(bottom of page)
TomMapfumo
Well-Known Member
- 4,345
Hi Folks!
Further to my recent Review of £15 beginner mouthpieces I have recently been trialling the Windcraft Etude HR Alto Sax mpc (0.065") which I have been playing alongside my usual Phil-Tone/Mouthpiece Cafe/Runyon 22 suspects.
Designed by Prof. Anton Weinberg, it is based on the Meyer G (for Gregory) mouthpiece, and retails at £45 at Dawkes.co.uk - an excellent online music store.
To use the same criteria as previously I used the same reed (Rigotti Gold 2.5) and ligature (Marc Jean) and did some unaccompanied exercises as well as played a couple of tunes with backing tracks. I felt the Etude was a very high quality mouthpiece, which had a broadly mellow, yet lively tone. It could be pushed and had a pleasant brightness when needed. The tone competed well with my more expensive pieces, and was most similar IMO to my Phil-Tone Aurora, which had the NY vibe but on the darker side. I also thought that it was close to the Runyon 22 sound, but would rate it more highly, with a slightly fuller tone.
My Phil-Tone Solstice - which has the classic Paul Desmond dry vibe - outshone the Etude in terms of liveliness, mellowness and dryness. The Etude had a "wetter" sound but was very playable. The Meyer G is supposed to embody the Desmond West Coast sound, and the Etude had the mellowness, but not a very dry sound. It had slightly less volume - partly due to the smaller tip opening, but could be pushed and coped well when I played some pieces with backing tracks. It was not as bright or powerful as my Mouthpiece Cafe NYC, which is more traditional Meyer like.
Given the price (£45) I would rate it very highly. It had a very authentic American/Meyer type quality and would particularly hold its own in mainstream and related jazz, latin and similar. It had a more traditional sound and, for my money outshone the Runyon 22, which sounded marginally thinner. I see it competing well with the Vandoren V16, Meyer HR and similar pro pieces, but at a much cheaper price and with a beginner friendly tip opening similar to the Yamaha 4C/Selmer S80 C*
Highly Recommended!
Tom.
Further to my recent Review of £15 beginner mouthpieces I have recently been trialling the Windcraft Etude HR Alto Sax mpc (0.065") which I have been playing alongside my usual Phil-Tone/Mouthpiece Cafe/Runyon 22 suspects.
Designed by Prof. Anton Weinberg, it is based on the Meyer G (for Gregory) mouthpiece, and retails at £45 at Dawkes.co.uk - an excellent online music store.
To use the same criteria as previously I used the same reed (Rigotti Gold 2.5) and ligature (Marc Jean) and did some unaccompanied exercises as well as played a couple of tunes with backing tracks. I felt the Etude was a very high quality mouthpiece, which had a broadly mellow, yet lively tone. It could be pushed and had a pleasant brightness when needed. The tone competed well with my more expensive pieces, and was most similar IMO to my Phil-Tone Aurora, which had the NY vibe but on the darker side. I also thought that it was close to the Runyon 22 sound, but would rate it more highly, with a slightly fuller tone.
My Phil-Tone Solstice - which has the classic Paul Desmond dry vibe - outshone the Etude in terms of liveliness, mellowness and dryness. The Etude had a "wetter" sound but was very playable. The Meyer G is supposed to embody the Desmond West Coast sound, and the Etude had the mellowness, but not a very dry sound. It had slightly less volume - partly due to the smaller tip opening, but could be pushed and coped well when I played some pieces with backing tracks. It was not as bright or powerful as my Mouthpiece Cafe NYC, which is more traditional Meyer like.
Given the price (£45) I would rate it very highly. It had a very authentic American/Meyer type quality and would particularly hold its own in mainstream and related jazz, latin and similar. It had a more traditional sound and, for my money outshone the Runyon 22, which sounded marginally thinner. I see it competing well with the Vandoren V16, Meyer HR and similar pro pieces, but at a much cheaper price and with a beginner friendly tip opening similar to the Yamaha 4C/Selmer S80 C*
Highly Recommended!
Tom.
Last edited by a moderator:
