Saxophones 2022 Selmer Supreme

Seriously, the law of dimishing marginal retruns once you get beyond the level of a good sax like the AW01 means the additional benefit of spening a load more is tiny.
Not quite. Though I agree with your intuitive take on the "law", to be pedantic...

It would say - so far as anything in economics is a 'law' - that the additional returns on only improving the sax (a factor of production), without improving other things, reduce. So, given a budget, it should probably be split across all the factors - MP, reeds, lessons etc. If sound production is your issue. Maybe you should split the budget to cloths and a haircut if looking good is your issue. Or buy two sold instruments if it's reliability...
 
Last edited:
I could not afford one anyway but was just trying to understand where the extra £1500 was justified, especially when a solid silver Yani would not cost a lot more!
I guess if it is a limited edition there is collector's value in there.
Selmer has been around a long time, so if they come up with something like this (after their other limited edition offerings) they must be pretty sure someone will buy it.
Will it be "better" than anything else out there? No, just different.
 
From a Tech I know : “From 1990s onwards the newer the Selmer the more time the tech spends on it to set it up or to set it right.” Does it mean anything? YMMV. Mine is a quasi new Jubilee model. Nice tone. Very Selmer. Haven’t had any big issues but it definitely took a lot of time to set up properly. Weak soldering is one problem I’ve encountered. Fixed with Loctite superglue. I know, right. And the blue steel pins are set too hard ex-factory. Pads take a loooong time to settle. Once properly set up, plays like the best of ‘em. Selmer is now majority owned by a hedge fund who are not unknown to major cost-cutting and profit maximisation.
It's easy to hire a "product styling" firm and change some appearance items, charge a bunch extra, and sell a small quantity to "investor/collector" types. However, it does nothing to advance the product, either in its design or its quality. It's a good indicator of a company that has lost interest in the product and is just trying to wring as much out of it as possible before tossing the dried husk to the next private equity owner.

Meanwhile, Yamaha engineers continue to study all the weak points of the product's design with an eye to eliminating them, while they also study first pass yield, warranty returns, and long term durability results for continuous product improvement, and they also study all their production processes to improve yield and reduce cost.

Which company would you bet on for the long haul?
 
It's easy to hire a "product styling" firm and change some appearance items, charge a bunch extra, and sell a small quantity to "investor/collector" types. However, it does nothing to advance the product, either in its design or its quality. It's a good indicator of a company that has lost interest in the product and is just trying to wring as much out of it as possible before tossing the dried husk to the next private equity owner.

Meanwhile, Yamaha engineers continue to study all the weak points of the product's design with an eye to eliminating them, while they also study first pass yield, warranty returns, and long term durability results for continuous product improvement, and they also study all their production processes to improve yield and reduce cost.

Which company would you bet on for the long haul?
I agree with you but Yamaha have done limited editions too, based mainly on cosmetics.
 
Selmer these days seem to be obsessed with a sort of "art for art's sake" approach to design. I keep seeing odd little features that make me think "Why would anyone do that?"

Here's the auxiliary B key on a Jubilee alto.
On most horns this key would feature a split barrel; a barrel at one end of the key, a separate key in the middle (B) and a smaller barrel at the other end. On this horn they've done away with the smaller barrel.
What this mean is that support has been removed from the regulation bar that runs along the rear of the stack keys - and support means stiffness. The stiffer your keys are, the less they will flex and the more accurate the regulation will be over a prolonged period of time.

I've seen this design on sopranos - and it works reasonably well because the keys are so small...and it's often the only way to cram that bar into a modern soprano top stack. But why would you put it on a larger horn?
The extended, unsupported bar is going to flex more and the stress from the A key when playing a C is going to induce wear at the end of the aux.B barrel.
OK, you get a longer first barrel on the aux.B - but there are other ways they could have had that without losing the secondary barrel.
Just seems...odd.

Selmer SA80 II Jubilee aux b.webp
 
That's just the name of one of the upper stack keys. The point is that the rear regulation bar, which should be supported at both ends with an arm (unless there's truly no way to shoehorn it in) is only supported with one arm, and is cantilevered off that. That's just bad mechanical design and there's no excuse for it. First rule in mechanical design is if it's working fine, don't mess with it.
 
In the original post we are asked to consider spending up to £9,000 on a saxophone.
If it makes your heart sing: then buy it!
I'm a biker, for 45 years my inflexible rule has always been 'my bike is the most expensive vehicle I own'. So if the car cost more than the £7500 my big Harley cost used I didn't buy it.
If your car costs more than your sax you are doing it wrong.
Let me recommend 20 year old Mercedes Benz E Class cars as being spectacularly good value. Don't worry about the mileage, in the owners manual it says "Consider an engine rebuild at 250,000 miles."
And you can still get cheap parts from Germany.
My last car? A 1967 Morris Minor bought for £1500. Sold it 5 years ago, now car-less and back to being a proper biker again.
(seriously considering getting a really nice curved soprano!)
 
What's an aux B? I have a B and one an octave above is there something that nobody's told me about?
It's the little key just above the B key (usually hidden away under the front top F touchpiece).
Pressing the B or A keys brings it down - and on some horns (particularly sopranos) it's also linked to the octave key mechanism.
 
C# is vented through that tone hole, right? the uppermost one on the top stack?

This is why when I get into specifying tone holes I either note which note vents through it, or its position on the stack, or which finger operates it. Most people call the left hand ring finger "the G key" but the note that's vented through it is A; whereas most people call the RH little finger upper key the "Eb" key and the note vented through that tone hole is Eb (or, one could think of it as D# because it's a normally closed key).

Point being that there are different nomenclatures, but the note that's vented through the tone hole is invariant.

So while Theobald Boehm solved a lot of problems for us, his design of having a finger operate a normally open pad located far away from it has made labeling more complicated.
 
In the original post we are asked to consider spending up to £9,000 on a saxophone.
If it makes your heart sing: then buy it!
I'm a biker, for 45 years my inflexible rule has always been 'my bike is the most expensive vehicle I own'. So if the car cost more than the £7500 my big Harley cost used I didn't buy it.
If your car costs more than your sax you are doing it wrong.
Let me recommend 20 year old Mercedes Benz E Class cars as being spectacularly good value. Don't worry about the mileage, in the owners manual it says "Consider an engine rebuild at 250,000 miles."
And you can still get cheap parts from Germany.
My last car? A 1967 Morris Minor bought for £1500. Sold it 5 years ago, now car-less and back to being a proper biker again.
(seriously considering getting a really nice curved soprano!)
I too am a biker but despite the Ducati Panigale making my heart sing I find that no saxophone is worth that amount. Everything is relative or YMMV.
 
I too am a biker but despite the Ducati Panigale making my heart sing I find that no saxophone is worth that amount. Everything is relative or YMMV.
£21K for the cheapest Panigale. Fancy an Eppelsheim Tubax?
My present to me on that day I get really good on my soprano sax will be an Eppelsheim Soprillo. Costs about the same as the upcoming 70,000 mile top-end rebuild and go-fasters on my Hardley will.
Choices. Careful and heart-warming choices.
 
My favorite hobby is sailing, but I have managed in the past to sail on other people's boat. Some in a range I will never ever be able to afford! 75' racing maxis, even pre-owned, even from the 80s are not within my budget...

Thank God, I am old now and do not fancy such a huge boat. I can't afford the crew to run it.

So a 40'-50' would probably do just great. But that's a touch more expensive than the horns I play. Even accumulated!

Then, I'm a touch more 'delicate' with my taste of sailing boats than I am so far with horns. So I'd be looking for a 'classic' (vintage) 50' Italian wood build from the 60s or 70s... Sailing MUST be done in style.

Italians are masters in that exercise. But there are some very good French boats built in that period too.

The only things standing between that dream and reality are my wife and kids! 😳

The kids are a question of time. A few more years and they'll be gone. Or at least I do hope so.

But the wife is a more complex matter! Always has been... But I may not be an exception at that. :rolleyes:
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,420
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom