Tone or Sound Am I an atypical saxplayer ?

marc1024

Member
Messages
41
Location
Belgium
Recently I ordered 6 baritone sax hard rubber mouthpieces to try out.
The company has a policy that makes it possible to return them within 2 weeks at no cost, so I could easily test them at home instead of having a quick go at them in a music store.

I normally play the stock hard rubber Yani 5 mpc, and wanted to see if I could play on more open mpcs, so ordered all mpcs with a 7 opening.

To my surprise I it was easier to play the 7 openings than my normal 5 opening mpc.
I also got a brighter tone on mouthpieces that are supposed to have a darker sound (Meyer & Otto link)
and a darker tone on the Berg Larsen and Vandoren V16, they were louder, but still had a warm and dark bottom, the Berg Larsen was just a little bit darker than the V16, and easier to control.

I got the best sound and flexibility out of the Jody Jazz HR* 7.
Depending on the reed, I can play the lowest notes real quietly pp, and have a dark subtone sound, or a bright louder sound.
I also ordered the HR*6 as this was recommended by Jody Jazz, but I did not try it as the HR*7 played so well.

In the end, I decided to keep the Jody Jazz HR*7, as it gives me a real beautiful dark sound, and also the Berg Larsen Grained Ebonite SMS, tone chamber 2, tip opening 110, because it is really loud, but still produces a full tone with a nice bottom, not a shrill paint peeler.
What also surprised me was that I got a real dark sound with the Legere signature reeds, and a bright sound with the Legere classic reeds, I would expect this to be just the opposite.

On my Yani 5 mouthpiece I also regularly had problems with spit or condensation fluid resonating along, producing a bad sound, I have not experienced this on the more open mouthpieces.
Also on the Yani 5 mpc, my sound got worse when I played a lot, and after stopping to play for a few days, my tone was ok again, I also don't experience this with the more open mouthpieces.
 
I forgot to mention that I played them all on Legere 2.75 strength reeds.
The next step is to try out a 3 strength on my Yani 5 mouthpiece and a 2.5 strength on the 7 opening mouthpieces
 
I also got excellent results with the Jody Jazz HR*7 and Legere Signature reeds. I also played on an earlier Rousseau jazz mouthpiece that gave me the versatility to play in both a jazz and a concert band setting depending on how hard I "pushed" it.
 
One maker's 7 may be close to another maker's 5 as far as tip opening. The number designations are not standardized, so there is no straight yardstick for comparison.

According to Theo Wanne charts a Yani Rubber 5 has a .080 tip.

Jody 7* = .105

Berg = .110

You are making huge jumps there, most players would not recommend those jumps. Yes, changing reed strengths can have an effect and make the transitions smoother -
While tonality and initial blowing responses might have enamoured you, just a word of advice....don't be surprised if you are going to have to woodshed significantly with them in order to get thru an entire piece or entire set of music.

Also pay attention to possible fatigue (again this requires you play for quite a while to determine whether).

Or maybe, yeah, you are atypical :sax:
 
The advantage of ordering via a webshop that lets you try them at home for 2-4 weeks weeks gave me a much better way to evaluate the mouthpieces, than to just blow a bit in a shop to hear what it sounds like.
The reason I kept the Jody Jazz mpc is that I need to play a long delicate and long piece with a dark sound at mp sound level, so during the 2 week evaluation period, I studied this piece, and found that I could play it much better with the Jody Jazz with the .105 opening than with my usual Yani 0.080 opening.

With the Jody Jazz .105, I can play the lowest notes with a whisper silent dark sound, and I also can go through the entire piece without experiencing any fatigue, I also can put more feeling and subtlety in the melody and control the reed much better than with the Yani 5 mpc that sounds way brighter when playing at a lower sound level.

Strange, I was expecting just the opposite.

With the Berg Larsen .110 opening, I feel the fatigue when playing longer, but it is much louder while still producing a full sound, instead of sounding like a paint peeler.

The reason to make this big jump was that a friend lend me a Rico Metalite 7 and 9, and I could play both of them and get a darker/fuller sound than on my Yani 5 (the 9 was doable but there I quickly got the fatigue)
So I decided to try out a number of different mouthpieces with 7 opening and see what happens.

The same unexpected thing happened with reeds, with a classical reed, I get a brighter sound than with a signature reed.
 
Last edited:
Thanks to European law, a customer has the right to return a product from a webshop within 2 weeks after receipt a product when it you don't like it.
And on top of that, this company (Thomann) lets you return it without shipping cost for the customer if you return in 2 weeks, and also allows you to keep it up to 4 weeks, but then you need to pay shipping cost.
 
With the Jody Jazz .105, I can play the lowest notes with a whisper silent dark sound, and I also can go through the entire piece without experiencing any fatigue, I also can put more feeling and subtlety in the melody and control the reed much better than with the Yani 5 mpc that sounds way brighter when playing at a lower sound level.

Strange, I was expecting just the opposite.
It sounds to me like your embouchure had developed enough already to be able to controll the bigger MPces. So perhaps you had outgrown that yani 5......
 
I'm not sure what's "typical" but a couple of us jumped from Yamaha xC to Otto Links, discussed here, with good results.

Seems to me there are two "typical"s - those who dive into faffing with mouthpieces almost immediately and those who dive in when they're good and ready.
 
It sounds to me like your embouchure had developed enough already to be able to controll the bigger MPces. So perhaps you had outgrown that yani 5......
That may very well be the case, because my tone started to get worse (very bright) when I play a lot on the yani, and it got better again when I did not play for a few days.

My diafragm air support also got a lot better lately, I can push more air through the horn than before.

I stopped playing for years because it was too busy with work, but now that I am retired, I have lots of time to play again.

I played tenor 20 years ago and played that with a N°4 reed on a Selmer C* mpc , and now as there was a shortage of bass instruments in the concert band, I started on baritone with a 2.5 reed on the yani mpc, then went up to 2.75, and now started on the 7 opening mpc with the 2.75 reed, and it is a real improvement tonewise and also for ease of playing.
With the more open mpc, I can play really quiet, but also push it and make it bark, without having the feeling to overblow it and going out of tune when playing loud like I started to have on the yani 5.

I don't regret switching to baritone, it has such a nice sound.
 
Last edited:
Baritone is Boss.
Tenor is King
Alto is President
Soprano is a [email protected].
My first proper mouthpiece on Baritone was the Selmer S80 C*, 40 years ago. I still use it.
Everybody has a different physiognomy. (chops).
It's a common misconception that we move from a smaller tip opening to a larger tip opening as we "grow"
Mouthpieces are like shoes. You need a good fit. If you have small feet big shoes won't help.
While I'm still using a small tip opening with a hard, Vandoren 4, reed on Baritone I use a Rico 11 on clarinet and the good old S80 in a G on sop.
Whatever works is what you should use and only change when you find something better.
Having said that, I like my house slippers in a bigger size than my dress boots. Who knew boots would go with a dress? 🙂
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,684
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom