Playing the saxophone Alto Sax Student Playing In Band

Kentishsax

Member
Messages
14
Location
Kent
Hi all

My private student is learning alto sax from me and they were asked to join their school band. I looked over the sheet music they've been given and it's for a brass band, for Eb horn (ie, in British terms, Eb tenor horn, a saxhorn). So they can play the sheet music because of course it's for Eb instruments but it's mostly very low notes and if one's sax isn't sealing well, those lower notes are hard. They have their own sax but use the school's in band and it sounds from their description that it probably hasn't been serviced etc. for yonks.

Anyway, the teacher has just scribbled through a bar to remove them here and there and just said 'play that', without thinking about how that messes up the bar lines and not advising on if rests are required or play through etc. I tried to take them through the part (which is not very good in all honesty) but not seeing the conductor's copy, I don't know how it should fit in. This is their first attempt at playing in an ensemble (other than playing along with me in lessons) and I am concerned that this poor experience is going to turn them off. They are playing a Christmas concert in the next few weeks - I think they need to pull out or get teacher to actually explain but 'they don't have time'...
 
Last edited:
If it were the Salvation Army, then I would understand why their music is scored for brass. 😀 (However, I wouldn't be bashful using say my bari to play a baritone bass clef horn or 4th bone part (add 3 #'s and play bass clef as treble) or say 3rd or 4th trumpet on the soprano. Traditions are made to be broken.) :sax:

In the military reserve and community bands, when we were short on alto sax parts, I've played the Eb alto horn part; short on tenor sax parts, played the Bb Baritone treble clef part.

Simple solution is if practically too low for the alto sax, then transpose an octave up?

I guess one thing you may be able to do, is contact the music instructor, maybe tell him or her that you want to help their student better their musicianship, and get further information into their program? 🙂
 
My take is that the scribbled out measures would be rests for the saxophones. In other words, stop playing and listen - and count!
It could be, but one of the original founders (I believe) of the Clovis Community Band had his signature marks on the conductor's score, which made it challenging for anyone else who tried to use the score, some in red magic marker markings, scribbled all over.

Plus I have encountered where a previous person in the seat marked up a sax part to where it was hard to read. (like learning to use the changed key signature instead of boldly annotating each note, especially running notes in a passage in ball point or felt tip pen, impossible to erase.) Where a previous conductor changed a few things, had measures marked out that should have only been done in pencil and lightly at that, because it was a one time thing for a particular performance.

So, short of the person present to do the markings and if the student did not understand, then it is easy to speculate.

Not saying you are wrong, but a few times I've run into what I assumed, and after asking, found a totally different story.
 
Marking parts in anything other than #2 pencil is about the worst violation of musical etiquette there is.

If those were rented parts for musical theater, you'd be charged triple cost for every part with an indelible mark.
 
Marking parts in anything other than #2 pencil is about the worst violation of musical etiquette there is. If those were rented parts for musical theater, you'd be charged triple cost for every part with an indelible mark.
True, but not all think as you and I. A while back, I remember my high school renting Bye, Bye, Birdie. What impressed me was usage of odd key signatures with notes scored as double sharp, double flat, etc.

(Not with rented orchestral parts), while at home, I have scanned an awefully marked part in permanent ink and using photo editing software, removed markings restoring the original print, so I could simply read the part. Then included the clean copy during folder turn-in so the next time, a player could properly play the part.

With older scores in a band's music library, may be long out-of-print so that one cannot even obtain replacement parts anymore.
 
Curious as to why they need or choose to use the school horns instead of their own. What bars are being scratched? Are they using flex band material?
The parents don't wish the sax to be damaged. I do have an example in an old student from years ago, took their sax to school and someone booted it in its case across the playground (and threatened with a knife).
 
Marking parts in anything other than #2 pencil is about the worst violation of musical etiquette there is.

If those were rented parts for musical theater, you'd be charged triple cost for every part with an indelible mark.
The teacher had scribbled it out in green biro. The parts were photocopied, not originals.
 
I think i was quite clear...
Well, I've been speaking English for 60+ years and reading it almost as long and it certainly wasn't clear to me.

Are you asking "should the student skip over the stuff that's scribbled out, or just lay out?"

If that's what you're asking, clearly the most likely answer is that the instructor intended for the student to just lay out on the bits that were scribbled across. But it is POSSIBLE that the entire ensemble is making a cut there.

And it doesn't matter whether it's a Xerox copy or an original, you DO NOT write on parts in ink. Special instructions change - cuts, lay-outs, etc.
 
The parents don't wish the sax to be damaged. I do have an example in an old student from years ago, took their sax to school and someone booted it in its case across the playground (and threatened with a knife).
That would be a good reason, but very much a shame and would make me a very frustrated parent. Schools would probably (I'm guessing) not care for their inventory like an individual would. So, your student uses his/her own sax while learning from you but then switches to the school horn for their band? Would that make it more difficult to learn the instrument?

What is the lowest note in the score(s)? Without seeing it, I would agree with ghostler to bump those notes up an octave or to the middle register. If it is flex band material, there are probably parts 1 through 3 available that might make it easier for the student.


By the way, a hearty welcome to the cafe!
 
Well, I've been speaking English for 60+ years and reading it almost as long and it certainly wasn't clear to me.

Are you asking "should the student skip over the stuff that's scribbled out, or just lay out?"

If that's what you're asking, clearly the most likely answer is that the instructor intended for the student to just lay out on the bits that were scribbled across. But it is POSSIBLE that the entire ensemble is making a cut there.

And it doesn't matter whether it's a Xerox copy or an original, you DO NOT write on parts in ink. Special instructions change - cuts, lay-outs, etc.
What is your problem, dude? I was NOT asking anything, I was reporting on this ocurrence. Of course not lay out but ASK the teacher to make it clear. And it was the teacher who scribbled out in ink, NOT my student. Chill out, for goodness sake.
 
What is your problem, dude? I was NOT asking anything, I was reporting on this ocurrence. Of course not lay out but ASK the teacher to make it clear. And it was the teacher who scribbled out in ink, NOT my student. Chill out, for goodness sake.
Two people here, one known native English speaker/writer, and one who probably is, told you your first post was unclear. It seems probable that it was unclear.

Don't be that guy that can dish it out but can't take it.
 
I think i was quite clear...
I haven't replied here because I am also unclear whether there is a specific question that we can answer apart from generally commenting on how bad it is to put indelible markings on music parts.

I do agree it sounds like poor experience but are you able to give your private student advice on how to diplomatically find out what they are supposed to do? But again, I'm unclear how we can help beyond agreeing with you: "I think they need to pull out or get teacher to actually explain but 'they don't have time'..."

The teacher doesn't have time to explain so your advice is for them to pull out of the concert. I would try to find a more positive solution - perhaps if you could provide images of the scribblings we'd be better informed.
 
Yes, oft it is easy to assume by "reading between the lines", but I have learned over time that there is usually more to a story than expressed. After further research, have found that what was initially assumed with limited facts is only partially true.

True evidence of a truth speaks clearly, so yes, even a sample of the alleged mark-ups would help the rest of us, as we are completely clueless, not being there to observe.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom