- Messages
- 3,431
- Location
- West Midlands
The point is if we look at the pictures our eyes don't lie, there are cosmetic flaws, and the Yamaha 280 is they're so called starter horn, but it is not cheap to buy new at not far off £900/1000 GBPs
Or how about....
The Thomann 580 is in the post.

Looks ok. The big issue we should be focusing on is matching abalone cufflinks.Ah , OK. Basically a Yamaha copy. Oh the irony!

Half the price and better quaity. Oh the irony indeed.Ah , OK. Basically a Yamaha copy. Oh the irony!
I'm not so sure, Colin. I've had 4 saxes from thomann, and 1 was sent back straight away. 1 of them should have been sent back but I "fixed" it myself. The thomann BariPro is excellent as was the Taiwanese made thomann Mk4. My YAS 285 is built like a tank and would destroy any of my other saxes in a fight, including the yanis. I would not bet any money on a thomann being better quality than a 285. It might play and sound great (I hope so!), but better quality? Nope.Half the price and better quaity. Oh the irony indeed.
Love the descriptions! Do you mean fussy or fuzzy? The TJ Raw has a different bore. Whilst some like the warmth it can sound indistinct or wooly. If you can find the early examples of Phil Veacock demoing the Raw, it doesn't sound that great IMHO.I have an Elkhart 2. Quite nice under the fingers but dull as dull.
Jupiter? A bit like having a top of the range moped.
I don't like TJ horns. They're reasonably wel made but the sound is fussy.
Chinese horns have come a long way since they started in the 80's. If Selmer can find a factory to turn out their horns, so can others.
Thomann gear seems reasonably priced and reliable. If it's cr@p it can go back.
