Saxophones Alto quandary.

Zoom in close with the pictures, you will see defects in soldering.
or is this it?
1645297262316.webp
 
It's not like the pictures g4m or thonmann show are of The instruments in stock. They're adverts. The photographers, who presumably do all the products, have no idea. The same instruments - most likely chucked out of the same factories by the dozens - look different on all the big-box sites.

Obviously it was the blue touches that CtB got gooey-eyed about. Who wouldn't?!
 
Last edited:
I nearly went for the hand made but it's matt copper and a bit fussy.

Maybe the bell brace joint is reflections but the LowC key is definitely bent and some of the pillar bases would be acceptable on a £250 copy but for something that retails in other shops over £1k it's a real off put.

Nit picking but it's a fair chunk of money for me and if this is the best one they've got to photograph for promotions, I'm out.
 
It literally looks like a cat pissed on the bell (outside only) and not just once 😎
I'd put the scruffy sax up against any specimen. One of the touches is actually as shirt button. Mind you, i did tidy up all the felts and corks myself, so some improvement.

Oh and "butt ugly but a great player" could be any of us except me; I'm not a great player.
 
Last edited:
I'm rather saddened by this thread. It's fine starting on a cheap horm but when you move on shouldn't it be to something better? Actively searching for some non-manufacturer brand isn't much of a step-up.
The Atremis mentioned originally are pretty variable with some shocking build quality. I wouldn't go near them. But then the Elkhart series II gets a thumbs down which is of a much higher build quality than most of the cheapo Chinese horns. Maybe the tone isn't to everyone's taste but they are a far better bet then some copy of a dodgy website.
Then we get criticism of Yamaha due to some supposed flaws spotted. Huh? They are a proper manufacturer with a longstanding reputation for building instruments to a consistanly high standard. Again the tone isn't to eveyone's taste, but these are reliable instruments with some level of customer service.
Buy an El Cheapo brand and they wont' have any spare parts. You don't know where it was made or what the level of quality is. Yet you're looking for those horns rather than the globally recognised industry standard Yamaha?

There are plenty of good horns out there. But the cheapo market is still a bit of a lottery. Some of the main manufacturers have put their beginner instruments into this category by having their starter horns made in China (like an Elkhart, for example - nowhere near as good as the Taiwanese Elkhart series II. )
I think there is still some merit in buying from a known brand. How about Trevor James, for example? They've been making some decent equipment for years now.

If you want a decent reliable horn Trevor James, Yamaha, Yanagisawa are good places to start. And not from Aliexpress !!!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,709
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom