Playing the saxophone Avante-guard or Free Jazz

What I find odd is that while Ornette Coleman and John Coltrane etc. came up with free jazz it was about 60 years ago. It is still called avant garde.

But traditional jazz which became popular 1910-ish was very very old school 60 years later. So maybe avant garde or free jazz has not evolved or been superseded as far as innovation goes. Or has it?
 
Last edited:
May I start by correcting the spelling. Its 'avant-guarde'. Forgive my french!

I like to compare it with paintings. Picasso or Gauguin were and still are not always appreciated because they broke the rules and deconstructed and or rearranged the shapes, the colors in ways that were not reflecting what we see.

For music it is somewhat different as music doesn't reproduce what we hear. But we're trained or educated to listen to well polished music according to some rules established a long time ago. But these rules are often different in other cultures. So why always follow them?

Jazz broke them politely for a while, then shook them up more and more to end up with no rules in free jazz. I'm not a huge fan of free jazz but I'm open to experiments and I'm lucky to have a neighbor who organizes home brewed concerts in his garage/studio just 5mins walk from my house, so I like to go and challenge my music taste.

All of the musicians involved are TRUE musicians by the way. So I take it they are fully conscious of the many rules they are breaking.

PS: I'm on my way back from Salzburg by the way but unfortunately it was not to attend any musical event. Just plain IT work... 😉
 
All of the musicians involved are TRUE musicians by the way. So I take it they are fully conscious of the many rules they are breaking.
If they’re classical musicians then there is a very big chance that they have little clue. You can easily sit in a top orchestra and know v little of what is going on harmonically or structurally. And you don’t need to frankly. And who cares either, as it will make no difference to the performance. All the info is on every part in front of every player, and it’s pretty specific.

Jazz players, improvisers, need to appreciate what is going on beneath them far more.
 
If you're performing six or seven nights a week with the occasional matinee, churning out the same old bumph, it must be nice to get together with some skilled friends and push the boundaries to shake out the cobwebs and break free of the chains.

Me? I struggle to play nice four or five times a month. Horses for courses.
 
May I start by correcting the spelling. Its 'avant-guarde'.
Here (UK) it's avant-garde. 🙂

Anyway.

I do free stuff (as well as the usual covers band, blues, classical, etc.) and it's probably my favourite way of playing. As far as I can remember, it always has been.
Apart from solo stuff, I play in a couple of 'groups'. One is the Free Range Orchestra- a diverse bunch of musicians who improvise togeher. It's fun. The other is a duo with a drummer. Sometimes we do freely rhythmic stuff and sometimes he provides a groove. See here.
I think of myself as a mostly melodic sort of player - default mode. But i occasionally branch out into the totally bonkers school of music. Depends on my mood.
I can easily imagine that some of the stuff that's about is a bit of a hard listen for a lot of people but not all of it is noise for the sake of noise. I grew up with my brother's record collection which (after he dispensed with the Beatles) consisted of stuff by Stockhausen, Nono, Berio, Varese, Webern, Schoenberg, Berg, etc., so I was well used to the concept of music encompassing any noise you care to make.
 
Here (UK) it's avant-garde. 🙂

Anyway.

I do free stuff (as well as the usual covers band, blues, classical, etc.) and it's probably my favourite way of playing. As far as I can remember, it always has been.
Apart from solo stuff, I play in a couple of 'groups'. One is the Free Range Orchestra- a diverse bunch of musicians who improvise togeher. It's fun. The other is a duo with a drummer. Sometimes we do freely rhythmic stuff and sometimes he provides a groove. See here.
I think of myself as a mostly melodic sort of player - default mode. But i occasionally branch out into the totally bonkers school of music. Depends on my mood.
I can easily imagine that some of the stuff that's about is a bit of a hard listen for a lot of people but not all of it is noise for the sake of noise. I grew up with my brother's record collection which (after he dispensed with the Beatles) consisted of stuff by Stockhausen, Nono, Berio, Varese, Webern, Schoenberg, Berg, etc., so I was well used to the concept of music encompassing any noise you care to make.
And to be balanced, let’s not forget that many a listener think that BeBop is noise…
 
And to be balanced, let’s not forget that many a listener think that BeBop is noise…
Time to trot out my old anecdote. A girlfriend came to gig and I asked here what she thought of it. Alright I suppose but it sounded like you were making it up as you went along..

Good discussion, and where's @altissimo when you need him?

I'm trying to remember some of the workshops with Maggie Nicols and John Stevens.

One of them was something like this:

Breathe in and out, and at the end of every exhalation play a short note/sound. This created a lovely kind of sparse texture that can be tonal or atonal because you can decide in advance if the notes are random or part of a specific scale or chord.

It was quite spooky because without attempting to people often ended up synchronised and even more spooky everyone sometimes decide to just stop at the same time - as they felt a natural kind of cadence to the piece.

I did a tour of Italy with Maggie doing that kind of stuff and it went down a storm. Lovely
 
I did several workshops with John back in the day and a couple of other workshop series that were based around his Search and Reflect methods. The point in space one is weird and wonderful and the long tones one is beautiful. I think the book, Search and Reflect, is still available but you really need the group experience for it to work.
 
but you really need the group experience for it to work.

And the open mind!

I was thinking, if we ever could do another Cafesaxophone event, I'd be up for something like this.

I remember when Maggie Nicols came to do a workshop at Southampton Uni, many students were gobsmacked at how enlightening the whole thing was.
 
And to be balanced, let’s not forget that many a listener think that BeBop is noise…
John Coltrane live in Stockholm. I know it's BeBop, it's "probably" got all 5 of harmony.....to texture, but what a headache a lot of it is! It sounds like my niece, who can't read or play music, picks up my sax and starts blowing. JMO.
 
John Coltrane live in Stockholm. I know it's BeBop, it's "probably" got all 5 of harmony.....to texture, but what a headache a lot of it is! It sounds like my niece, who can't read or play music, picks up my sax and starts blowing. JMO.
And entitled we are!

I like Trane on Kind Of Blue and some other stuff, but there’s plenty I don’t like too.

In fact, the older I get, the more I switch off to “busy jazz”.
 
Free playing is about listening to and being responsive to the other musicians. You can lead or you can follow, you can, should, take and expand upon what the other musicians are doing.

I think that's at the core of what can lead it to being really exciting, those moments where "it" suddenly branches off and spontaneously finds a new groove or a different space because of some reaction or spark of an idea by the players.

That's definitely one mode I appreciate it in, the tension of the exploration, followed by the release/pay off of these really great moments.

The other would be that overall textural or sonic qualities that creates an atmosphere or vibe in the room, the abstract cinematics. I've seen/heard this being very successful when mixed with real-time electronics, especially with post-processing of the acoustic instruments.
 
I'm pretty well with @jbtsax on this one. Have my musical tastes evolved over the decades? Yes - I listen to stuff now that I wouldn't have thirty years ago. The reason contemporary 'classical' music (and especially the 'avant-garde' (I know that's not the French spelling, but it is the UK spelling!) of the period roughly 1920s to 1970s) lost all credibility is it completely disconnected itself from its audience.

In an attempt to break away from what were seen as the 'strictures' of tonal harmony, composers went off down various pathways (e.g. atonal music, serialism, musique concrète, etc) in order to be 'different'.

Jazz did something very similar.

I would suggest that a primary function of art is to communicate with its audience. The problem with a lot of this type of music is the audience is extremely small. There was a time prior to the middle of the C20th when a première of a new work was a major event that people would enthusiastically go to. Do it now and you will struggle to get anyone in the auditorium unless it's paired with something people like.

There became this reverse snobbery where if a piece was 'liked' then it was wrong. Why did mainstream composers start writing film scores or Christmas music? Because you could write tonal music and 'get away' with it and not get lambasted by the arts establishment which was hostile to anything that was not 'modern'. BBC Radio 3 under the leadership in the 1960s and 70s was hostile to composers who weren't 'modern'. English composers such as George Lloyd were ruthlessly ignored and their music not performed or aired despite being a major composer. When Benjamin Britten wrote a piece (I can't remember which one) which became 'popular' in the 60s he was heavily criticised for not being 'challenging' enough. His next compositions were suitably atonal and execrable.

There is nothing wrong with experimentation and trying something new. If the only intended audience is yourself, then fair enough. If only someone with a Ph.D in music analysis can appreciate your music, then I think that's just self-indulgent and deliberate elitism.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,173
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom