Saxophones Alto quandary.

This was a Chinese sax I had in recently. This is supposed to be a good one sold by one of out big sax shops that prefered this make to Walsteins. It felt rather uncomfortable in the hands and then I realised the thumb rests were out of alignment. They should be roughly in line with each other, but here the lower one is way off to the right.
It's got palm keys that are cut to a really sharp point which can result in cut fingers.
The pads are set with a seat that goes far into the pad.
It's these sort of things that steer me away from Chinese makes.
P1310202b.webp
P1310213b.webp
 
This was a Chinese sax I had in recently. This is supposed to be a good one sold by one of out big sax shops that prefered this make to Walsteins. It felt rather uncomfortable in the hands and then I realised the thumb rests were out of alignment. They should be roughly in line with each other, but here the lower one is way off to the right.
It's got palm keys that are cut to a really sharp point which can result in cut fingers.
The pads are set with a seat that goes far into the pad.
It's these sort of things that steer me away from Chinese makes.
View attachment 19766View attachment 19765
Wow. That thumb hook is one of the worst things I've seen on a sax recently. Horrendous.
 
Years ago I spotted a Jollysun in a Cash generator. I had my mouthpiece with me and gave it a try. 😳
No sale.
I'm driving a Ford focus. The same company that made the Edsell and other lemons.
You can't judge an orchard by one apple. 😉
DHL says it'll be here monday. :thumb::yess:
 
I must be missing something. What's so terrible about the one in the picture ?

On my tenor the RH hook lines up roughly with the right edge of the LH thumb rest and that's very comfortable for me.

Rhys
It's just too far round to the right. Your thumb digs into the sharp edge. It's very uncomfortable. I've never had a sax that felt so uncomfortable.
 
You can't judge an orchard by one apple. 😉
What, like thinking all Yamahas are bad based on one set of photos ? 😉

I've seen and tried a lot of different instruments. I remember the early days of Ebay when there was just 5 saxophones on there. Then we had an influx of brightly coloured saxes and all sorts of brand names cropping up. I had a Bently which was a British brand/import. Some of those were OK - some were dreadful. I got a Bauhaus Walstein on the basis of good reviews. Mine had loose keywork, as many did. It was also loose on the octave mechanism that made it unreliable. I had to swedge it was extremely difficult due to the extra hard brass. I sold that one on and got a el cheapo sop which plays as, if not better than the Walstein. It had some flaws like the bit under the octave key is solder on upside down. The octave key wasn't on straight. I tried to ease it over to where it should be and it fell apart, so I had to hard solder it back together.
Walsteins are out of business now. It seems they couldnt' get the quality right. Fix one problem and another would crop up. They tried and tried to get the consistency people demand and failed.
Yamahas were made in Japan. Now they have moved into getting instruments made in Indonesia and China. The quality isn't always as consistent as it once was.

You can get some decent Chinese instruments. I've seen them. But the quality remains variable - even in good ones. Some will be good with a few tweaks. Others can verge on being unplayable.
 
Well...it's arrived.
First impressions were not good. The box is battered and has been opened and sealed with Thomann tape. Opening the box, there's very little packing. Some crumpled paper is all. Inside the case the body is wrapped in popped bubble wrap.
Removing the horn from the case reveals an undamaged instrument. Phew! Credit to DHL and maybe the case. It's a fabric covered job with permanent back pack straps and zip closure. Fit's the horn good but I'm not 12.

Nice sling in the case with a carabiner style metal hook. Large and small microfibre pull through and a cloth. Two Thomann reeds. Cork grease. Two BG patches and the ubiquitous white gloves.

The mouthpiece has an interesting single screw lig that I may investigate later.

The bell keys are wedged shut with blocks of cork that will come in handy later.

Assembled the horn, greased the neck cork and fitted the soloist.

First blow took an hour and a half. I couldn't put it down. Palm key feet will need recorking to better fit my needs but apart from that everything is where it should be and it plays great.

The pads seem a little firm but maybe only compared to what I'm used to.

The upper register is very sweet. The lower register isn't as full as I'm used to but got better the more I blew it. The bell notes subtone easily and are very rich. The action is nice under the fingers and responds quicker than I can.

I've checked it all over and can't find a thing wrong. It seems well put together.
I think with time I should be able to make it sing.

I'm not in love but it feels like a useful tool. Strangely I still have alto GAS. 😳
 
First blow took an hour and a half. I couldn't put it down. Palm key feet will need recorking to better fit my needs but apart from that everything is where it should be and it plays great.
Glad your first impressions of the horn are good. I've used Thomann many times and always had good service.

I'm considering one of their own brand sopranos, possibly one of the handmade models or the TSS-380.
 
I've got that "I wonder what the startone is like?" feeling. :rolleyes:
Go for it Colin. If it's not costing you any more money. and they allow it Why not try as many as you would seriously consider.
We always advise people to try before they buy after all.
Quietly wondering why this one didn't come first seeing it's so close to what you are used to.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,707
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom