Saxophone beginners Advice on embouchure, please

I'm still working on my embouchure and making some progress I think. I've tried many of the suggestions and so far, I've found the 'lip out' techniques works best in principle. However, I still find myself slipping back to biting my my bottom TEETH (won't make that mistake again!) I got a trumpet mouthpiece from kind Tom and I finally produced a sound from it yesterdy. I've also put a sticky pad thing on top of my mouthpiece, which I've discovered is a Yamaha 5c - so I'm not going to bothr getting a 4c now.

Still a long way to go but I feel I'm definitely getting better, so thanks for all the advice guys.

Philippa
 
One thing that does not appear to have been mentioned (forgive me if I'm wrong, I'm a newby to the Forum), is the scraping or sanding of reeds to suit your present embouchure. I have always bought reeds of a higher grade than I require, namely a 3. This grade will not allow me to blow low notes comfortably (sometimes even D is a struggle). I then carefully scrape the reed using a Stanley blade (normally fifty strokes a side), before trying it to see progress. I continue with this, and gradually the notes come in one at a time until finally Bb arrives. Always work towards the tip, but staying well away from it. Never remove material from the thick part of the reed, always the sides. Practice makes perfect!
The way I see it, why struggle. I believe this method allows the embouchure to develope naturally over time, and is an aid to producing good tone and vibrato at an early stage of a career.

johnboy.
 
This sounds like the hard way of doing it. There is no doubt that for some learners the lowest notes are hard, but for others it is the high notes. I happened to find the low notes quite easy, but I really had to practice on the high ones (Eb to F#). Daily practice (lots of it) fixed the problem.
 
The hard way? - I don't know. It takes time to get the reed to the right strength for playing, yes, but it will be exactly the right strength.
Top F# or bottom Bb. I would have thought that if it was a reed problem (too soft or too hard), starting from too hard and reducing the strength, would still be the solution.
Practice? even the best of us need lots of it, but let's make things easy for ourselves.
Thanks for your comment, let's hope we can get a lot of response!!!

johnboy.
 
Hi Philly123, A trick I found very helpful after I had been playing for a while was to play "Happy Birthday" on the mouthpiece only. You do this by placing a finger in the sax end of the mouthpiece and moving it in and out, while increasing and decreasing pressure on the reed with your bottom lip, and slide to the right notes.
If you saw my reply about softening reeds, I should clarify it. If you hold the reed up to the light, you see the hard center of the reed forming a bullet shape. Put the reed on a flat surface and remove material from the side towards the hard center, BUT NOT FROM IT! A movement from the edge towards the tip sweeping in to the front of the bullet shape is correct, but don't go near the tip.
You will find as you get the hang of it, you get more working reeds from a box.

johnboy.
 
Sorry Johnboy,

I'm still not convinced that scraping the reeds is a useful passtime - it gives you a good insight as to how the reeds work, and into what makes a good reed, but it's equally possible to just find a brand/cut/strength that suits. Surely if a 3 is too hard, and you have to shave it down, maybe try a 2.5?? Reed manufacturers have decades worth of experience of shaving reeds, so I defer to their superior knowledge.
The way I see it is if you're a recent beginner you've got more important things than learning to shave reeds to worry about, like reed and ligature position/tightness, plus all those pesky fingerings!

Once you've got past this stage you can probably play on most of the reeds in a box. I've recently been using Legere Signature and Hahn synthetic reeds for my playing work, but I've found that I can also use every reed in a box of La Voz or Vandoren V16. It's true that some reeds will last better than others, but my experience of shaving reeds is that that it reduces their longevity anyway.

Good luck with all of this, readers!

Nick
 
Thats fine guys, I'm saying what has worked for me over the years. That's the way my music teacher taught me in 1953 and it certainly helped me. I never ever struggled with embouchure. Tone and vibrato were easy to achieve, and as this happened I found that reed strength increased. For years now I have played Hemke 3 scraped until bottom Bb comes singing in without loads of puff.
As I said this is what worked for me, and nothing is lost by trying it and perhaps everything to gain.
It takes me on average, about an hour to get a reed playable to my satisfaction.
Let's not forget that the Forum is here to provide ideas that may help others. We are all different!
P.S. I had learned the recorder first, a good starting point for any would be saxophonist (the basic fingerings more complicated)!

johnboy.
 
I read Johnboy's comments with interest. Many of the greats, Stan Getz for example, used to adjust their own reeds.

There's a really interesting book on it 'The Saxophone Reed', by Ray Reed. It's on amazon. Probably a lot more in it than many people want - and it takes some reading.

Makes a lot of sense to me to start with a 3 and shave it a little until it plays the way you want it to. If you started with the thickness you wanted, then it'd be too thin when you finished.

I'm going to be trying it - soon, but I'm pressed for time at the moment.
 
Hi Kev, It realy is worth trying, I call it fine tuning. Being involved most of my life with quality assurance, my credo is "Near enough isn't good enough!"
By the way folks, can we stick to the subject. This thread was started by a lady in pain. She sounds as though she needs all the advice she can get.

johnboy.
 
Hi Johnboy,

I've been playing sax for 16 years, and I was shown a few reed scraping techniques by my teacher at school - not till I was a competent player though!

All I was trying to say is that while all reeds are not perfect, and while scraping the reeds can undoubtedly improve matters, modern manufacturing methods and quality control (unless you buy the cheapest brands) will mean that someone at the beginning of their playing career shouldn't have to worry about such an advanced technique.

I think that while you develop an embouchure (or any new skill) you're a bit like a child learning to draw - it's easier at first to use a big sheet of paper and a crayon held in your fist, you wouldn't use A5 lined notepaper and a fountain pen! To switch metaphors, if you learn to drive in an automatic car you aren't allowed to drive a manual, whereas the opposite is not true. If you learn to drive in a lovely big mercedes it will be difficult to drive a clapped-out fiesta, whereas the opposite is not true.
If you learn to play on any old reed, when you then learn to scrape the reed to the perfect quality for your embouchure you will produce a great sound. I believe that the opposite is not true.

I think (hope) from the comments in this thread that Philly123 is on the way to sorting out her embouchure now. I just thought it would be best to try to head off beginners like her reading this thread from diverting attention from the real business of learning the sax!

Thanks, great point, and yes, we should perhaps start a reed-scraping thread to discuss the merits and pitfalls!

Nick
 
Hi Nick,
I,m sorry if I came across a bit strong.
Reading through the replies, I think we all need slapped wrists. Not one of us has asked Philly the strength of the reed she is using!!! It might be a good idea if teachers make sure that the reed strength matches the mouthpiece, and that the student is comfortable before beginning any tuition. Philly certainly needed this kind of attention.
Yes I agree, that a thread about scraping reeds would be a good idea. You know that I only scrape to soften the reed untill all the notes come in.
I have read that you can produce a reed to suit different music styles, by scraping different areas of the reed. Any experts please respond.

johnboy.
 
Hi Johnboy,

I've been playing sax for 16 years, and I was shown a few reed scraping techniques by my teacher at school - not till I was a competent player though!

All I was trying to say is that while all reeds are not perfect, and while scraping the reeds can undoubtedly improve matters, modern manufacturing methods and quality control (unless you buy the cheapest brands) will mean that someone at the beginning of their playing career shouldn't have to worry about such an advanced technique.

I think that while you develop an embouchure (or any new skill) you're a bit like a child learning to draw - it's easier at first to use a big sheet of paper and a crayon held in your fist, you wouldn't use A5 lined notepaper and a fountain pen! To switch metaphors, if you learn to drive in an automatic car you aren't allowed to drive a manual, whereas the opposite is not true. If you learn to drive in a lovely big mercedes it will be difficult to drive a clapped-out fiesta, whereas the opposite is not true.
If you learn to play on any old reed, when you then learn to scrape the reed to the perfect quality for your embouchure you will produce a great sound. I believe that the opposite is not true.

I think (hope) from the comments in this thread that Philly123 is on the way to sorting out her embouchure now. I just thought it would be best to try to head off beginners like her reading this thread from diverting attention from the real business of learning the sax!

Thanks, great point, and yes, we should perhaps start a reed-scraping thread to discuss the merits and pitfalls!

Nick

I think that this just about sums it up.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,434
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom