Playing the saxophone Worst sax playing on a classic rock song?

Was that Bowie? He was quite the patron of Mott The Hoople at the time and, of course, wrote "All the young dudes".

Bowie, genius that he was, could be like chalk on a blackboard from time to time. Even his solo at the end of "Walk on the wild side" threatened to go off the rails at any moment.
From what I can find, Andy Mackay played tenor sax on the album. He went on to be founding member of Roxy Music. Andy MacKay Wikipedia
 
Bowie, genius that he was, could be like chalk on a blackboard from time to time. Even his solo at the end of "Walk on the wild side" threatened to go off the rails at any moment.

Er, I'm confused.

The great baritone sax solo on Walk on the Wild Side was played by my hero Ronnie Ross. Ronnie gave saxophone lessons to a very young David Bowie. Bowie produced Walk on the Wild Side and brought Ronnie in to play that iconic solo.

Rhys
 
I just want to say. The thread "Worst sax playing on a classic rock song" doesn't feel right for me, Everyone that is playing the saxophone, on different levels and styles, have my heart. I'm not the right guy to judge. Let's talk about the good saxes on rock songs.
 
In defence of the Baker Street riff; it's very recognisable and not that hard to play
well recognisably. Better to learn that than twinkle twinkle little f'ing star.
I’d put them about equal in regard to ease of playing. And importance to be able to know and play.
 
Well, blow me down with a feather; for the last 45 years or so, I have been labouring under the misunderstanding that Bowie had played that solo.

We live. We learn.

I've just found this video with Bowie talking about the sax solo and Ronnie Ross - straight from the horse's mouth.

View: https://youtu.be/8vIGla8YrWs

And here is the solo. Surely an example of a jazz saxophone great playing his own thing on a "rock" song and making an iconic solo that works memorably.

View: https://youtu.be/oG6fayQBm9w?t=215



Rhys
 
I just want to say. The thread "Worst sax playing on a classic rock song" doesn't feel right for me, Everyone that is playing the saxophone, on different levels and styles, have my heart. I'm not the right guy to judge. Let's talk about the good saxes on rock songs.
I think that that is a pretty reasonable standpoint; it is easy to throw stones from within glass houses.

Moreover, I guarantee that the next time I come within a mile of a rolling tape, I will be able to take that bar a notch lower.
 
From what I can find, Andy Mackay played tenor sax on the album. He went on to be founding member of Roxy Music. Andy MacKay Wikipedia
Interesting how there is no mention on Andy’s website of his time with MTH !

Was MTH a steppingstone for the band members? Bad Company was definitely better. Roxy Music had a good run. Just not my cup of tea.
 
Interesting how there is no mention on Andy’s website of his time with MTH !

Was MTH a steppingstone for the band members? Bad Company was definitely better. Roxy Music had a good run. Just not my cup of tea.
Andy MacKay's contribution to MTH was done after Roxy's inception (if memory serves). And I will refrain from criticism of MacKay because Roxy Music were a formative influence on me.

I've been avoiding this thread because it reminded me of the type of sax playing that I loathed in my youth. But there were so many British players of that era who played on pop and rock sessions who really could play:- Mel Collins, Ken Fordham, Dick Heckstall-Smith, Dick Morrisey, Ronnie Ross, John Helliwell and on and on, so many good players. That's English saxophone!

But, yes there were some pop performances that stank. I particularly hated the sax solos from the New Romantic era:- Haircut One Hundred, Spandau Ballet etc. These were played by band members, just kids with no proper tuition and no embouchure to speak of. When you compare their playing to, say, young players who really could play, like Chris Hunter, Chris White, Will Gregory or our illustrious @Pete Thomas - or those from the USA who were coming out of the music colleges there who just had access to great players who taught - it's just plain embarrassing, and I accept no arguments about 'naïve energy' being more important than good technique - there were some really bad players and some gruesome solos.

Mostly their problems as sax players were to do with lack of good teaching: i.e. lack of knowledge of playing through any changes at all (never mind Be-Bop), lack of aural perception of pitch and intervals, and undeveloped embouchures. But put a kid who owned a saxophone in a Band with a record contract in the studio in the 70s through the 80s, and that was what you got. Fortunately there is much better tuition now and some stunning players coming up, even if there are no longer the same avenues for employment.

I am reminded of a story from my own youth when after playing and overdubbing on 4 tracks in one session for some demos I did in the early 80s (no real sweat since I had written the music), the engineer said he was impressed because a particularly famous solo of the time had taken 2 days to complete 8 bars.:rofl:
 
I'm more a Rock & Roll Saxophone enthusiast than Rock Sax enthusiast. The afro-american roots are important. Blues, Jazz, R&B, Country, Rock & Roll, Soul .... In many Rock songs , with sax, the afro-american roots are way back. But good sax players in the European Rock as well.

Here is a YT clip with the freelancing windwood instrumentalist Uffe Andersson (RIP) that was playing sax with ABBA. Listen to how he became ABBA's sax player and also the difficulties the be playing sax in cold places and to warm-up behind stage with jazz when ABBA performed on the stage ... .
View: https://youtu.be/Ec-4dGmBOxY
 
Last edited:
This is a very strange thread which I have just scanned for the first time so I'll just say that, for me, it's the sax break that makes Baker Street, the song and vocal are pretty banal but the sax lifts it and makes it special. Simple and effective, all you need.
 
This is a very strange thread which I have just scanned for the first time so I'll just say that, for me, it's the sax break that makes Baker Street, the song and vocal are pretty banal but the sax lifts it and makes it special. Simple and effective, all you need.
I also think this as well, take the sax out of the song and it wouldn't have been so iconic, the sad thing was that Raphael Ravenscroft got a small fee for his work and Gerry Rafferty was getting £188,000 a year royalties out of the song.
 
the sad thing was that Raphael Ravenscroft got a small fee for his work and Gerry Rafferty was getting £188,000 a year royalties out of the song.
That's how the music industry is working. Lee Allen (tenor) and Alvin Tyler (baritone) played on lots of recordings Little Richard, Fats Domino ..., and their saxes made huge impact worldwide, didn't get any royalties. They were paid per hour as session musicians.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom