Tech/maintenance YTS 280 Bad alignment?

@PigSquealer yes I work on my own cars, random question.

@SimonHoward I bought a yamaha on their reputation for quality & reliability, in truth only comparing one other other much cheaper tenor. I expected central & even pad placement as a fundamental given from yamaha.

From the experienced people replying it seems my expectations were/are too high.
Random question about the cars. I ask this because of mechanical exposure. You understand what you’re looking at but not to this environment. Your expectations were set high without complete knowledge. Nothing personal.

The Yamaha 23,26,28 product line are intermediate / beginners saxophones. They are made extremely durable and play well even after years of abuse. The metals, engineering, quality of the pads, corks and finish are all part of the quality. Did you know they are not lacquered? The finish is a clear epoxy. Extremely durable to rough handling. Yamaha takes pride in their instruments looking well for a very long time.
As a father who participated with a daughter in band. You would be amazed what kids do to these instruments. Not once in seven years did I see a Yamaha go in the bin. On the other brands, how many parts horns would you like. Some parents purchased three to one YAS/YTS.
Your 280 will bring you years of enjoyment.
 
@PigSquealer yes I work on my own cars, random question.

@SimonHoward I bought a yamaha on their reputation for quality & reliability, in truth only comparing one other other much cheaper tenor. I expected central & even pad placement as a fundamental given from yamaha.

From the experienced people replying it seems my expectations were/are too high.
If your YTS 280 was sold to you with some keycups off centered the folks on the factory have failed. But also the shop where you bought your sax. Lack of quality work. Sometimes it happened that a new sax was not not in good selling condition when it came to shop. But all saxes were "made ready" for the buyer and that included inspection of the keyscups and pads. We could have saxes in stock for 1-2 years before they were sold. A shop with a tech can fix this easy but there are shops without techs.

Today a new YTS 280 is nearly 16 000 s e k here in Sweden. A G4M tenor is 4000 s e k!
 
Random question about the cars. I ask this because of mechanical exposure. You understand what you’re looking at but not to this environment. Your expectations were set high without complete knowledge. Nothing personal.

You're exactly correct, no offence taken, I'm a mechanical engineer by trade.

If they get back to me I'll post yamaha's repsonse.
 
@SimonHoward I bought a yamaha on their reputation for quality & reliability, in truth only comparing one other other much cheaper tenor. I expected central & even pad placement as a fundamental given from yamaha.

From the experienced people replying it seems my expectations were/are too high.

If pad centrality is your benchmark you might find it tough going to find a manufacturer who meets your expectations. Simply put, the sax isn't a particularly precise bit of kit. In fact I don't think I've ever seen a new horn that would meet such standards - at any price. No matter how well you jig up the parts for assembly, there will always be the need to make adjustments to suit the individual instrument - and when you start moving keys around you're going to change the geometry.

Here's a selection of keys from a YTS61:

keycups.webp


None of them have perfectly centred pads - and yet they've been working just fine for at least the last 50 years. Now that's what I call reliability.
There are many, many things that a prospective purchaser of a horn should be aware of in terms of build quality - but pad centrality comes pretty low on the list. Probably just above the size of the accessory compartment in the case.

Incidentally - It's Stephen, not Simon.
 
I would just add that if you want to move a key cup to correct an off center pad and the existing pad has an indentation or "seat" it is usually necessary to replace the pad. I have had moderate success heating a pad slick and ironing the leather to be "flat" once again, but to get a perfectly seated pad it is usually better to start with a fresh pad.
 
I would just add that if you want to move a key cup to correct an off center pad and the existing pad has an indentation or "seat" it is usually necessary to replace the pad. I have had moderate success heating a pad slick and ironing the leather to be "flat" once again, but to get a perfectly seated pad it is usually better to start with a fresh pad.
Trouble is, it rarely irons the felt beneath the leather - unless you get the thing unfeasibly hot (which then shrinks the leather). It looks good, but it hides the real story.
More often than not I find that the time spent trying to coax an old pad into a revised seat costs more than replacing the old one.
 
You're exactly correct, no offence taken, I'm a mechanical engineer by trade.

If they get back to me I'll post yamaha's repsonse.
Just think of it as wherever a pancake hits the plate. It tastes the same. If it’s off the edge of the plate it could break. The chances of the key cups being aesthetically in line are more likely. I don’t think I’ve heard of anyone complaining about that one.
 
If yamaha can't manage to get a pad bettter centred than this, then buying a yamaha for the quality is out of the window for me.


Well, if it really annoys you, and triggers OCD then return it to Yamaha, as it is a slight imperfection in manufacturing. I thought they had at least a 2 year warranty (if not 5 year)

But I thought buying a saxophone was to enjoy the music. As long as the instrument does what its designed to do, why worry?

PS: I have many variations in Alto and Tenor to play on from my collection including the famous Selmer MK VI. Which Alto do I pick up and play the most? The YAS-62II (with a G1 neck).

Happy playing
 
Ok but if it were any worse then the resonator would catch on the tonehole. What if replacement pads have larger resonators & they do catch on the tonehole??

If yamaha can't manage to get a pad bettter centred than this, then buying a yamaha for the quality is out of the window for me.

Thanks for all the responses, I've contacted yamaha directly to see what they've got to say.

The resonator is NOT catching on the hole - hence it is within the intended design limits. If you replace it with a larger resonator, YOU are exceeding the limits. Ever notice that they are often called “oversized” resos?

If you are an engineer, you are familiar with the concept of robust design. The product functions as intended even with small variations in manufacture. If it didn’t pass a play test after assembly, it would have gone through rework.

I guess we’ll see if Yamaha explains that the same way. It’s no mystery to me.
 
With the Yamaha's long posts on the low C and low E flat keys it is difficult, when the key is closed, to get both the pads centered to the tone hole and the key cup parallel to the tone hole. For a good seat I would prioritize parallel above centered..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom