Saxophones Alto quandary.

I've seen loads of these and not seen one with those flaws before. I assume it's stock images - it is unlikely to be pictures of the horn you receive.
It's £890 from Sax.co.uk - a reliable site that will, I expect do something about it if the horn isn't right. With distance selling laws you have the right to return it - regardless. If you buy from abroad I'm not sure if you have the same rights(?)
 
Last edited:
Reputation is yesterdays horn. If the build quality slips what are you buying for a premium price? I don't want to play postal ping pong till a decent one turns up. Sure I won't get the one in the pictures. However that's the one they chose to use for promotion purposes.

I'm sure the ali express horns were proffered tongue in cheek.

My G4M punches way above its weight but I don't know where to get another.

The Startone Bari is turning heads and ears and feels great. Why wouldn't I consider their alto?

I've had many dealings with Thomann and never been disappointed.
30 day no quibble return policy, 3 year guarantee and way cheaper than any one here.

Spare parts? The only spare parts for a saxophone I've needed is pads and springs. I'm not resurrecting anything. Just wear and tear from my own use.

The Thomann 580 is in the post. Due any day. Fingers crossed.

I'm in the mood for an Egg Foo Yung now. 😉
 
I think Colin may have been put off TJ by his shocking Artemis?
I've played two RAW altos... One shockingly bad after a shop overhaul at MIR Walsall (NOT Connolly or Sheward MIR), the other a brand new one I bought which played well but did nothing for me.

I'd have thought someone of Colin's ability would have bought a good used horn, knowing how to spot one, but sometimes car troubles and finances can conspire to push toward the mail order/instalment retailers.

It's easy for me to say I often pick up great used horns for 1/3 of typical used prices but it takes time, commitment, and cash in hand to pounce.

If he's got by and got gigs with a G4M for so long Colin may be one of those few players who can sound great on anything. Paying big bucks if you have that talent is still worthwhile in terms of longevity and reliability. I should have tried harder to find him a great bargain. That 880 looked good but he's not a Yany lover.
 
Took the Startone Bari to an open mic in a Burnley restaurant on Sunday. Sing for your supper. Pulled pork burgers and lentil curry. Mmm

I also got the Thursday Tapas gig.
5 courses £16 at the Loom and me for pudding.

The G4M will be with the Canal St stompers tomorrow night at the Railway in Sale. 😉
 
G4M are available from their website - Gear4Music.com

Artemis isn't a Trevor James horn. It comes from the same company but is made in China whereas TJ branded instruments are probably Taiwanese made. The standard is much higher with horns bearing the Trevor James name. You can pick up a good The Horn Revolution on Ebay for about £350. Great horn for the price.

The other brand I'd look for is Jupiter. The 500 is OK but the 769 is a better blow. Second-hand you can pick them up for a fair price.

I'd recommend second-hand if you're looking at the cheaper end of the market - which I'm assuming is the case looking at cheaper horns. You get more for your money though you have to check condition and might need a few adjustments. Horns like the Elkhart series II aren't made any more so you'd have to go second-hand if you wanted one of those.

Buying new you shouldn't have issues with Yamahas. The pictures aren't great but I can say I've never seen one like that - adn I've seen a lot of them. It is unlikely to have to be returned -especially if you buy from a saxophone shop who'll check the instrument over before sending. Generic music shops will just send you something in the box. Even then, I would still favour brands like Yamaha above others. If you have concerns over the finish then talk to someone at the shop and insist the sax is examined prior to dispatch.

Yamaha finish tends to be much better than others, like Trevor James who have had issues with their Raw finish and lacquer on silver plate and nickel. TJs are still good horns. Jupiter horns can have a lot of blemishes after a few years. Jupiters are still good horns.
 
I have an Elkhart 2. Quite nice under the fingers but dull as dull.
Jupiter? A bit like having a top of the range moped.
G4m changed suppliers. The one I have is 11 years old and no longer available.
I don't like TJ horns. They're reasonably wel made but the sound is fussy.
Yamaha?Maybe but too dear for what they are.
A Yani would be lovely but would need a second motgage.
I have reservations about a second hand horn. Anything in my price bracket is either ancient or unloved. Maybe I'll get something vintage to do up later.
Chinese horns have come a long way since they started in the 80's. If Selmer can find a factory to turn out their horns, so can others.
Thomann gear seems reasonably priced and reliable. If it's cr@p it can go back.
I just wish the postman would come. :sax:
 
Half the price and better quaity. Oh the irony indeed.
I'm not so sure, Colin. I've had 4 saxes from thomann, and 1 was sent back straight away. 1 of them should have been sent back but I "fixed" it myself. The thomann BariPro is excellent as was the Taiwanese made thomann Mk4. My YAS 285 is built like a tank and would destroy any of my other saxes in a fight, including the yanis. I would not bet any money on a thomann being better quality than a 285. It might play and sound great (I hope so!), but better quality? Nope.
 
I have an Elkhart 2. Quite nice under the fingers but dull as dull.
Jupiter? A bit like having a top of the range moped.

I don't like TJ horns. They're reasonably wel made but the sound is fussy.

Chinese horns have come a long way since they started in the 80's. If Selmer can find a factory to turn out their horns, so can others.
Thomann gear seems reasonably priced and reliable. If it's cr@p it can go back.
Love the descriptions! Do you mean fussy or fuzzy? The TJ Raw has a different bore. Whilst some like the warmth it can sound indistinct or wooly. If you can find the early examples of Phil Veacock demoing the Raw, it doesn't sound that great IMHO.
They do, of course make different model and they do sound different to each other.

Yes, Selmer use Chinese factories to make their new Elkharts. They arent' a patch on the old Elkhart series II. Build quality is still variable. It's a bit of a lottery with Chinese horns. It's things like the springs and screws that can be iffy. The cheaper ones still seem to cut too many corners. The better made examples, like the Thomman, tend to be a surer bet. I hope it is good for you.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,709
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom