Advice needed for breathing problem

Hi everyone!

it's been a while since I last posted so I'd better just mention that I've been playing tenor for about 15 months.

I'm getting on fairly well but my big problem is breathing.....
I have read all the stuff about using the diapragm, good posture etc and try to follow this, but I am still having problems.

It seems as if I'm running out of oxygen before I run out of air. I have to breathe the last bit out before I can breathe in again.

Does that make any sense?

Am I taking too much in or something??

Any comments gratefully received!

Thanks
 
Sounds like you are topping up the air in your lungs without getting rid of the oxygen-depleted air - inevitably this means you end up with lungs full of useless air - you need to breathe out more completely between gasps for fresh breath - or put another way maybe try playing more notes until you take another breath. Also try looking ahead at the music and deciding in advance where you are going to take breaths. Good luck. Pete
 
I know the feeling, Col9 and I are currently playing the bass line from Peter Gunn on Baritone and its a continuous repetition thoughout the piece, really drains the blood from the head!

18 Bars of the same riff followed by two bars with two short notes then back to 22 bars of the same riff.

Brings a whole new meaning to "Last Man Standing"

My practice has taken on a whole new slant, playing conservatively and even contemplating circular breathing, making darn sure my nose is clear!
 
A useful exercise, as Peter suggests, would be to mark breathing spaces on any piece of music in pencil and see whether that is the pattern that works for you, or needs adjusting, so that you can find an appropriate gap (be it 2 bars, 4 bars or whatever)

Also try an exercise where you hold a note for, say, 8 beats then have a 4 beat pause to breathe, then a further 8 beats and so on (at something like 60bpm). Then shorten the gap to 2 beats; then one beat (using a metronome) - the purpose would be to discipline a sharp intake of breath. At stage 1 (4 beat gap) breath out for 2, and then in for 2 etc. It should help you remember to breath out as well as breath in.

It is easy to get tense about breathing, so you may benefit from some structured exercise, and then just get on with it.

Kind regards
Tom 8)
 
I have to say that, if I don't practice on a regular basis, then my breathing is the first thing to suffer. Last year, when went on my holiday for three weeks, I left my sax's at home, I suffered terribly when I got back and my band had a gig the week I got back. This year I took my tenor with me (bearing in mind, I holiday in a caravan) and entertained the campsite with my busking set, to an occasional round of applause! (And no complaints :laugh: )
I think that practice is the only way to build up the strength in the diaphragm. Remember to use your stomach muscles as a support too.
 
Thanks guys!

Pete - I think you've hit the nail on the head. Looks like I'm topping up and not letting the used air out first.
Thanks for pointing me in the right direction!

Tom - I like the exercises. Might help me to remember to breathe out! Thanks.

And thanks to Pjonah and Taz for their encouragement!

Pauline
 
Hi Pauline, I've been playing the tenor for about 15 months also, and am also having the same problems, in fact I was about to ask for advice, but you have done it for me, so I ditto your thanks to the others who have given useful advice.
Sometimes I feel I have run out of breath, when I haven't run out of air in my lungs, so i have to breath out, and then inhale again.
I tried not taking in so much air before starting to play, and then i do run out of breath!!
Oh well, practice, practice, practice.
 
I had the same problem (less so now).

Agree with the comments on topping up, exercises, being more relaxed. All were relevant to me.

I went as far as to try this thing. I think it maybe helped me to get stronger at quick intakes of breath.
link


However my teacher condemned it as the device of the devil and said breath exercises and long notes would work just as well.

And I looked damn silly driving to work with a white plastic dildo-shaped device in my mouth.
 
Jadoube wrote:
I had the same problem (less so now).

Agree with the comments on topping up, exercises, being more relaxed. All were relevant to me.

I went as far as to try this thing. I think it maybe helped me to get stronger at quick intakes of breath.
link


However my teacher condemned it as the device of the devil and said breath exercises and long notes would work just as well.

And I looked damn silly driving to work with a white plastic dildo-shaped device in my mouth.

I like it, well I would being a Diabolist! well not really.....or not at all.

Nice idea though, do you just walk around with a regulator like object stuffed in yer face? Keeeewlll
 
Basically yes.

You adjust the resistance in the tube so it takes a bit of extra muscle to breath through it. You then take about 25 cycles of fast intake, slow letting out of breath. Takes a few minues each day. Every so often you increase the resistance.

Like everything the trick is getting in the habit of doing it every day.
 
Pauline wrote:
.

Does that make any sense?

Am I taking too much in or something??

Any comments gratefully received!

Thanks

Hi Pauline,
Just a thought, have you ever tried to study whats actually happening as you breathe?

Using the lower part of the lungs is not that natural during everyday breathing, at least in the context that you need when having a decent start to each playing breath.
There is an artical in Larry Teal's Art of sax playing that will at least help you decide if you are breathing correctly.

In brief, its along the lines of suggesting you lay on the floor (face up - no sax) with a book on your stomach. As you start to breathe, your goal is to fill the area of your lungs closest to the book, which, in turn means you'll see the book raise in the air before the air you're taking in, fills the upper portion of your lungs. This gives you a genuine lung full.
As you exhale slowly and controlled for an even release of air, the diaphragm control is being executed. once you are used to it, stand up and try it with out the book. Then move on to doing it with the sax.

Well it feels pretty awkward at first but it will become more natural each time you use it.
Good luck!
 
Pauline wrote:
Hi everyone!

it's been a while since I last posted so I'd better just mention that I've been playing tenor for about 15 months.

I'm getting on fairly well but my big problem is breathing.....
I have read all the stuff about using the diapragm, good posture etc and try to follow this, but I am still having problems.

It seems as if I'm running out of oxygen before I run out of air. I have to breathe the last bit out before I can breathe in again.

Does that make any sense?

Am I taking too much in or something??

Any comments gratefully received!

Thanks

Hi Pauline

I have exactly the same problem. However, it only happens in the first few minutes of playing. My breathing becomes normal after i have warmed up myself.
 
Thanks everyone!

PeeDee - sorry you are having the same problem but glad I am not alone! Let me know how you get on.

I have been doing TomMapfumo's exercises and also thinking about my breathing when doing scales. I'm trying hard to use my stomach muscles to push out the last bit of air and putting more thought into where to breathe in music pieces and it seems to be helping.

As Peedee says - practice, practice, practice!
 
Surely breathing should also correspond with the phrasing of the piece being played particularly if the phrase is to be played legato.

It is a mistake to think you take a breathe and then not take another one till that has run out. Look at the music if there is a natural break in the phrase refill with breathe. And make it a big one. Keep you lungs topped up as you go. If you don't you will lose tuning, note quality and projection of sound.
 
Just try to keep your lungs fully inflated.

Hopefully you are breathing out through your instrument rather than blowing it. That is the difference between using your diaphram and stomach muscles and not your throat.

Then when you get a chance replace what you have expelled. Try listening to a singer on a Cd. Maybe an opera singer. Assess when they take a breathe.

Another thing you could do to prove the point to yourself is this.

If you have a chromatic tuner blow the tuning note and keep playing a long note and watch what happens to the note as your air pressure decreases. Now play a long note only this time breathe when you need to keep the note constant.

a lot of people i hear play do not take in enough breath. It takes a lot of puff to blow a wind instrument. So take in a full lungful. Your chest should expand (so to speak)then control the out flow with your diaphram.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom