhaps if you're really adventurous someone will play an intro.
Then maybe we talk about structuring the solo, what percentage of solos have the same form, moving from simplicity to complexity then winding down? Personally, I've had far more detailed and engaged conversations about formal ideas from the free jazz side of the world than the straight ahead. I'll put it like this, I'd say 90% of the dedicated improvisers I know think of form actively throughout their performances. How many people are engaged like that while playing standards? (Sorry that's pretty reductive, but you get the point)

I could sort of break this down for each element stated but the point is, these elements are exactly what improvisers are working with every second of a performance. (I mean good, dedicated improvisers of course. When we speak of jazz in a broad sense we don't think of the worst example... we think of the ideal standard, no?)
Frankly those 4 elements aren't really enough. Timbre, as someone pointed out, density, dynamics, interplay, energy, there are so many aspects to music that can be explored if you want to get into them.

But I do think, to some extent, you need to want to like the music. It's a bit like food. If the idea of eating an oyster turns you off, if you eat one, you're probably not going to like it. If, however, you're intrigued and excited by trying something strange and disgusting, then even if it tastes strange to you, you'll try again. In the end you may not like it, but you might find it offers pleasures that you haven't ever found elsewhere. Some people want to try a raw Carolina Reaper. Or what about Casu Marzu, the cheese with live maggots in it? I tried it once, and I admit, I don't even remember how it tasted. It was kind of hard to get past watching the little dudes springing across the table. I'd definitely try it again though!
 
Last edited:
Perhaps my old "fuddy duddy" definitions can help explain where I am coming from. and the types of music I understand and prefer listening to. 😉

As I walk out of the concert hall I can remember and hum the melody of songs that were performed.
I can sit down at a keyboard and work out the chord changes that define the harmony I heard.
I can also tap the underlying recurring rhythm(s) of each piece.
I can sit down and write the form using, A, B, C, etc. to denote the sections.
I can identify the textures contained in the music as monophony, homophony, polyphony, or (ugh) cacophony.
I think it’s clear to everybody what you prefer and nobody would want to argue against it. This isn’t an us and them situation people who enjoy free music also like the things you describe, there isn’t any conflict there, you just don’t understand why people play it and don’t like to hear it.

In your original post you suggested, somewhat disingenuously I thought, that you might get some pointers to help you appreciate free music. I honestly don’t think you really want to and I equally honestly don’t think you should bother trying. Enjoy what you like and leave the rest alone.
 
Perhaps my old "fuddy duddy" definitions can help explain where I am coming from. and the types of music I understand and prefer listening to. 😉

As I walk out of the concert hall I can remember and hum the melody of songs that were performed.
I can sit down at a keyboard and work out the chord changes that define the harmony I heard.
I can also tap the underlying recurring rhythm(s) of each piece.
I can sit down and write the form using, A, B, C, etc. to denote the sections.
I can identify the textures contained in the music as monophony, homophony, polyphony, or (ugh) cacophony.
I come out of a concert 'garage' and I certainly can't do any of the above and I doubt any of the members here could. It was quite experimental and unusual.

The instruments were a Yamaha CP70, a violin and drums* all played in unusual ways with accessories. Not exactly melodies that one would follow, let alone recognize. But it was obviously coordinated and followed some patterns.

I enjoyed it despite the horrid heat and my liquid state! 😵
 
In your original post you suggested, somewhat disingenuously I thought, that you might get some pointers to help you appreciate free music. I honestly don’t think you really want to and I equally honestly don’t think you should bother trying. Enjoy what you like and leave the rest alone.
Why would you write something like that? You can't possibly know what I really want or why I started this thread. 🙁
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,171
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom