Kentishsax
Member
- Messages
- 14
- Location
- Kent
Hi all
My private student is learning alto sax from me and they were asked to join their school band. I looked over the sheet music they've been given and it's for a brass band, for Eb horn (ie, in British terms, Eb tenor horn, a saxhorn). So they can play the sheet music because of course it's for Eb instruments but it's mostly very low notes and if one's sax isn't sealing well, those lower notes are hard. They have their own sax but use the school's in band and it sounds from their description that it probably hasn't been serviced etc. for yonks.
Anyway, the teacher has just scribbled through a bar to remove them here and there and just said 'play that', without thinking about how that messes up the bar lines and not advising on if rests are required or play through etc. I tried to take them through the part (which is not very good in all honesty) but not seeing the conductor's copy, I don't know how it should fit in. This is their first attempt at playing in an ensemble (other than playing along with me in lessons) and I am concerned that this poor experience is going to turn them off. They are playing a Christmas concert in the next few weeks - I think they need to pull out or get teacher to actually explain but 'they don't have time'...
My private student is learning alto sax from me and they were asked to join their school band. I looked over the sheet music they've been given and it's for a brass band, for Eb horn (ie, in British terms, Eb tenor horn, a saxhorn). So they can play the sheet music because of course it's for Eb instruments but it's mostly very low notes and if one's sax isn't sealing well, those lower notes are hard. They have their own sax but use the school's in band and it sounds from their description that it probably hasn't been serviced etc. for yonks.
Anyway, the teacher has just scribbled through a bar to remove them here and there and just said 'play that', without thinking about how that messes up the bar lines and not advising on if rests are required or play through etc. I tried to take them through the part (which is not very good in all honesty) but not seeing the conductor's copy, I don't know how it should fit in. This is their first attempt at playing in an ensemble (other than playing along with me in lessons) and I am concerned that this poor experience is going to turn them off. They are playing a Christmas concert in the next few weeks - I think they need to pull out or get teacher to actually explain but 'they don't have time'...
Last edited:

