All profit supporting special needs music education and Help Musicians

M/Pieces - Ligs Alto Sax mouthpiece review: Windcraft Etude

TomMapfumo

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,215
Locality
Skabertawe, South Wales
Hi Folks!

Further to my recent Review of £15 beginner mouthpieces I have recently been trialling the Windcraft Etude HR Alto Sax mpc (0.065") which I have been playing alongside my usual Phil-Tone/Mouthpiece Cafe/Runyon 22 suspects.

Designed by Prof. Anton Weinberg, it is based on the Meyer G (for Gregory) mouthpiece, and retails at £45 at Dawkes.co.uk - an excellent online music store.

To use the same criteria as previously I used the same reed (Rigotti Gold 2.5) and ligature (Marc Jean) and did some unaccompanied exercises as well as played a couple of tunes with backing tracks. I felt the Etude was a very high quality mouthpiece, which had a broadly mellow, yet lively tone. It could be pushed and had a pleasant brightness when needed. The tone competed well with my more expensive pieces, and was most similar IMO to my Phil-Tone Aurora, which had the NY vibe but on the darker side. I also thought that it was close to the Runyon 22 sound, but would rate it more highly, with a slightly fuller tone.

My Phil-Tone Solstice - which has the classic Paul Desmond dry vibe - outshone the Etude in terms of liveliness, mellowness and dryness. The Etude had a "wetter" sound but was very playable. The Meyer G is supposed to embody the Desmond West Coast sound, and the Etude had the mellowness, but not a very dry sound. It had slightly less volume - partly due to the smaller tip opening, but could be pushed and coped well when I played some pieces with backing tracks. It was not as bright or powerful as my Mouthpiece Cafe NYC, which is more traditional Meyer like.

Given the price (£45) I would rate it very highly. It had a very authentic American/Meyer type quality and would particularly hold its own in mainstream and related jazz, latin and similar. It had a more traditional sound and, for my money outshone the Runyon 22, which sounded marginally thinner. I see it competing well with the Vandoren V16, Meyer HR and similar pro pieces, but at a much cheaper price and with a beginner friendly tip opening similar to the Yamaha 4C/Selmer S80 C*

Highly Recommended!
Tom.:thumb:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

TimC

Member
Messages
50
Just got myself the Windcraft Etude alto mpc a few days ago and I have to say I'm really enjoying it. I've been playing two months on a Hite Premiere that while a good improvement over the Jupiter 4C mpc that came with my Jupiter 769 sax, never made me feel quite comfortable while playing. Especially the notes from low C and below have been tough despite going at it daily.

Now playing on the Windcraft Etude it both feels and sounds better. That low B is actually beginning to be usable in songs and while tonguing I've almost stopped to involuntarily go up an octave as I did sometimes on the Hite. Overall I'm really happy with the upgrade, and it's actually quite cheap for an ebonite mpc. And good value always makes me happy! :thumb:
 

TomMapfumo

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,215
Locality
Skabertawe, South Wales
Glad you like it - it is an excellent piece, well made, and obviously plays and feels good.
Thanks for letting us know what you thought!

Kind regards
Tom
 

Popular Discussions

London
Paris
New York
Los Angeles
Sydney
Moscow
New Delhi
Top Bottom